Housing Policy
#41
(02-11-2020, 01:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 05:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: A society should look to narrow the gap it won’t hurt the rich and it will only help the poor.
Developed societies already do. The free market enables them to do so. Developed societies get their cake (the obscenely rich) and eat it (the welfare state). If you reduce the size of the cake, there is always less to eat. It's not hard to understand Dekka.

The trouble with this argument is the obscenely rich hide most of their cake in a different cupboard under the stairs. The greedy bastards wouldn’t want anyone else eating an extra slice / crumb off their table.

The truth is that experience has shown that the cake never grows at the same rate as that of the proportion of the cake consumed by the very wealthy.
Reply
#42
(02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 05:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: A society should look to narrow the gap it won’t hurt the rich and it will only help the poor.
Developed societies already do. The free market enables them to do so. Developed societies get their cake (the obscenely rich) and eat it (the welfare state). If you reduce the size of the cake, there is always less to eat. It's not hard to understand Dekka.

Do you have any links or resources to show how unregulated free market helps to narrow the gap between the rich and poor in the UK in 2020? I tend towards the view that a free market *can* aid the poor in developing countries with untapped resources, though exploitation is inevitable. In developed countries that have moved to a service economy that exploitation is entrenched and there is no incentive to improve public services or the lot of the less fortunate. How does the free market encourage increased standards of education or cheaper and more freely available public transport? How does it encourage increasing wages beyond inflation? (genuine questions, if there are answers please let me know. I did English at uni, not economics!) And if the free market does improve these things, why hasn't it in the past 15 years where public spending has been in the gutter?

I see some support for instance for removing the minimum wage to allow unskilled workers to find work. I doubt employers/companies would lower prices at the same time as lowering wages? What happens to the people in full time work who can't afford food and shelter (a situation we have plenty of now)
Reply
#43
(02-11-2020, 01:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The truth is that experience has shown that the cake never grows at the same rate as that of the proportion of the cake consumed by the very wealthy.

Which is exactly as it should be. When I put my all my assets down as collateral to start a business in the depths of the financial crisis I expected my particular cake to grow more quickly than someone who, say...didn't.

(02-11-2020, 01:53 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: unregulated free market
 
There isn't such a thing.
Reply
#44
(02-11-2020, 03:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-11-2020, 01:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The truth is that experience has shown that the cake never grows at the same rate as that of the proportion of the cake consumed by the very wealthy.

Which is exactly as it should be. When I put my all my assets down as collateral to start a business in the depths of the financial crisis I expected my particular cake to grow more quickly than someone who, say...didn't.


But your missing the point, if the cake is growing at a rate less than the rate at which the wealthys' proportion is growing, then the amount of cake the rest of the country has could well be less.

Let me provide you with some numbers to demonstrate.
A cake weighs 100g, shared 50% for the wealthy 50% for the rest.
The cake over a period of time grows 10% now weighing 110g, the proportion that the wealthy receives of the cake increases by 20% over the same time, which equates to 60% or 66g. The rest of the country has a 40% share which equates to 44g, less than they had previously.
Reply
#45
It seems the problem is Cakeism
Reply
#46
Donughts the lot of em
Reply
#47
Putting all cakes on the table and going back to the original title of this thread; why can't we have a housing policy which starts with a rule that you are responsible for your own housing rather than the state? This being with fairness in mind to the elderly, sick or any adult unable to care for themselves. Why should a local authority pick up the cost of housing someone?
Reply
#48
(02-12-2020, 02:20 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: Putting all cakes on the table and going back to the original title of this thread; why can't we have a housing policy which starts with a rule that you are responsible for your own housing rather than the state? This being with fairness in mind to the elderly, sick or any adult unable to care for themselves. Why should a local authority pick up the cost of housing someone?

Possibly because we are not starting from a level playing field. Look at it from both ends of the spectrum, the youth of today have a starting average house price of nearly £300k and an average salary of around £30k. When I started out in the 90s I had a salary of £15k on a house of £45k which was just about affordable, kids today haven't got a chance unless they take out debt for a lifetime.

Then you could look at the elderly, my old man served his country in the war, paid all of his taxes throughout his life and was promised cradle to the grave care. Unfortunately that didn't happen and he ended up having to pay for something he didn't buy into. My uncle, a bevan boy no less, is facing having to sell his house to pay for any care. He was hoping to leave his house to his grandkids to start them off in life (see above).

Then there are people who, through no fault of their own, can't work, what should they do?

Social housing worked through the 50s, 60s and 70s because it mixed different types of people together to provide a community and provide a foot on the ladder for people to move on from. On the estates where I grew up there were policemen, nurses, factory workers and all other trades together. Kids grew up watching folk go to work and set the norm to aspire to. Nowadays, because there are so few houses available the majority all go to those in greatest need and we have created sink estates where no-one works and kids see folk getting away with life without going to work and, lo and behold, they aspire to that.

And one important point in all of that, the local authority isn't picking up the full bill because the tenants would pay rent.
Reply
#49
Imbalance in demographics seems like one of our biggest challenges to me. As is alluded to above, where "wealth" that used to be locked into housing has historically assisted the next generation financially, a lot of it now evaporates in 2-3 years on very costly end of life living arrangements. Meanwhile, the pressure from the economically inactive population grows ever greater, both practically and economically.
Reply
#50
(02-12-2020, 05:43 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Imbalance in demographics seems like one of our biggest challenges to me. As is alluded to above, where "wealth" that used to be locked into housing has historically assisted the next generation financially, a lot of it now evaporates in 2-3 years on very costly end of life living arrangements. Meanwhile, the pressure from the economically inactive population grows ever greater, both practically and economically.

The vast majority of the elderly do not end up in long term care. Even if they do wealth doesn't "evaporate", it's spent on services.

If families wish to preserve housing wealth they could always look after their parents as every generation up to the 1980s tended to.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)