Ferguson again
#31
(02-03-2020, 12:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I imagine we believe he needs an operation, but know he can play perfectly fine in the short term with injections and alternate treatments. It’s not uncommon for players to delay non-essential surgery until the summer... we have form of doing this (Hegazi last season)

If we know he’s going, we clearly want to get value for money out of him whilst he’s here, and not pay for him to sit at home recovering so he’s fit and ready for another club. Imagine this would have been a factor in his people’s alleged preference for him not to rejoin from Palace on loan.

There are so many moving parts in this whole saga it really does have the potential to derail a season.

It really doesn't need to though. We have Peltier now to cover. 

Furguson should now play for the U23s until the end of the season if he is fit enough. He needs time away from the first team to reflect on his career.

Sitting in the stands and watching his mates get promoted (hopefully...) should be good food for thought.

We really don't need him at present. Let's get O'Shea bedded in now and Peltier up to speed. Gibbs will be back soon and Townsend is playing well.

Put simply we've moved on.
Reply
#32
(02-03-2020, 12:24 PM)Brandywell Wrote: Strange how Albion think he's ok to play, but Palace disagree and needs an urgent op

Might explain why Grady and Gibbs made short lived comebacks from injury

My thoughts were Palace used it as an excuse to drive the price down and we still wanted the full price.
Somewhere between the two is probably nearer the truth.
Palace didn't appear to be as black and white as "we don't want him" prolonged talks indicated a deal was possible, but at a discounted price.

Rushing players back after injury is always a risky business, but sometimes you never know until they are back.
Then of course the opposition do crunching tackles the first chance they get, doesn't make it any easier.
Reply
#33
Reply
#34
(02-03-2020, 11:58 AM)hudds Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 11:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:48 AM)fbaggy Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:46 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:11 AM)Peachy Wrote: Read this article this morning which suggests the Palace knee experts believe he should be operated on but we want to give it rest and see what happens.

Weird that he played against Cardiff. Didn't look to be carrying a knock. 

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...n-17674643

And apparently we’re willing to loan us back to him for the rest of the season, meaning he would be playing?

Whole thing is bizarre to the extreme

Cuzer
too many apostrophes, changes the whole dynamic of that sentence

I really don't buy this and reckon someone's just trying to stir the shit.  Palace are desperate for players and there's no way he'd have been loaned back.

(02-03-2020, 11:32 AM)Huggybear Wrote: Like it or not it is in the best interest of our club that he stops and signs a contract.The worst case scenario is that he goes abroad and we get as little as £250,000.Who is to say that a foreign club signs him and an English club buys him from there for million pound six months later .Total corruption and a bit like the Louie Barry situation.On the other hand he could go to a Premier League club at the end of the season and it would go to a tribunal where by the 7million rising to 11 million that Palace were going to pay has to be took into account.Fergusons knee injury makes it even more complicated because what happens if he does need surgery .As a club why should we be prepared to give him the operation when he is going to leave us at the end of the season.It really is very complicated.

We have a legal and moral obligation to look after his welfare - both physical and mental.  Probably need to see a shrink after all this.
He has a moral obligation as well, as well as an obligation to look after himself, so he and/or his agent should pay for a shrink, and any operation.  We can continue to pay his wages - £1k a week is massively in excess of the national average wage, so should be happy.

Er...it doesn’t quite work like that.
Reply
#35
(02-03-2020, 12:29 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 12:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I imagine we believe he needs an operation, but know he can play perfectly fine in the short term with injections and alternate treatments. It’s not uncommon for players to delay non-essential surgery until the summer... we have form of doing this (Hegazi last season)

If we know he’s going, we clearly want to get value for money out of him whilst he’s here, and not pay for him to sit at home recovering so he’s fit and ready for another club. Imagine this would have been a factor in his people’s alleged preference for him not to rejoin from Palace on loan.

There are so many moving parts in this whole saga it really does have the potential to derail a season.

It really doesn't need to though. We have Peltier now to cover. 

Furguson should now play for the U23s until the end of the season if he is fit enough. He needs time away from the first team to reflect on his career.

Sitting in the stands and watching his mates get promoted (hopefully...) should be good food for thought.

We really don't need him at present. Let's get O'Shea bedded in now and Peltier up to speed. Gibbs will be back soon and Townsend is playing well.

Put simply we've moved on.

Exactly. Also, we are generally good at looking after our players. Both Gayle and J-Rod were in excellent condition throughout our time with us and we have plenty of players near the top of the appearance charts. Gibbs is made of glass and won't play at 90%, Diangana was just bad luck.
Reply
#36
(02-03-2020, 01:29 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 11:58 AM)hudds Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 11:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:48 AM)fbaggy Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:46 AM)Cuzer Wrote: And apparently we’re willing to loan us back to him for the rest of the season, meaning he would be playing?

Whole thing is bizarre to the extreme

Cuzer
too many apostrophes, changes the whole dynamic of that sentence

I really don't buy this and reckon someone's just trying to stir the shit.  Palace are desperate for players and there's no way he'd have been loaned back.

(02-03-2020, 11:32 AM)Huggybear Wrote: Like it or not it is in the best interest of our club that he stops and signs a contract.The worst case scenario is that he goes abroad and we get as little as £250,000.Who is to say that a foreign club signs him and an English club buys him from there for million pound six months later .Total corruption and a bit like the Louie Barry situation.On the other hand he could go to a Premier League club at the end of the season and it would go to a tribunal where by the 7million rising to 11 million that Palace were going to pay has to be took into account.Fergusons knee injury makes it even more complicated because what happens if he does need surgery .As a club why should we be prepared to give him the operation when he is going to leave us at the end of the season.It really is very complicated.

We have a legal and moral obligation to look after his welfare - both physical and mental.  Probably need to see a shrink after all this.
He has a moral obligation as well, as well as an obligation to look after himself, so he and/or his agent should pay for a shrink, and any operation.  We can continue to pay his wages - £1k a week is massively in excess of the national average wage, so should be happy.

Er...it doesn’t quite work like that.

I know, more's the pity.
Reply
#37
The only bit I don't understand is if CP were willing to let him stay here for the rest of the season, surely the operation would be irrelevant (barring any insurable disasters) to CP's ability to play him next season as he'd have it in the close season? Unless it's a major operation, in which case, I would have thought they would have pulled out of the deal.

The only thing I can think of is there was a reduction in the fee to take into account a 'loan fee' which now we wanted paying up because he didn't want to play for us or even more far-fetched, he really fancied an operation and wouldn't play unless we let him!

Or, we've been told a load of rubbish...
Reply
#38
(02-03-2020, 11:58 AM)hudds Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 11:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:48 AM)fbaggy Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:46 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(02-03-2020, 10:11 AM)Peachy Wrote: Read this article this morning which suggests the Palace knee experts believe he should be operated on but we want to give it rest and see what happens.

Weird that he played against Cardiff. Didn't look to be carrying a knock. 

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...n-17674643

And apparently we’re willing to loan us back to him for the rest of the season, meaning he would be playing?

Whole thing is bizarre to the extreme

Cuzer
too many apostrophes, changes the whole dynamic of that sentence

I really don't buy this and reckon someone's just trying to stir the shit.  Palace are desperate for players and there's no way he'd have been loaned back.

(02-03-2020, 11:32 AM)Huggybear Wrote: Like it or not it is in the best interest of our club that he stops and signs a contract.The worst case scenario is that he goes abroad and we get as little as £250,000.Who is to say that a foreign club signs him and an English club buys him from there for million pound six months later .Total corruption and a bit like the Louie Barry situation.On the other hand he could go to a Premier League club at the end of the season and it would go to a tribunal where by the 7million rising to 11 million that Palace were going to pay has to be took into account.Fergusons knee injury makes it even more complicated because what happens if he does need surgery .As a club why should we be prepared to give him the operation when he is going to leave us at the end of the season.It really is very complicated.

We have a legal and moral obligation to look after his welfare - both physical and mental.  Probably need to see a shrink after all this.
He has a moral obligation as well, as well as an obligation to look after himself, so he and/or his agent should pay for a shrink, and any operation.  We can continue to pay his wages - £1k a week is massively in excess of the national average wage, so should be happy.

I would imagine it's all covered in his contract.   Best in my view that any treatment is under the supervision of WBA to protect our interests and if these experts in the US believe he needs surgery, it's probably worth a discussion.  May well 'solve' the issue and probably keeps him out for the rest of the season.

(02-03-2020, 02:35 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: The only bit I don't understand is if CP were willing to let him stay here for the rest of the season, surely the operation would be irrelevant (barring any insurable disasters) to CP's ability to play him next season as he'd have it in the close season? Unless it's a major operation, in which case, I would have thought they would have pulled out of the deal.

The only thing I can think of is there was a reduction in the fee to take into account a 'loan fee' which now we wanted paying up because he didn't want to play for us or even more far-fetched, he really fancied an operation and wouldn't play unless we let him!

Or, we've been told a load of rubbish...

The fact is he's failed a medical.  We'll never know all the ins-outs.
Reply
#39
(02-03-2020, 12:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I imagine we believe he needs an operation, but know he can play perfectly fine in the short term with injections and alternate treatments. It’s not uncommon for players to delay non-essential surgery until the summer... we have form of doing this (Hegazi last season)

If we know he’s going, we clearly want to get value for money out of him whilst he’s here, and not pay for him to sit at home recovering so he’s fit and ready for another club. Imagine this would have been a factor in his people’s alleged preference for him not to rejoin from Palace on loan.

There are so many moving parts in this whole saga it really does have the potential to derail a season.

Drama-Queen!  Big Grin
Reply
#40
(02-03-2020, 10:11 AM)Peachy Wrote: Read this article this morning which suggests the Palace knee experts believe he should be operated on but we want to give it rest and see what happens.

Weird that he played against Cardiff. Didn't look to be carrying a knock. 

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...n-17674643

Unless something has dramatically changed since the summer, we have arguably the best sports science department in British football with Leicester being the only other contender to that. I'd generally trust their opinions over other clubs, especially a club like Palace who's players are constantly injured.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: