Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-11-2020, 09:54 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-11-2020, 09:59 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(02-11-2020, 08:45 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-09-2020, 09:11 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-09-2020, 08:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-09-2020, 08:38 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-09-2020, 12:04 PM)Hopalong Wrote: The population of the West Midlands is 3.2m plus the surrounding counties where we attract support.
We're selling out nearly every week and could easily live with a 32k stadium which would attract new fans.
The tired argument by some is based on not selling out every week. As I said I’ve lost two opportunities to go this season due to the crap capacity.
It’s a joke. Fill in the corners, add gently to the Halfords and job done. 30,000 is all we ask for.
The problem is the argument regarding selling out is the the one the club has based its decision on. I would like a bigger and better stadium but we are where we are. And tell me when is the right time to expand? When is that perfect window? We have 1500 less seats than when we went up under Megson 18 years ago.
Have Villa had near 42,000 crowds consistently in the past several years? Why didn’t Wolves go for a 10,000 capacity stadium when they were losing to the likes of Chorley.
You read through the clubs with bigger stadiums than us now- the likes of Bristol City, who have had 4 years in the top division in the past 100 years or MK Dons, who weren’t even a club when most of us were shaving.
Look at the likes of Brighton, Middlesbrough, Cardiff- barely any history worth talking about.
Wolves were a pale shadow of us a few years back, but now look light years ahead.
There is no reason whatsoever that we can’t look to increase our stadium.
It’s a total joke.
+1
The argument that if they go they will build bigger is irrelevant. None of those teams mentioned above sold out to their capacity before they decided to expand or build new. What it does do is give them room to grow when/if they are successful. Quite frankly for the cost of Brown ideye and Oliver Burke we could have had a new Halfords lane end. We don't mind spending the money on tripe players - I mean Zohore £8m there's another tier - but it's somehow anathema to spend it on making the stadium bigger.
We must be the only team, who has been in the Premier league, to have reduced capacity over the past 20 years. It's a joke. Here's a link showing us with the 33rd biggest stadium in the country. https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...y_capacity Currently, on league place, we are higher in the footballing pyramid than 16 of the clubs- I would add that some of those clubs Leeds, Sunderland and Sheff W have unquestionably larger support- true fallen giants. The rest we can put an argument forward for being their equals at least.
I think what makes this thread such a reoccurring subject is how unique we are in the unwillingness to improve the capacity debate. I genuinely cannot think of another club, of our historical standing, who are like us in that we play so percentage wise to capacity, with so little wriggle room.
It is, as many who don't see it as an issue have said, in ways a bit pointless as it comes down to the club's owners decision. That doesn't mean it shouldn't be questioned though. The likes of Peace once said he'd up the capacity, but then changed his mind, so clearly it's not that crazy.
The attitude by season ticket holders to those who don't go all the time is odd too. Every single club in the country has regular diehards and floating fans. It was always like this. If they want to look down their noses at those who don't go all the time then that's their prerogative, without taking into account other people's demands in their lives and choices to support a club less fanatically than them. Look at the wildly varying attendances in the 70s- We could get 15,000 v Norwich and 35,000 v Liverpool.
The Albion capacity debate will continue to raise its head because the whole subject is so baffling compared to the rest of the English football world. It is a real conundrum.
Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
"
(02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Could do with the hire firm fucking off.
(02-11-2020, 10:28 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Could do with the hire firm fucking off.
My final on this as it does my fruit in this subject. The New Tivoli stadium for Aarchen was build for £42m - capacity 32500. Cost of circa £1200 a seat. Has nearly 12000 standing seats as options - as an allseater 27K. You could knock the whole of the Hawthorns down and build that on the same site for £50m. FFS. Just fookin get on with it
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(02-11-2020, 10:28 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Could do with the hire firm fucking off.
It's a ransom strip - and they know it.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
02-11-2020, 11:37 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-11-2020, 11:44 AM by MassDebater.)
(02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Remi does the maths on 'ere!
But I'll have a pop... 'Pools works out at £3,750 per seat, and whilst Aachen may have built a ground cheaper you can assume the Liverpool price is more along the lines of what it would cost over here. Official Halford's capacity is currently on 3,773 BTW. Can't really use the East STand to compare costs as it was built 19 years ago and things have gone up a lot since then.
In effect you're looking at a ten year season ticket to cover the build cost (ignoring maintenance) of each seat. That's also excluding the simple fact that the club would probably end up needing to pay a lot more to do something to Halford's Lane (sewers, gas mains, electric, broadband etc...) , they may even have to re-route part of the road, and that could then lead to changes needed at the Academy over the road, etc..., but would assume it would increase costs further. A simple 5,000 expansion would likely cost c£19m, based on Liverpool's costs, which may actually work out lower since they had more seats...add in that it's building on an existing structure & the road and you may well end up almost doubling the costs (based on it cost £16m for them to do Centenary Square in Brum (and that was largely a paving and putting in some nice garden bits and fountains type work...very little vertical stuff)).
I don't think we'd see much change from £30m, for something that may give us 5,000 more capacity which likely would rarely get past half full. *if* we get promoted *and* re-establish ourselves then I would say do it, until then it would be an expense that could impact promotion chances.
Posts: 2,502
Threads: 567
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
Whenever this debate is raised, one thing never seems to get mentioned and that is we now live in a time when clubs are under increasing pressure to keep ticket prices low or indeed lower them further, I don't see it as an attractive proposition for any business to make a large outlay to build something they are under increasing pressure to charge less for, when what they have already got is perfectly adequate.
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
All a bigger stadium would do would change the reasons and excuses for people to not go. Lower division, Peace, Pulis, Capacity........ Ad infinitum ffs
|