Another needless my point of vie thread
#1
We really don't need another one of these, but I didn't want to tag onto someone ese's thread, because the temptation is to respond to points already made.

I am a bit long in the tooth and have more and more come to enjoy football as a sport not a need for my team to win. Don't get me wrong i'm still nervous as a kitten if we are winning by one goal and we are heading into the last 10 mins, but I no longer get upset if results don't go our way. This may or may not mean my views offer a little more perspective.

For me the two main reasons why are results have fallen of a cliff are 
1 - least importantly, the defence has not improved through the season, which you would hope it would do, it may be getting worse. Big concern why this is happening, because it was the area of our play that provided the biggest opportunity for improvement.

2 - Far more crucially, the front 3 players for the team and particularly the centre forward have stopped playing well, in particular the movement of our front 3 is poor, they are just not offering Livermore, Sawyers and Perreria options, where before that was a strength. Losing Diangara has been a bigger loss than I thought it would be. Also the continual rotation of the fullbacks (for reasons beyond Bilic's control tbf) hasn't helped. No wonder Sawyers is passing sideways and backwards, it's the only way we can keep possession. It's why Perreria has started to run in to cul de sacs more often, there is nothing happening ahead of them. I have been surprised during this poor run, that Austin has been relegated almost to third choice striker. HRK did deserve to replace him during November, but his form has dropped of a cliff, and to my mind Austin moves defenders out of position better than either Zohore or HRK. 

The other thought I have and it is playing Devil's Advocate but would promotion this season be in the club;s best interest. There is so much more work needed in our squad re-building process. We are perhaps not as far forward as we thought we were. The fact that many are advocating Brunt and Barry should be in the first 11 (and maybe they are right) is an indication of how much work there is still to do.

On Bilic, I always thought it was a curious slightly leftfield appointment. And I do wonder what is strength as a manager is, he strikes me as someone who manages through his big personality, rather than good strategizing or coaching. Not sure any player as improved performance as the season as progressed. That said I do like him, and as a club we do have to get out of the habit of changing the manager every time there is a period of poor results. For me there should be no question (or discussion for that matter) of him losing his job during the current season.
Reply
#2
(01-29-2020, 11:26 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: We really don't need another one of these, but I didn't want to tag onto someone ese's thread, because the temptation is to respond to points already made.

I am a bit long in the tooth and have more and more come to enjoy football as a sport not a need for my team to win. Don't get me wrong i'm still nervous as a kitten if we are winning by one goal and we are heading into the last 10 mins, but I no longer get upset if results don't go our way. This may or may not mean my views offer a little more perspective.

For me the two main reasons why are results have fallen of a cliff are 
1 - least importantly, the defence has not improved through the season, which you would hope it would do, it may be getting worse. Big concern why this is happening, because it was the area of our play that provided the biggest opportunity for improvement.

2 - Far more crucially, the front 3 players for the team and particularly the centre forward have stopped playing well, in particular the movement of our front 3 is poor, they are just not offering Livermore, Sawyers and Perreria options, where before that was a strength. Losing Diangara has been a bigger loss than I thought it would be. Also the continual rotation of the fullbacks (for reasons beyond Bilic's control tbf) hasn't helped. No wonder Sawyers is passing sideways and backwards, it's the only way we can keep possession. It's why Perreria has started to run in to cul de sacs more often, there is nothing happening ahead of them. I have been surprised during this poor run, that Austin has been relegated almost to third choice striker. HRK did deserve to replace him during November, but his form has dropped of a cliff, and to my mind Austin moves defenders out of position better than either Zohore or HRK. 

The other thought I have and it is playing Devil's Advocate but would promotion this season be in the club;s best interest. There is so much more work needed in our squad re-building process. We are perhaps not as far forward as we thought we were. The fact that many are advocating Brunt and Barry should be in the first 11 (and maybe they are right) is an indication of how much work there is still to do.

On Bilic, I always thought it was a curious slightly leftfield appointment. And I do wonder what is strength as a manager is, he strikes me as someone who manages through his big personality, rather than good strategizing or coaching. Not sure any player as improved performance as the season as progressed. That said I do like him, and as a club we do have to get out of the habit of changing the manager every time there is a period of poor results. For me there should be no question (or discussion for that matter) of him losing his job during the current season.

I don't see how staying in this division helps the club in any way.
Reply
#3
Until last night I hadn't felt the old anger at a result for a very long long time. Just something about it last night that seems to have hit nerves and triggered responses. A bit like, enough is enough, kind of thing I think?

1. The defence, no matter who is playing keeps making the same errors. What do they work on in training? Do we have players who can play the dangerous balls in for them to practice clearing? Or do we play in practice as we play in the games? Ergo the defence aren't getting the practice they need? Surely not!?

2. I said ages ago that I wasn't going to slate our ineffective forwards anymore, but fugg me they make it inevitable. It just seems that when one of them has a good run they feel like Billy Big Balls and can then not bother for another few games, then they know they'll get a rest and then the next fella gets his shot, rinse and repeat. I guess when you have 3 options, and none of them are particularly great it's really hard to feel like needing to do your job all the time?

Devil's Advocate - Financial wise it is totally in the club's best interest, simply for the guaranteed parachute payments the year later. As it is, we may actually do better with the squad we have, as they will have less physical demands in the Prem and can show off their skills. From a fan's point of view, we already know what a struggle it will be, so I think for us another valiant missing out probably works best.

Bilic - I thought it wasn't a great appointment, and had my doubts, but he's won me round; although such is the nature of we fickle footy fans, that if he keeps on like this I can't see him being here next year, or even for the play offs if we get into them.
Reply
#4
In respect of point 1 I look at Liverpool under Klopp. The defence and keeper just weren't at the required level and no amount of "training" improved them. Liverpool are going great guns now that they have replaced those players with decent players.

So I would say don't expect our defending to improve until we have brought in better defenders.
Reply
#5
(01-29-2020, 11:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-29-2020, 11:26 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: We really don't need another one of these, but I didn't want to tag onto someone ese's thread, because the temptation is to respond to points already made.

I am a bit long in the tooth and have more and more come to enjoy football as a sport not a need for my team to win. Don't get me wrong i'm still nervous as a kitten if we are winning by one goal and we are heading into the last 10 mins, but I no longer get upset if results don't go our way. This may or may not mean my views offer a little more perspective.

For me the two main reasons why are results have fallen of a cliff are 
1 - least importantly, the defence has not improved through the season, which you would hope it would do, it may be getting worse. Big concern why this is happening, because it was the area of our play that provided the biggest opportunity for improvement.

2 - Far more crucially, the front 3 players for the team and particularly the centre forward have stopped playing well, in particular the movement of our front 3 is poor, they are just not offering Livermore, Sawyers and Perreria options, where before that was a strength. Losing Diangara has been a bigger loss than I thought it would be. Also the continual rotation of the fullbacks (for reasons beyond Bilic's control tbf) hasn't helped. No wonder Sawyers is passing sideways and backwards, it's the only way we can keep possession. It's why Perreria has started to run in to cul de sacs more often, there is nothing happening ahead of them. I have been surprised during this poor run, that Austin has been relegated almost to third choice striker. HRK did deserve to replace him during November, but his form has dropped of a cliff, and to my mind Austin moves defenders out of position better than either Zohore or HRK. 

The other thought I have and it is playing Devil's Advocate but would promotion this season be in the club;s best interest. There is so much more work needed in our squad re-building process. We are perhaps not as far forward as we thought we were. The fact that many are advocating Brunt and Barry should be in the first 11 (and maybe they are right) is an indication of how much work there is still to do.

On Bilic, I always thought it was a curious slightly leftfield appointment. And I do wonder what is strength as a manager is, he strikes me as someone who manages through his big personality, rather than good strategizing or coaching. Not sure any player as improved performance as the season as progressed. That said I do like him, and as a club we do have to get out of the habit of changing the manager every time there is a period of poor results. For me there should be no question (or discussion for that matter) of him losing his job during the current season.

I don't see how staying in this division helps the club in any way.

Why is it so difficult for people to understand why promotion is paramount to our future. (we need the money not the PL)
Reply
#6
(01-29-2020, 11:26 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: We really don't need another one of these, but I didn't want to tag onto someone ese's thread, because the temptation is to respond to points already made.

I am a bit long in the tooth and have more and more come to enjoy football as a sport not a need for my team to win. Don't get me wrong i'm still nervous as a kitten if we are winning by one goal and we are heading into the last 10 mins, but I no longer get upset if results don't go our way. This may or may not mean my views offer a little more perspective.

For me the two main reasons why are results have fallen of a cliff are 
1 - least importantly, the defence has not improved through the season, which you would hope it would do, it may be getting worse. Big concern why this is happening, because it was the area of our play that provided the biggest opportunity for improvement.

2 - Far more crucially, the front 3 players for the team and particularly the centre forward have stopped playing well, in particular the movement of our front 3 is poor, they are just not offering Livermore, Sawyers and Perreria options, where before that was a strength. Losing Diangara has been a bigger loss than I thought it would be. Also the continual rotation of the fullbacks (for reasons beyond Bilic's control tbf) hasn't helped. No wonder Sawyers is passing sideways and backwards, it's the only way we can keep possession. It's why Perreria has started to run in to cul de sacs more often, there is nothing happening ahead of them. I have been surprised during this poor run, that Austin has been relegated almost to third choice striker. HRK did deserve to replace him during November, but his form has dropped of a cliff, and to my mind Austin moves defenders out of position better than either Zohore or HRK. 

The other thought I have and it is playing Devil's Advocate but would promotion this season be in the club;s best interest. There is so much more work needed in our squad re-building process. We are perhaps not as far forward as we thought we were. The fact that many are advocating Brunt and Barry should be in the first 11 (and maybe they are right) is an indication of how much work there is still to do.

On Bilic, I always thought it was a curious slightly leftfield appointment. And I do wonder what is strength as a manager is, he strikes me as someone who manages through his big personality, rather than good strategizing or coaching. Not sure any player as improved performance as the season as progressed. That said I do like him, and as a club we do have to get out of the habit of changing the manager every time there is a period of poor results. For me there should be no question (or discussion for that matter) of him losing his job during the current season.

Agree, the Austin thing is baffling. He comes in, he scores, and back to the bench. Say what you want he is our leading scorer, yet he plays 15 minutes per match.

Truth is without Perriera and Grady we are a mid-table squad.
Reply
#7
Think your wrong on point 1, by saying less importantly,

A solid defence is MOST important, its your defence thats gets you through times when your attackers arent performing where you scrape out 0-0 or 1-0's.

We concede silly free kicks and are conceding far to many set pieces.

I wonder whether NOT conceding set pieces goes hand in hand with SCORING FROM setpieces? Because we dont score enough of them either.


My worry is Bilic hasnt improved our defence and is only looking at attacking options?
Reply
#8
What is strikingly strange re' point 1 Shabby is we have two very well seasoned and experienced Defenders on the main coaching team in Slaven and Julian. One would have certainly thought defensive errors would have been thoroughly ironed out by now. Any can accept a genuine mistake at the back, but the consistent fug ups and lapses in concentration are starting to grain the fans.

It's a mystery as to why these fug ups and concentration lapses are continually allowed to happen!
Reply
#9
(01-29-2020, 12:34 PM)scotbaggie Wrote: Truth is without Perriera and Grady we are a mid-table squad.

This. Absolutely this. We have some decent players but we only have two match winners. Without both we look utterly devoid of creativity. Nothing at all. Both Grady and Pereira can create something from nothing.

Let's hope Robinson adds another dimension to us because boy do we need it.
Reply
#10
(01-29-2020, 12:49 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: What is strikingly strange re' point 1 Shabby is we have two very well seasoned and experienced Defenders on the main coaching team in Slaven and Julian. One would have certainly thought defensive errors would have been thoroughly ironed out by now. Any can accept a genuine mistake at the back, but the consistent fug ups and lapses in concentration are starting to grain the fans.

It's a mystery as to why these fug ups and concentration lapses are continually allowed to happen!

Didn't we say / think similar when we last had a solid defender in as manager? Ermmm last season. Maybe our defensive players just aren't as good as we think...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)