Team
#51
(02-10-2020, 04:58 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-09-2020, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have no idea why fans judge the team selection before a ball is kicked. Their own theoretical team cannot ever be proven to be better so it seems a bit pointless.

By that logic we can't have an opinion on anything. No discussions about whether Big Dave should or shouldn't have been sacked because once a new manager comes in the circumstances are different. No one can ever prove whether another manager would have been better or not.

There seems to be more people talking about how people shouldn't have opinions on team selection than those who actually voice their opinion about it! This forum is better when people can give their opinions.

I’m giving an opinion that I find the daft ott criticism of any manager’s team choice pointless before a ball is kicked. Others can disagree I’m not ahem “shutting down debate”. Some fans have very thin skin when their opinion is questioned and resort to calling those who do lots of needless expletives or play you’re a WUM card. You know this is true. They of course can call managers and players and those that disagree all the names under the Sun or you must respect my opinion no matter if it has nothing to back it up.
Reply
#52
Manager =top of the league. Internet managers =nil
Reply
#53
(02-10-2020, 05:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 04:58 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-09-2020, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have no idea why fans judge the team selection before a ball is kicked. Their own theoretical team cannot ever be proven to be better so it seems a bit pointless.

By that logic we can't have an opinion on anything. No discussions about whether Big Dave should or shouldn't have been sacked because once a new manager comes in the circumstances are different. No one can ever prove whether another manager would have been better or not.

There seems to be more people talking about how people shouldn't have opinions on team selection than those who actually voice their opinion about it! This forum is better when people can give their opinions.

I’m giving an opinion that I find the daft ott criticism of any manager’s team choice pointless before a ball is kicked. Others can disagree I’m not ahem “shutting down debate”. Some fans have very thin skin when their opinion is questioned and resort to calling those who do lots of needless expletives or play you’re a WUM card. You know this is true. They of course can call managers and players and  those that disagree all the names under the Sun or you must respect my opinion no matter if it has nothing to back it up.

I agree with all of that. Daft OTT criticism is always pointless, and it always seems to be those giving it that can't take a difference in opinion. 

I can say that I'm suprised he played O'Shea out wide though Big Grin
Reply
#54
Putting different players in the team and putting players in different roles is part of upsetting the oppositions preparations. Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. It's the plan B many of our managers never had according to some. Embrace it as it's working and entertaining. If you want one dimensional safe mode follow the next team TP rocks up at. Ffs what do people want??????
Reply
#55
(02-10-2020, 06:25 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 05:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 04:58 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-09-2020, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have no idea why fans judge the team selection before a ball is kicked. Their own theoretical team cannot ever be proven to be better so it seems a bit pointless.

By that logic we can't have an opinion on anything. No discussions about whether Big Dave should or shouldn't have been sacked because once a new manager comes in the circumstances are different. No one can ever prove whether another manager would have been better or not.

There seems to be more people talking about how people shouldn't have opinions on team selection than those who actually voice their opinion about it! This forum is better when people can give their opinions.

I’m giving an opinion that I find the daft ott criticism of any manager’s team choice pointless before a ball is kicked. Others can disagree I’m not ahem “shutting down debate”. Some fans have very thin skin when their opinion is questioned and resort to calling those who do lots of needless expletives or play you’re a WUM card. You know this is true. They of course can call managers and players and  those that disagree all the names under the Sun or you must respect my opinion no matter if it has nothing to back it up.

I agree with all of that. Daft OTT criticism is always pointless, and it always seems to be those giving it that can't take a difference in opinion. 

I can say that I'm suprised he played O'Shea out wide though Big Grin

No Dek - the problem is your opinion is not about the team / manager / club it's directed at what someone else has "posted". You should be offering your own opinion, if you think Bilic's selection is correct just say so. If you continue to criticise others opinions don't keep crying when they verbally throw it straight back at you. 
I don't think you realise your posts are inviting confrontational responses, unless that's exactly what your looking for? That's how it looks.
Reply
#56
Of course he knows what he is doing does DH he is right about everything ..........apart from pulis/brexit /tories ( gets tin hat ready )
Reply
#57
(02-10-2020, 10:57 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Of course he knows what he is doing does DH he is right about everything ..........apart from pulis/brexit /tories ( gets tin hat ready )

China I’m not biting I like you  Smile
Reply
#58
(02-10-2020, 05:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 04:58 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-09-2020, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have no idea why fans judge the team selection before a ball is kicked. Their own theoretical team cannot ever be proven to be better so it seems a bit pointless.

By that logic we can't have an opinion on anything. No discussions about whether Big Dave should or shouldn't have been sacked because once a new manager comes in the circumstances are different. No one can ever prove whether another manager would have been better or not.

There seems to be more people talking about how people shouldn't have opinions on team selection than those who actually voice their opinion about it! This forum is better when people can give their opinions.

I’m giving an opinion that I find the daft ott criticism of any manager’s team choice pointless before a ball is kicked. Others can disagree I’m not ahem “shutting down debate”. Some fans have very thin skin when their opinion is questioned and resort to calling those who do lots of needless expletives or play you’re a WUM card. You know this is true. They of course can call managers and players and  those that disagree all the names under the Sun or you must respect my opinion no matter if it has nothing to back it up.

Of course it's fair enough for people to offer opinions about team selection and how the game is going in its early stage, but it is setting yourself up for a fall.

Want to have a strong opinion, make it one that can only be determined over a long period of time. So for example when we bought Charlie Austin I said if he stays fit (which he has) he would definitely score over 20 goals in the league this season (which he probably won't now) but nobody remembers that prediction now.

But if you say that before the game that the team selection is wrong and then we put in a really good performance, or if after 20 mins of a game you say we are playing terribly and a certain player is rubbish, and we go on to win handsomely with that player playing a blinder, don't expect others not to remind you of your predictions.
Reply
#59
(02-10-2020, 08:33 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 06:25 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 05:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 04:58 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-09-2020, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have no idea why fans judge the team selection before a ball is kicked. Their own theoretical team cannot ever be proven to be better so it seems a bit pointless.

By that logic we can't have an opinion on anything. No discussions about whether Big Dave should or shouldn't have been sacked because once a new manager comes in the circumstances are different. No one can ever prove whether another manager would have been better or not.

There seems to be more people talking about how people shouldn't have opinions on team selection than those who actually voice their opinion about it! This forum is better when people can give their opinions.

I’m giving an opinion that I find the daft ott criticism of any manager’s team choice pointless before a ball is kicked. Others can disagree I’m not ahem “shutting down debate”. Some fans have very thin skin when their opinion is questioned and resort to calling those who do lots of needless expletives or play you’re a WUM card. You know this is true. They of course can call managers and players and  those that disagree all the names under the Sun or you must respect my opinion no matter if it has nothing to back it up.

I agree with all of that. Daft OTT criticism is always pointless, and it always seems to be those giving it that can't take a difference in opinion. 

I can say that I'm suprised he played O'Shea out wide though Big Grin

No Dek - the problem is your opinion is not about the team / manager / club it's directed at what someone else has "posted". You should be offering your own opinion, if you think Bilic's selection is correct just say so. If you continue to criticise others opinions don't keep crying when they verbally throw it straight back at you. 
I don't think you realise your posts are inviting confrontational responses, unless that's exactly what your looking for? That's how it looks.

I give my opinions on the team just as much as anyone else. The idea that I don’t is either a mistake or deliberately misleading. Did you see the dogs abuse I got for supporting TP’s tenure? Or the criticism I got for suggesting DM and GJ were not a good match to get us promoted? Or the splinters I’ve got for sitting on the fence in the politics section? 

Yes sometimes I will ask some posters to justify their opinions because they state them as fact or they are just downright stupid. Is that not a valid form discussion on a forum like this? Sometimes I will just take the piss like everyone else does at times in here. 

In regards to team selection I will let the bloke who has taken us to the top of the league decide who he picks and see if it works. If it doesn’t then fair enough he will be criticised for it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: