Bye Corbyn!
#1
I did find this a pretty amusing read:

https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/jer...6.html?amp
Reply
#2
Bit off-brand for the Independent!

I was a massive corbynista who agreed with pretty much all of his policies but even I agree that in the end it was all a bit of a waste of time. I find the concept of "electability" annoying as everything should be about policies but this is the world in which we live unfortunately and the reason Labour lost (IMO). Say what you like about Blair, he and his team would've swatted away the mountain of smears levelled at Corbyn with far greater efficacy and that is a more important political skill than coming up with good policy in this day and age.

Anyone but RLB next please as she'll be the exact same.
Reply
#3
(03-27-2020, 07:51 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Bit off-brand for the Independent!

I was a massive corbynista who agreed with pretty much all of his policies but even I agree that in the end it was all a bit of a waste of time. I find the concept of "electability" annoying as everything should be about policies but this is the world in which we live unfortunately and the reason Labour lost (IMO). Say what you like about Blair, he and his team would've swatted away the mountain of smears levelled at Corbyn with far greater efficacy and that is a more important political skill than coming up with good policy in this day and age.

Anyone but RLB next please as she'll be the exact same.

I wasn't a Corbynista, but given his rivals for the leadership job in 2015 he was the right choice. But he had massive flaws, he wasn't a very good politician , his immediate circle of advisers were a drag on the party, he wasn't astute enough to deal with day to day problems (Brexit, anti-Semitism issue spring to mind). He has a glorious isolated moment of brilliance the 2017 election campaign, but failed miserable to capitalise on the gains made by Labour .

On RLB she is a far better politician than Corbyn, she would be the wrong choice in this election, for the reason that those advisers close to Corbyn are backing her and I think would still have a malign influence on the party if she became leader. Lose this leadership election and lose them, next time round she may be an excellent choice,
Reply
#4
(03-27-2020, 07:51 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Bit off-brand for the Independent!

I was a massive corbynista who agreed with pretty much all of his policies but even I agree that in the end it was all a bit of a waste of time. I find the concept of "electability" annoying as everything should be about policies but this is the world in which we live unfortunately and the reason Labour lost (IMO). Say what you like about Blair, he and his team would've swatted away the mountain of smears levelled at Corbyn with far greater efficacy and that is a more important political skill than coming up with good policy in this day and age.

Anyone but RLB next please as she'll be the exact same.

Say what you will about Blair, but he would have eviscerated the Tories at the last election. For Corbyn to put up such a weak opposition against that shower is criminal.
Reply
#5
(03-27-2020, 07:51 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Bit off-brand for the Independent!

I was a massive corbynista who agreed with pretty much all of his policies but even I agree that in the end it was all a bit of a waste of time. I find the concept of "electability" annoying as everything should be about policies but this is the world in which we live unfortunately and the reason Labour lost (IMO). Say what you like about Blair, he and his team would've swatted away the mountain of smears levelled at Corbyn with far greater efficacy and that is a more important political skill than coming up with good policy in this day and age.

Anyone but RLB next please as she'll be the exact same.

Even Blair would have struggled to fight off the type of character assassination that Corbyn had.

"Electability" is a real issue for Labour now, Starmer who is favoured by many is easy to pin as 'London-centric', RLB is a Corbynista and a woman (sad but true - I don't trust this country anymore). It's a really big choice for the next Labour leader.

What's worse is the amount of favour the Tories are going to glean from putting into place measures that a Labour Government would see as standard.
Reply
#6
(03-27-2020, 09:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: What's worse is the amount of favour the Tories are going to glean from putting into place measures that a Labour Government would see as standard.

It does stick in the craw somewhat that they're getting praise for enacting Labour policies! I see Tory voting relatives on Facebook posting about how the NHS needs more money and that the govt should look after people who lose their jobs. Yeah no shit. Vote for it then next time!

Agree with whats been said about Corbyn and I realise I'm pissing in the wind but it does annoy me that any of that is relevant. It should just be "here are the policies I intend to enact" vs "here are the policies the other lot intend to enact". 

I'd slightly favour Starmer just because I think the Mail/Express types will like the fact he's a 'Sir'. "oooh, the Queen must like him"  Rolleyes Rolleyes
Reply
#7
What’s really galling is seeing Tories clapping the NHS workers these are the same people that have either been part of or voted for auaterity for a decade. Let’s not forget in 2017 Tory MPs cheered the defeat of a bill to raise doctors pay in the Commons.

Starmer is the only one who is a credible alternative to this government.
Reply
#8
"Corbyn hard left playbook" - which policies in the most recent manifesto do you consider 'hard left' and if so, why is that a bad thing? Really struggle to understand how people can think he was 'dreadful'. Ineffective in the current (shite) trial-by-media system that we have maybe.

"myth as is that Tories are anti NHS" - I assume you've seen the recent recap video from 2017 (I believe) of Tory MPs cheering as they blocked a pay-rise for NHS and emergency workers. They've also criminally underfunded it for the past decade. You can't just whitewash the past 10 years and say that Johnson will be somehow different as if he wasn't part of it all. They've suddenly found money now that it's become necessary.
Reply
#9
Post-election I was listening to an interview with Blair: his analysis was that when you're in government the public are subconsciously comparing you with their own idealised image of what the perfect government might look like; inevitably the incumbents fall short of the mark.

Come an election and this line of thinking is discarded; the electorate then begin to compare the government with the available alternatives. That's why (his view at least) unpopular and incompetent governments can often get re-elected. I think he probably had a point.
Reply
#10
(03-27-2020, 11:30 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-27-2020, 10:28 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: "Corbyn hard left playbook" - which policies in the most recent manifesto do you consider 'hard left' and if so, why is that a bad thing? Really struggle to understand how people can think he was 'dreadful'. Ineffective in the current (shite) trial-by-media system that we have maybe.

"myth as is that Tories are anti NHS" - I assume you've seen the recent recap video from 2017 (I believe) of Tory MPs cheering as they blocked a pay-rise for NHS and emergency workers. They've also criminally underfunded it for the past decade. You can't just whitewash the past 10 years and say that Johnson will be somehow different as if he wasn't part of it all. They've suddenly found money now that it's become necessary.

I think it's a myth that any party does not want the best for the country (employment, society, NHS) achieved in the manner they think is correct and sustainable - even Cameron/Osbourne with austerity believed somehow it was necessary and good. I don't see BJ as ideological as them, just my opinion on him, but yes he was part of the party that did it. I think you are mistaken if you do not see Corbyn and Momentum as hard-left influenced, particularly in foreign policy where he is like some student radical still, attacking the US whatever (and the UK to a degree, particularly MI5), praising the likes of Iran and Hamas, attacking what he calls 'Zionists' and using it as a pejorative term, creating a climate to drive Jewish Labour members who have fought for the Labour cause all their lives out of the party.  So yes, for me, absolutely dreadful, and potentially dangerous to national security if he had got in. Regarding economics, I would be in favour of much of what was proposed, though all at once would be unaffordable and unrealistic and hopefully was just electioneering and would not have been attempted. But it made the whole thing look false on top of 4 day weeks suggested etc. Certainly railways for me were always natural monopolies and I am anti austerity and pro more government intervention and investment in a successful mixed economy. But I would not attack all institutions on ideological grounds or approve of language of class warfare, demonising all the wealthy etc which seemed to me to be a characteristic sometimes of Labour under Corbyn - this also did them no favours. Society is very different to the cold-war post WWII he first became radicalised in and I still do not think he has noticed. The perpetual idealist student agitator - not a political leader.

Extreme circumstances have seen the current government have to change tack on public spending, it’s not their default position. Ten years of cuts, the new government ideologically entrenched in Brexit and now Covid 19. Let’s remember that most spending was only to bring levels of policing, NHS staffing etc  to levels they had been before the slash and burn austerity years.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)