The Athletic re youth players
#11
There has to be a better way of monetising departures in our favour. I am though unaware of the figures involved in getting a kid from local junior football all the way to regular first team stuff. It'll be interesting to see if academy budgets get diverted into data analysis if Brentford's model continues to do well.
Reply
#12
It took Chris Wood a while to establish himself. At Brighton he was known as Chris Wooden due to his lack if mobility. It wasn't until Leeds that he really got going.
Reply
#13
As someone said a couple of weeks back, Ferguson, last season didn`t look anything special. Slav saw his potential and played him. No doubt, there are two sides to what has happened since, but, we made him a great offer for a 19 year old. Hope he ends up playing for Torquay or Greenock Morton.
Regarding Edwards etc, he has made some useful appearances, scored 1 or 2. Taking a gamble with him that costs us £ 2 million could make sense. A few appearances , a few goals here and there, if we decide he won`t make it as a regular Prem / Champ player, somebody like Millwall / Wigan etc might pay £750,000 or so for him.
Reply
#14
(02-21-2020, 12:55 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: As someone said a couple of weeks back, Ferguson, last season didn`t look anything special. Slav saw his potential and played him. No doubt, there are two sides to what has happened since, but, we made him a great offer for a 19 year old. Hope he ends up playing for Torquay or Greenock Morton.
Regarding Edwards etc, he has made some useful appearances, scored 1 or 2. Taking a gamble with him that costs us £ 2 million could make sense. A few appearances , a few goals here and there, if we decide he won`t make it as a regular Prem / Champ player, somebody like Millwall / Wigan etc might pay £750,000 or so for him.

The issue here is that he didn't look very special to those working with him, but did look special to a new incoming manager. 
If the rumours are true and the club was looking to loan him out this season even though he has gone onto show he had the ability to be a first choice pick for the first half of the season for a team that lost only once in that period and were comfortable in an automatic spot, then it throws doubt on the club's ability to accurately assess the abilities/potential of their squad.
Reply
#15
(02-21-2020, 01:39 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-21-2020, 12:55 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: As someone said a couple of weeks back, Ferguson, last season didn`t look anything special. Slav saw his potential and played him. No doubt, there are two sides to what has happened since, but, we made him a great offer for a 19 year old. Hope he ends up playing for Torquay or Greenock Morton.
Regarding Edwards etc, he has made some useful appearances, scored 1 or 2. Taking a gamble with him that costs us £ 2 million could make sense. A few appearances , a few goals here and there, if we decide he won`t make it as a regular Prem / Champ player, somebody like Millwall / Wigan etc might pay £750,000 or so for him.

The issue here is that he didn't look very special to those working with him, but did look special to a new incoming manager. 
If the rumours are true and the club was looking to loan him out this season even though he has gone onto show he had the ability to be a first choice pick for the first half of the season for a team that lost only once in that period and were comfortable in an automatic spot, then it throws doubt on the club's ability to accurately assess the abilities/potential of their squad.

Good point , but surely that applies to other clubs besides us. It depends on a coaches ability to maybe spot something. By several accounts, we looked at Danny McGrain in the late 60`s, decided he was not good enough. Played 500 games for Celtic and got about 60 Caps. Man Utd had David Platt as a youngster, said he would never make it and let him go to Crewe.
Reply
#16
Judging youth players potential is one of the hardest jobs in football. More mistakes are made than correct estimates.
Reply
#17
Some player blossom late and probably need to have the right surroundings to help them along. Look at Gareth Mcauley. Joined us while nearing his mid 30's and undoubtedly played the best football of his career with us.
Reply
#18
Like Birdy says it's a tricky one. 

I've seen Tulloch a handful of times for the stiffs and he really has come on leaps and bounds and is now progressing very quickly. He looks a very exciting player to me.

Who's to say he's not going to be a better bet than Edwards? We've all seen what Edwards can and can't do but that's only because he's been given a chance. Tulloch hasn't been afforded those minutes to shine in the league so we are going to let him go without seeing how he might fair.

Very similar to the Tyler Roberts situation. On the verge of breaking in but choosing to leave and got picked up and played straight away in the Championship. 

I think similar will happen to Tulloch. 

Shame imo but can see the clubs point of view. You only have to look at Harper to see what can happen the other way.
Reply
#19
Harsh on Harper there, don't think Bilic expected to use him much this season and he's been given a lot to work on. Bilic was very keen we got him signed up so I expect he'll want to use him.
Reply
#20
(02-21-2020, 12:35 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The only gripe I have is that there ought to be a standard, or incremented, compensation amount(s) if you have brought them through your Academy.
There ought.
But many, probably most, clubs beyond us are caught by this issue.
The FA, FIFA ought to be on to it.
But I've never seen anything that tells me that they are.
It should be in the associations' interests to spread academy football, but nothing seems to happen..
Is it to do with restraint of trade?
I can see that a 17 year old should not be tied to a contract against his will.
But, off the top of my head, it should be within the FA's powers to restrict the number of youth players a club can register?
So Liverpool and Chelski should not have a bank of 50 young players to pick from...
Or am I missing something?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: