So...possibly us and Leeds promoted
#51
The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.

Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.

Winners

1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.

2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.

3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.

Losers

1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.

2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?

As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.
Reply
#52
(03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.

Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.

Winners

1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.

2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.

3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.

Losers

1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.

2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?

As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.

I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones.  As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them.  Can’t think of any other way.  Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable.  Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.

With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away.  An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone?
Reply
#53
(03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.

Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.

Winners

1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.

2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.

3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.

Losers

1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.

2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?

As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.

I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones.  As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them. 

Much less of a fuss with the play-offs in terms of fairness and legals.  Given there is no certainty for any of them to have finished in those spots, the legal case would be "interesting" and it might be that a share of the pot would be a proportionate remedy to an unprecedented situation.  Plus, fuck 'em!
Reply
#54
SSN poll shows 52% in favour of the dildo brothers scheme.
Reply
#55
I'm calling this now. 

The Premier League will scrap everything and say fuck off to us and Leeds. They will look after themselves and they will get no objection from any Prem side will they? Why would they.

The rich get richer and us and Leeds get screwed. Legal claims will fall on deaf ears as its an unprecedented scenario and the counter argument will be "you weren't mathematically certain of being promoted".

Both us and Leeds have had 5 to 7 game spells without a win and that could well be used to say it could have happened again before the season was out. 

Sorry to be doom and gloom but I just don't think the Premier league give a shiny shite about us and Leeds.
Reply
#56
It's only an opinion- mine at that(!); but maybe we should just finish the season however long it takes. The loan, player contracts business will have to be dealt with but that surely cannot be beyond possible? Scrap the euros, finish the season, then make plans for what happens next time out.
Reply
#57
(03-15-2020, 02:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I'm calling this now. 

The Premier League will scrap everything and say fuck off to us and Leeds. They will look after themselves and they will get no objection from any Prem side will they? Why would they.

The rich get richer and us and Leeds get screwed. Legal claims will fall on deaf ears as its an unprecedented scenario and the counter argument will be "you weren't mathematically certain of being promoted".

Both us and Leeds have had 5 to 7 game spells without a win and that could well be used to say it could have happened again before the season was out. 

Sorry to be doom and gloom but I just don't think the Premier league give a shiny shite about us and Leeds.

That also means giving two fingers to Liverpool too and I'm not sure that will happen.
Reply
#58
(03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.

Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.

Winners

1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.

2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.

3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.

Losers

1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.

2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?

As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.

I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones.  As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them.  Can’t think of any other way.  Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable.  Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.

With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away.  An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone?

Rangers had the chance to join the PL when they were made to start in the Scottish third division. They could have bought into non-league in England and within 8-9 years have been pushing for promotion to the Prem... instead they decided to spend 5 years trying to get back to the top of the SPL and the easy route to Champs League riches. There should be absolutely no shortcuts, if either tram want it, they do it the same way everyone else has to.

I don’t want either Rangers or Celtic in the English league as not only will it be two bigger clubs to compete with should we ever try and win a cup or push for one season in Europe, but also the fans are absolute scum bags best kept well away from our towns and cities.
Reply
#59
(03-15-2020, 02:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: It's only an opinion- mine at that(!); but maybe we should just finish the season however long it takes. The loan, player contracts business will have to be dealt with but that surely cannot be beyond possible?  Scrap the euros, finish the season, then make plans for what happens next time out.

We are going round in circles TJ.  Of course finish it if possible but I think highly improbable not matter how desirable it would be.  But it is also conceivable that it won't be finished and the current suspension is just a pause before the lot get cancellled.  Then what?   Nice if we got promoted but that's the choice of the Prem clubs.  They might just haul up the ladder.
Reply
#60
I'm glad I haven't renewed my season ticket.

With no recommencement on the horizon, what would I be buying?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)