Ratings
#11
Johnstone - 6 -distribution poor, not tested.

O’Shea - 5 - took 15 mins to know he’s not a fullback.
Ajayi - 7 - nice goal and several moments where his class showed
Bartley - 7.5 - leaders performance against a very poor side
Townsend - 7.5 - solid in defence and attack... no doubt people will still say he is shit

Sawyers - 7 - chased and harried - won loose balls, made tackles and did the defensive work... playing the ball forward was poor, moment of madness at death
Livermore - 7.5 - some lovely football, one great track back when Phillips had given up.

Phillips - 7 - at the centre of everything we did well, but switched off too often
Krov - 6.5 - lots of industry but no end product - lost possession overplaying at least 3 times.
Robinson -8 - MOTM - sign him up. Hard working, tracked back and won possession and created numerous good chances... with a couple games under his belt he will be an asset

Austin - 5 - forgot he was on the pitch. Other than penalties what does he offer.
Reply
#12
(02-01-2020, 08:20 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Not bad marks Cuz. Poor edgy first half. Much better 2nd after Hal stretched the game. Luton were dire - but we got the job done. Marks

SJ 5.5 dreadful kicking and more poor communication first half when he didn’t even sweep up routine through balls. Better 2nd

O’Shea 7 slow start but aggressive and athletic. Luton’s best players down his side

Townsend 6.5. All effort and steady enough. Lack of pace an issue as got done by the diagonal a lot

Semi 7 way too casual first hour and skinned for penalty shout. Huge goal

Bartley 6.5 first rule of being a CH is not letting the ball bounce. Too casual at times and incredibly was trying to slow the game at 1-0 when we clearly needed a 2nd. 

Livermore 7 good effort and no nonsense. Keeps going when the team doesn’t

Sawyers 6.5 visibly more effort and moved ball better. One stupid moment 2 half

Krov 7 good first 45 and busy and energetic. Really needs to improve end product. Loads of bad decisions 2 half

Phillips 7 often flatters to deceive but aggressive today despite double marking. Poor corner but 2 great crosses

CR 7.5. Easily our pick first half. Good movement and energy. Got his shots off but faded last 15

Austin 5.5. So easy to nullify. Phillips should have put him in but just ineffective 

Hal 7.5. Changed the game. Simple linkplay and movement. Put himself about and made pitch bigger

Furlong 7. Did really well. Quick and gave us an out. Sensibly kept ball in Luton half last 10 - best way to defend a lead

Nail on head about Townsend, Manc. When he is at the top of his game he is an ok champ level full back. When he isn't he is poor. For as well as he did today his frailties aren't ever far away.
A mixed day, some pretty average performances most notably from Austin but thankfully some really good ones from Robinson, Krov and the outstanding Livermore. For those that doubt Jake then look at him today. Did not stop, worked his bollocks off and did the dirty side of the game so well. Covers for those around him and you can see why he has developed into a huge influence in the dressing room.
Perfect opponents today and fingers crossed that those returning/debuting next week add that extra quality for the Millwall game.
Reply
#13
Today was exactly as I expected.. Horrible conditions, nervy team and very nervy crowd.

Really pleased at how things panned out.
Reply
#14
The problem I have is Livermore, not because of his play or work rate either. It’s more that he keeps drifting out of position to cover players that don’t seem to want to do the dirty stuff. Countless times today he did it and left the middle wide open. I wish he’d do just us job and if others aren’t doing what they should then show them to be not working and get them subbed for someone that will. It’s an issue that keeps coming up. I get it’s a team game but it’s the same principle for them all.
Reply
#15
(02-01-2020, 10:27 PM)Lightnin Wrote: The problem I have is Livermore, not because of his play or work rate either. It’s more that he keeps drifting out of position to cover players that don’t seem to want to do the dirty stuff. Countless times today he did it and left the middle wide open. I wish he’d do just us job and if others aren’t doing what they should then show them to be not working and get them subbed for someone that will. It’s an issue that keeps coming up. I get it’s a team game but it’s the same principle for them all.

Good point to be fair. I think most of Livermore's mistakes are actually someone else mistakes he is covering for...
Reply
#16
Bond 10. The best keeper in all the land
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)