Gayle's Ban...
#1
At the time, much as I love the Baggies, I loffed and said to my missus that wor a penalty, and was very surprised and overjoyed when it was given, and converted. However Gayle did not award it to himself, the Ref made the decision, and he was in close proximity to the"offence", and did NOT delay with his decision! I have replayed the incident numerous times at the slowest speed available to me, and I am convinced a yellow boot, being worn by the bloke in the mask, made contact with Gayle's foot resulting in his fall, although he did without doubt exaggerate it.        The Ref. it seemed, was happy with his decision at that time, and it is disgraceful that the Player, and ultimately the Club, should be retrospectively punished for the inept performance of the official.  We see week in and week out, aided by tv replays, incident after incident where officials blatantly get it wrong, this is the situation that MUST be addressed, and the officials brought to book.  (starting with Anthony Taylor)
   I WOULD LOVE IT, YES LOVE IT ,(bit of Kevin  Keegan there for you) if we got auto-promotion based on a difference of one point !
Reply
#2
The thing I noticed too was the Forest players were more concerned telling the ref that the ball was won first. There didn't appear to be moaning about a dive. Like you say the ref was in a good position to see it. Surely he saw the fall was exaggerated, but still believed there was a foul?
Reply
#3
watching the EFL on quest I was a bit narked that they focused on the ref's decision to award us a dubious penalty and didn't give what looked a penalty to their bloke at the end.  however they completely neglected to mention the first big incident which was a blatant red card for their player in the first half which undoubtedly would have changed the game.

grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

rant over
Reply
#4
(02-15-2019, 09:58 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: At the time, much as I love the Baggies, I loffed and said to my missus that wor a penalty, and was very surprised and overjoyed when it was given, and converted. However Gayle did not award it to himself, the Ref made the decision, and he was in close proximity to the"offence", and did NOT delay with his decision! I have replayed the incident numerous times at the slowest speed available to me, and I am convinced a yellow boot, being worn by the bloke in the mask, made contact with Gayle's foot resulting in his fall, although he did without doubt exaggerate it.        The Ref. it seemed, was happy with his decision at that time, and it is disgraceful that the Player, and ultimately the Club, should be retrospectively punished for the inept performance of the official.  We see week in and week out, aided by tv replays, incident after incident where officials blatantly get it wrong, this is the situation that MUST be addressed, and the officials brought to book.  (starting with Anthony Taylor)
   I WOULD LOVE IT, YES LOVE IT ,(bit of Kevin  Keegan there for you) if we got auto-promotion based on a difference of one point !

Agreed.

I'm a bit biased though.
Reply
#5
(02-15-2019, 09:58 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: At the time, much as I love the Baggies, I loffed and said to my missus that wor a penalty, and was very surprised and overjoyed when it was given, and converted. However Gayle did not award it to himself, the Ref made the decision, and he was in close proximity to the"offence", and did NOT delay with his decision! I have replayed the incident numerous times at the slowest speed available to me, and I am convinced a yellow boot, being worn by the bloke in the mask, made contact with Gayle's foot resulting in his fall, although he did without doubt exaggerate it.        The Ref. it seemed, was happy with his decision at that time, and it is disgraceful that the Player, and ultimately the Club, should be retrospectively punished for the inept performance of the official.  We see week in and week out, aided by tv replays, incident after incident where officials blatantly get it wrong, this is the situation that MUST be addressed, and the officials brought to book.  (starting with Anthony Taylor)
   I WOULD LOVE IT, YES LOVE IT ,(bit of Kevin  Keegan there for you) if we got auto-promotion based on a difference of one point !
You are right there Ferenc. I said yesterday that I genuinely don't know of any football fan who approves of diving. I'm ok with us getting punished...as long as someone else is done as well, pronto.
I also think that dive or not, a half decent barrister could talk us out of trouble on a number of grounds.
 i.e.   Re-run a million similar instances that went without punishment.
or  State our man jumped to avoid further collision and injury
or  Query the randomness of getting a 2 game ban where if the ref had thought he dived, it would just be a yellow card.

I genuinely think the club has gone along with it to avoid the ban coming up when we play Leeds, Bristol or Sheff Utd. Anyway, I look forward to seeing how Zaha gets on this weekend.
Reply
#6
(02-15-2019, 12:05 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 09:58 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: At the time, much as I love the Baggies, I loffed and said to my missus that wor a penalty, and was very surprised and overjoyed when it was given, and converted. However Gayle did not award it to himself, the Ref made the decision, and he was in close proximity to the"offence", and did NOT delay with his decision! I have replayed the incident numerous times at the slowest speed available to me, and I am convinced a yellow boot, being worn by the bloke in the mask, made contact with Gayle's foot resulting in his fall, although he did without doubt exaggerate it.        The Ref. it seemed, was happy with his decision at that time, and it is disgraceful that the Player, and ultimately the Club, should be retrospectively punished for the inept performance of the official.  We see week in and week out, aided by tv replays, incident after incident where officials blatantly get it wrong, this is the situation that MUST be addressed, and the officials brought to book.  (starting with Anthony Taylor)
   I WOULD LOVE IT, YES LOVE IT ,(bit of Kevin  Keegan there for you) if we got auto-promotion based on a difference of one point !

Agreed.

I'm a bit biased though.

Few also seem to have noticed it was a foul throw prior to forest scoring their 2nd. Gayle was kicked and pushed all night and the ref did nothing. Fair play to Gayle, a point was deserved.
Reply
#7
The cheeky point v Forest may be worth the 2 game ban.
We will know in two games time.
Reply
#8
I have been in football for more than 65 years, played in me last game, a charity thing when I was 62, and I can honestly say I was crap, for some reason the shirts and shorts was tighter, the ball was bouncier, and the pitch was bigger, but nevertheless I was out there and had a goo, but I dae chate! In my day if somebody kicked you, you waited ya time and kicked 'em back, now it's all chatin ! Claiming throws and corners, when they know full well, it's the other way,  trying to pinch a couple of cms when tekkin a corner, wots that all about, pissin about by the corner flag, to eat up a few seconds when times nearly up, load of bollocks. Pink, lime green,yellow boots, 15-20 blokes in the dug out all in matching outfits, wots wrong with a bloke with a towel on his shoulder wearin a big cap, and a white enamel bucket of cold warter, that soon gets'em back on their feet, and summat else, I bet they doe even have a fake at half-time now, I tell  ya, it's all gone to pot!
Reply
#9
It's the whole of society and football is just part of it. By making it easier and easier decade after decade, we have successfully turned men into women.
Reply
#10
(02-15-2019, 09:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 09:58 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: At the time, much as I love the Baggies, I loffed and said to my missus that wor a penalty, and was very surprised and overjoyed when it was given, and converted. However Gayle did not award it to himself, the Ref made the decision, and he was in close proximity to the"offence", and did NOT delay with his decision! I have replayed the incident numerous times at the slowest speed available to me, and I am convinced a yellow boot, being worn by the bloke in the mask, made contact with Gayle's foot resulting in his fall, although he did without doubt exaggerate it.        The Ref. it seemed, was happy with his decision at that time, and it is disgraceful that the Player, and ultimately the Club, should be retrospectively punished for the inept performance of the official.  We see week in and week out, aided by tv replays, incident after incident where officials blatantly get it wrong, this is the situation that MUST be addressed, and the officials brought to book.  (starting with Anthony Taylor)
   I WOULD LOVE IT, YES LOVE IT ,(bit of Kevin  Keegan there for you) if we got auto-promotion based on a difference of one point !
You are right there Ferenc. I said yesterday that I genuinely don't know of any football fan who approves of diving. I'm ok with us getting punished...as long as someone else is done as well, pronto.
I also think that dive or not, a half decent barrister could talk us out of trouble on a number of grounds.
 i.e.   Re-run a million similar instances that went without punishment.
or  State our man jumped to avoid further collision and injury
or  Query the randomness of getting a 2 game ban where if the ref had thought he dived, it would just be a yellow card.

I genuinely think the club has gone aI loolong with it to avoid the ban coming up when we play Leeds, Bristol or Sheff Utd. Anyway I look forward to seeing how Zaha gets on this weekend.

I wouldn't waste anytime on that as he is banned from this weekend's game.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: