Striker dilemna
#31
Which one of those loans we signed were center forwards Dumbo.

(02-02-2020, 08:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 08:29 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 03:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:50 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:35 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Im not sure with that as a front 4 that we would need to be holding the ball up much. 

Brilliant to see Robinson finally enable some dynamism and thrust to return to our attacking play.

The top sides don't play hold up they attack with fast one-touch passing.  I think we have the personnel to do this now with Robinson at the top and Diang Phillips Grosicki Pereira behind. 

Be interesting to see what Bilic does when all fit - has to ditch the Livermore-Sawyers combo for me.  Play one or the other, we're too slow and ponderous with both.

And play one of the more spritely Brunt or Barry?

I do think Harper could slot into our midfield and add a bit more directness, but we’d be even more exposed on the break.

If we fail to get autos it’ll be our failure to bring in an MC that causes it for me.

(02-02-2020, 08:29 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 03:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:50 PM)Hopalong Wrote: The top sides don't play hold up they attack with fast one-touch passing.  I think we have the personnel to do this now with Robinson at the top and Diang Phillips Grosicki Pereira behind. 

Be interesting to see what Bilic does when all fit - has to ditch the Livermore-Sawyers combo for me.  Play one or the other, we're too slow and ponderous with both.

And play one of the more spritely Brunt or Barry?

I do think Harper could slot into our midfield and add a bit more directness, but we’d be even more exposed on the break.

If we fail to get autos it’ll be our failure to bring in an MC that causes it for me.

You obviously haven't read the thread.  Where have Barry/Brunt been mentioned?  

Get rid of one of Livermore/sawyers and play a more attacking formation. 

Do Man City play 2 holding midfielders? 

We need to accommodate our best players/most of whom are attacking players.  

We will then score lots of goals and win matches.

You’re right.

What we should do is not play any defenders nor midfielders and just put 10 strikers on the field, we’ll score loads more then.

It’s amazing no manager has worked this out yet

Reverse logic is undeniable.
Reply
#32
(02-02-2020, 01:12 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 12:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 12:07 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 12:01 PM)Sliced Wrote: Zohore isn't an option and Robinson was good out wide yesterday. IMO we continue with Austin up top, he at least looks like scoring occasionally

But why continue with something that's clearly not working when you can at least try something that most likely will?

Robinson on the wing worked!

I agree!  But Grosicki could play there til Diang back.

(02-02-2020, 02:50 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:35 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:31 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Robinson through the middle would allow us to play our best players in the three behind him but I worry about his ability to hold up the ball, especially away from home

I still see HRK being our best bet given how we set up and where our main threats come from

Zahore could be the best option but just seems to half hearted unfortunately

Cuzer

Im not sure with that as a front 4 that we would need to be holding the ball up much. 

Brilliant to see Robinson finally enable some dynamism and thrust to return to our attacking play.

The top sides don't play hold up they attack with fast one-touch passing.  I think we have the personnel to do this now with Robinson at the top and Diang Phillips Grosicki Pereira behind. 

Be interesting to see what Bilic does when all fit - has to ditch the Livermore-Sawyers combo for me.  Play one or the other, we're too slow and ponderous with both.

Too slow and ponderous with both, don't you remember the tearing teams apart for a good chunk of the season? When both played?
Reply
#33
I think you have to play the two sitting midfielders with the way we play. You have Phillips, Grady, Pereira and striker (or variations of) all bombing forward. You need two of them to keep an eye for covering.

I think if we are chasing a game then fair enough. Hook one for a more attack minded player but not from the start imo.

We have to remember we are top of the league and we've achieved that with Sawyers and Jake.
Reply
#34
(02-02-2020, 08:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 08:29 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 03:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:50 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:35 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Im not sure with that as a front 4 that we would need to be holding the ball up much. 

Brilliant to see Robinson finally enable some dynamism and thrust to return to our attacking play.

The top sides don't play hold up they attack with fast one-touch passing.  I think we have the personnel to do this now with Robinson at the top and Diang Phillips Grosicki Pereira behind. 

Be interesting to see what Bilic does when all fit - has to ditch the Livermore-Sawyers combo for me.  Play one or the other, we're too slow and ponderous with both.

And play one of the more spritely Brunt or Barry?

I do think Harper could slot into our midfield and add a bit more directness, but we’d be even more exposed on the break.

If we fail to get autos it’ll be our failure to bring in an MC that causes it for me.

(02-02-2020, 08:29 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 03:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:50 PM)Hopalong Wrote: The top sides don't play hold up they attack with fast one-touch passing.  I think we have the personnel to do this now with Robinson at the top and Diang Phillips Grosicki Pereira behind. 

Be interesting to see what Bilic does when all fit - has to ditch the Livermore-Sawyers combo for me.  Play one or the other, we're too slow and ponderous with both.

And play one of the more spritely Brunt or Barry?

I do think Harper could slot into our midfield and add a bit more directness, but we’d be even more exposed on the break.

If we fail to get autos it’ll be our failure to bring in an MC that causes it for me.

You obviously haven't read the thread.  Where have Barry/Brunt been mentioned?  

Get rid of one of Livermore/sawyers and play a more attacking formation. 

Do Man City play 2 holding midfielders? 

We need to accommodate our best players/most of whom are attacking players.  

We will then score lots of goals and win matches.

You’re right.

What we should do is not play any defenders nor midfielders and just put 10 strikers on the field, we’ll score loads more then.

It’s amazing no manager has worked this out yet

Jeez.... where did I say that?   Rolleyes

I said play 1 holding midfielder not two and 5 offensive players who obviously need to do the defensive side when not in possession.   

We have to play Grosicki, Phillips, Pereira, Diangana and Robinson if available - in my view - otherwise what was the point in signing them,  especially Robinson who is only going to be here for another maximum 16 games.  Are we really going to sit say Grosicki/Phillips and Robinson/Diangana on the bench to accommodate Austin and Sawyers which is what you seem to be advocating.  

It's my belief that we now have the players to play a much more attacking game across the entire pitch,  not needing to rely on hoofing it to a target man to hold the ball up whilst the rest of the team join in,  but will be able to play through teams with our pace.   

Just my opinion.
Reply
#35
(02-03-2020, 10:09 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 08:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 08:29 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 03:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 02:50 PM)Hopalong Wrote: The top sides don't play hold up they attack with fast one-touch passing.  I think we have the personnel to do this now with Robinson at the top and Diang Phillips Grosicki Pereira behind. 

Be interesting to see what Bilic does when all fit - has to ditch the Livermore-Sawyers combo for me.  Play one or the other, we're too slow and ponderous with both.

And play one of the more spritely Brunt or Barry?

I do think Harper could slot into our midfield and add a bit more directness, but we’d be even more exposed on the break.

If we fail to get autos it’ll be our failure to bring in an MC that causes it for me.

(02-02-2020, 08:29 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-02-2020, 03:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: And play one of the more spritely Brunt or Barry?

I do think Harper could slot into our midfield and add a bit more directness, but we’d be even more exposed on the break.

If we fail to get autos it’ll be our failure to bring in an MC that causes it for me.

You obviously haven't read the thread.  Where have Barry/Brunt been mentioned?  

Get rid of one of Livermore/sawyers and play a more attacking formation. 

Do Man City play 2 holding midfielders? 

We need to accommodate our best players/most of whom are attacking players.  

We will then score lots of goals and win matches.

You’re right.

What we should do is not play any defenders nor midfielders and just put 10 strikers on the field, we’ll score loads more then.

It’s amazing no manager has worked this out yet

Jeez.... where did I say that?   Rolleyes

I said play 1 holding midfielder not two and 5 offensive players who obviously need to do the defensive side when not in possession.   

We have to play Grosicki, Phillips, Pereira, Diangana and Robinson if available - in my view - otherwise what was the point in signing them,  especially Robinson who is only going to be here for another maximum 16 games.  Are we really going to sit say Grosicki/Phillips and Robinson/Diangana on the bench to accommodate Austin and Sawyers which is what you seem to be advocating.  

It's my belief that we now have the players to play a much more attacking game across the entire pitch,  not needing to rely on hoofing it to a target man to hold the ball up whilst the rest of the team join in,  but will be able to play through teams with our pace.   

Just my opinion.

I’m not advocating Austin, Hoppy... I’ve been one of his biggest critics all season as he just doesn’t offer enough... what I am saying is that I don’t think it’s as easy as saying we’ve got all these attacking players, we have to play them all at once. 

IMO we do not have a midfield partnership better than Livermore and Sawyers for how Slav wants to play... I keep seeing Brunt, Barry and Krov lauded, but neither of those have the same amount of mobility and ball retention as RS and JL. Given it’s quite clear that Slav won’t change how we set up, or how he wants to approach games, those two are the best we have. I think Harper is probably the best alternative, but he isn’t as physical and hard working as JL nor as good on the ball as RS.

The biggest criticism of them is giving the ball away and not winning it back in dangerous areas... no one else in our team will do a better job than they do of turning over possession, and no one will have a better pass completion than those two... for me it’s no shock their form has dropped off in the absence of Gibbs and Diangana who created space and relieved the pressing on them enabling them to play it forward better. For me, it’s the system that has led to a lot of our recent poor performances and defeats as there just hasn’t been the space or the attacking out ball for those guys to play. With more pace in the side RS in particular will improve... I thought he was better on Saturday but seem to be in the minority.

I think Robinson has to start up top, and then it can be any 3 from Phillips, Periera, Grosicki and Grady behind, with Krov and Edwards back up... we then have the option to bring Austin or HRK on should we need a more physical presence up top.
Reply
#36
Actually I don't even think we have a dilemma. We play 1 striker, and we have two guys primarily splitting the time that can get 15-20 each at roughly this pace. When you consider the other attacking options we have, and the style we are playing, I'm not sure there is anything wrong with this. We can score from all over the place. As Bilic has repeatedly pointed out, he doesn't want a team where we are relying on strikers to get 25 goals. He wants it spread out like it is.

I remain much more concerned about the defending. When we get promoted I really worry about teams continually getting 2-3 goals on us. I think our attack will be fine.
Reply
#37
(02-03-2020, 10:54 PM)scotbaggie Wrote: Actually I don't even think we have a dilemma. We play 1 striker, and we have two guys primarily splitting the time that can get 15-20 each at roughly this pace. When you consider the other attacking options we have, and the style we are playing, I'm not sure there is anything wrong with this. We can score from all over the place. As Bilic has repeatedly pointed out, he doesn't want a team where we are relying on strikers to get 25 goals. He wants it spread out like it is.

I remain much more concerned about the defending. When we get promoted I really worry about teams continually getting 2-3 goals on us. I think our attack will be fine.

I worry about claims like that  Big Grin
Reply
#38
(02-03-2020, 10:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:54 PM)scotbaggie Wrote: Actually I don't even think we have a dilemma. We play 1 striker, and we have two guys primarily splitting the time that can get 15-20 each at roughly this pace. When you consider the other attacking options we have, and the style we are playing, I'm not sure there is anything wrong with this. We can score from all over the place. As Bilic has repeatedly pointed out, he doesn't want a team where we are relying on strikers to get 25 goals. He wants it spread out like it is.

I remain much more concerned about the defending. When we get promoted I really worry about teams continually getting 2-3 goals on us. I think our attack will be fine.

I worry about claims like that  Big Grin

I think you have to have that belief and I bet Bilic has drummed it into the players from day 1.  If you don't believe you won't achieve. The positive thing is that every signing has only ever talked openly about promotion!
Reply
#39
I don’t think our problem is scoring.

How many clean sheets have we accumulated this season?
Reply
#40
(02-04-2020, 01:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I don’t think our problem is scoring.

How many clean sheets have we accumulated this season?

We're 14th with 6 clean sheets. Leeds have 12 and are first.

There are 25 better strikers in the Champ (in terms of goals scored), before Charlie.

It really beggars belief that we are the top scorers...I've never known anything like it. And joint 5th best defence.... So despite all of the 'feelings' we aren't that bad. We really are a team unit for the first time I think.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: