Today’s ratings
#1
SJ 5 - shaky from the off, just doesn’t command his area properly 

O’Shea 5 - worst performance since becoming a regular, looked every inch of a centre half playing at full back

Hegazi 7.5 - stand out performer before enforced departure 
AJ 6 - had to improve when Bartley came on

Townsend 4 - looked and played like he was knackered

Robbo 5  - did try to be fair
Jake - see above
Harper 5.5 - some good stuff but generally languid. Wouldn’t have hooked him though
Krov 4 - v poor today
Perriria 3 - should have been subbed at HT

HRK 4 - not effective at all today

Subs

Bartley 4 - back to being Bartley
Philips 4 - perfect illustration today of the inconsistency that has stopped him being a top player
Groz 7 - needs to start in the next league game

Slav 4 - picking a predictable and tired starting XI played right into Cook and Wigan’s hands
Reply
#2
(02-29-2020, 06:48 PM)Penny Black Baggie Wrote: SJ 5 - shaky from the off, just doesn’t command his area properly 

O’Shea 5 - worst performance since becoming a regular, looked every inch of a centre half playing at full back

Hegazi 7.5 - stand out performer before enforced departure 
AJ 6 - had to improve when Bartley came on

Townsend 4 - looked and played like he was knackered

Robbo 5  - did try to be fair
Jake - see above
Harper 5.5 - some good stuff but generally languid. Wouldn’t have hooked him though
Krov 4 - v poor today
Perriria 3 - should have been subbed at HT

HRK 4 - not effective at all today

Subs

Bartley 4 - back to being Bartley
Philips 4 - perfect illustration today of the inconsistency that has stopped him being a top player
Groz 7 - needs to start in the next league game

Slav 4 - picking a predictable and tired starting XI played right into Cook and Wigan’s hands

I'd have taken Pereira off and kept Harper on. Harper at least seemed to want to put tackles in.
Reply
#3
Thought Krov tried but he was poor but he was far better than Harper! Thought Harper was back to his usual today after a decent performance Tuesday.
Reply
#4
Sometimes it's easy to accuse the players of not trying. Sometimes, try as you might, things don't go your way. Especially in sport when there is another team hell bent on frustrating you.
Reply
#5
Yes we're 2nd best all day but absolutely nothing dropped or came off for us today just one of those days I'm afraid.
Reply
#6
Bilic: rotates squad away to Wigan, draws game. Fans: Should keep a winning team, played into Wigan hands.

Bilic: keeps same team against Wigan as winning run. Loses game. Loses. Fans: needed to rotate.

Wigan are on form, we were tired and never got going. It happens.
Reply
#7
Johnstone was good imo bar needing to be a bit quicker. Can’t blame the players for having a bad game after such a good run. Thought Johnstone, Hegazi were the best two which says a lot. Krov and Pereira stank - must have had a late night together .
Reply
#8
No one can score Slav 4 for sticking with a winning side. Seemed like everyone in agreement was the right thing to do pre game.

For me we lost the effectiveness of Livermore snapping into tackles further up the field to get us moving today. Morsy wouldn’t have had half the time if Jake was further forward

Even when Sawyers back we should lean on the experience of Barry/Brunt more in the run in.
Reply
#9
(02-29-2020, 07:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Bilic: rotates squad away to Wigan, draws game. Fans:  Should keep a winning team, played into Wigan hands.

Bilic: keeps same team against Wigan as winning run. Loses game. Loses. Fans: needed to rotate.

Wigan are on form, we were tired and never got going. It happens.

I said after the Preston game a few players looked tired - we’ve played (practically) the same team for six intensive weeks.

I still think we will go up.
Reply
#10
I for one, do not buy this tired bollix. Wigan are on great form, WE were on the best form in the league. We didn't turn up, they did. They played more recently than us and arguably fighting relegation is tougher than for promotion. They wanted it, we didn't today, it is as simple as that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)