Dingle Don
#41
Just think that our fans are being over sensitive or very biased.Ive watched the game back again and think that Goodman made an honest assessment of the major decisions .If I'm being honest Livermore should have been sent off and also fouled the Forest player before our second goal.The goal for us that was disallowed at the end should of counted so overall the referee Stroud had a bad day.Just because Goodman gave an honest assessment doesn't make him anti Albion.What I would say is give me a referee who tries to give honest decisions and may get a few wrong than the farcical VAR that has been used in the Premier League.
Reply
#42
(02-17-2020, 05:40 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Just think that our fans are being over sensitive or very biased.Ive watched the game back again and think that Goodman made an honest assessment of the major decisions .If I'm being honest Livermore should have been sent off and also fouled the Forest player before our second goal.The goal for us that was disallowed at the end should of counted so overall the referee Stroud had a bad day.Just because Goodman gave an honest assessment doesn't make him anti Albion.What I would say is give me a referee who tries to give honest decisions and may get a few wrong than the farcical VAR that has been used in the Premier League.

It was more Goodmans narrative throughout the game rather than his opinions on the rights and wrongs of the decisions. He basically implied Forest were the better side and says lucky Albion this and lucky Albion that throughout.

Sometimes people get a bit carried away with Goodman bashing but it is wholly justified in this instance imo. It was one of the most bizarrely myopic co commentaries I have ever heard!
Reply
#43
(02-16-2020, 07:26 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: I was obviously at the game but so much went on that I’ve watched it through again today.
Thought we played well and Forest should have had a couple of goals defeat for it to be a fair reflection.
I’ve been pretty calm about Dingle Don apart from a few instances BUT that commentary today !!
Wow!  It was so bad and contradictory it must have been premeditated.
Forest kicked us off the pitch most of the game yet the ref wouldn’t yellow card them ; Sow should have had two and so could have Cash! Ok Livermore could have also gone.
Dingle Don seemed to make all kinds of excuses for Forest players then called ours out for similar?  Very weird as he also seemed to dumb the whole game down to make us equivalent to Forests poor performance.

(02-16-2020, 12:04 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I’ve met Don a few times, loves his time at The Albion and only ever speaks highly of us as a club and a fan base

I was there yesterday so didn’t hear the commentary but reading this thread it seems he was OTT against us, certainly wasn’t against Millwall though where he basically said we were exceptional

Cuzer

Agree that he was pretty positive about us at Millwall and has been much better this season which is why yesterday’s commentary was so bizarre!  Almost as though he had pre meditated much of his narrative and then just adopted the situations to suit. He was down playing everything good about us or committed against us BUT doing the opposite for Forest. Almost as though he was doing the Forest house commentary for their website.

(02-16-2020, 06:37 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(02-16-2020, 03:36 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(02-16-2020, 12:04 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I’ve met Don a few times, loves his time at The Albion and only ever speaks highly of us as a club and a fan base

I was there yesterday so didn’t hear the commentary but reading this thread it seems he was OTT against us, certainly wasn’t against Millwall though where he basically said we were exceptional

Cuzer

I’ve heard you say that before, Cuzer and I don’t doubt you. Yesterday was farcical though. Be interesting to make him watch it back and reflect on his own professionalism

I have met him a couple of times at Chester Races. He’s really sound

He denies bias and talks fondly of us - in what were dark days. 

He certainly admits to preferring Wolves to us, mind...

That last sentence says it all ......


Where did you find the full match replay?
Reply
#44
Anyone with any doubts just needs to watch the 5-1 back. Where 5 lucky deflections handed Wolves an unjust loss.
Reply
#45
(02-16-2020, 07:26 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: I was obviously at the game but so much went on that I’ve watched it through again today.
Thought we played well and Forest should have had a couple of goals defeat for it to be a fair reflection.
I’ve been pretty calm about Dingle Don apart from a few instances BUT that commentary today !!
Wow!  It was so bad and contradictory it must have been premeditated.
Forest kicked us off the pitch most of the game yet the ref wouldn’t yellow card them ; Sow should have had two and so could have Cash! Ok Livermore could have also gone.
Dingle Don seemed to make all kinds of excuses for Forest players then called ours out for similar?  Very weird as he also seemed to dumb the whole game down to make us equivalent to Forests poor performance.

(02-16-2020, 12:04 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I’ve met Don a few times, loves his time at The Albion and only ever speaks highly of us as a club and a fan base

I was there yesterday so didn’t hear the commentary but reading this thread it seems he was OTT against us, certainly wasn’t against Millwall though where he basically said we were exceptional

Cuzer

Agree that he was pretty positive about us at Millwall and has been much better this season which is why yesterday’s commentary was so bizarre!  Almost as though he had pre meditated much of his narrative and then just adopted the situations to suit. He was down playing everything good about us or committed against us BUT doing the opposite for Forest. Almost as though he was doing the Forest house commentary for their website.

(02-16-2020, 06:37 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(02-16-2020, 03:36 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(02-16-2020, 12:04 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I’ve met Don a few times, loves his time at The Albion and only ever speaks highly of us as a club and a fan base

I was there yesterday so didn’t hear the commentary but reading this thread it seems he was OTT against us, certainly wasn’t against Millwall though where he basically said we were exceptional

Cuzer

I’ve heard you say that before, Cuzer and I don’t doubt you. Yesterday was farcical though. Be interesting to make him watch it back and reflect on his own professionalism

I have met him a couple of times at Chester Races. He’s really sound

He denies bias and talks fondly of us - in what were dark days. 

He certainly admits to preferring Wolves to us, mind...

That last sentence says it all ......
+1 That qualifies him as a utter cunt .
Reply
#46
His commentary on the 5.1 years back was really biased ,it just seems to have carried on from there
Reply
#47
(02-17-2020, 06:13 PM)Mickyfudge Wrote: His commentary on the 5.1 years back was really biased ,it just seems to have carried on from there

Why don't they get someone to tell him he is spouting rubbish and his commentry is biased and not wanted.
Reply
#48
(02-17-2020, 05:40 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Just think that our fans are being over sensitive or very biased.Ive watched the game back again and think that Goodman made an honest assessment of the major decisions .If I'm being honest Livermore should have been sent off and also fouled the Forest player before our second goal.The goal for us that was disallowed at the end should of counted so overall the referee Stroud had a bad day.Just because Goodman gave an honest assessment doesn't make him anti Albion.What I would say is give me a referee who tries to give honest decisions and may get a few wrong than the farcical VAR that has been used in the Premier League.


Honest assessment my backside
Reply
#49
(02-17-2020, 05:40 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Just think that our fans are being over sensitive or very biased.Ive watched the game back again and think that Goodman made an honest assessment of the major decisions .If I'm being honest Livermore should have been sent off and also fouled the Forest player before our second goal.The goal for us that was disallowed at the end should of counted so overall the referee Stroud had a bad day.Just because Goodman gave an honest assessment doesn't make him anti Albion.What I would say is give me a referee who tries to give honest decisions and may get a few wrong than the farcical VAR that has been used in the Premier League.

Can't agree. He surpassed himself on Saturday. Against Millwall I thought he was quite complementary. Against Forest it was a constant stream of negativity for Albion and positivity for Forest. Which is bizarre given we totally outplayed them.
Reply
#50
(02-17-2020, 06:48 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(02-17-2020, 05:40 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Just think that our fans are being over sensitive or very biased.Ive watched the game back again and think that Goodman made an honest assessment of the major decisions .If I'm being honest Livermore should have been sent off and also fouled the Forest player before our second goal.The goal for us that was disallowed at the end should of counted so overall the referee Stroud had a bad day.Just because Goodman gave an honest assessment doesn't make him anti Albion.What I would say is give me a referee who tries to give honest decisions and may get a few wrong than the farcical VAR that has been used in the Premier League.

Can't agree. He surpassed himself on Saturday. Against Millwall I thought he was quite complementary. Against Forest it was a constant stream of negativity for Albion and positivity for Forest. Which is bizarre given we totally outplayed them.

I'm with you on that one.  I stated earlier that I never particularly thought him one-sided re us but on Saturday I thought he must've been watching through his earholes.  Myopic doesn't cover it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: