Tonight’s marks...
#1
Typical Albion eh? The result and performance we all feared, and have seen soooooo many times over the years we decided to drop in, whilst live on TV and a chance to put daylight between us and third

Credit to Stoke, they’re mainly shite but they defended superbly and worked their bollocks off, 7touches in our 18 yard box and they win 1-0, to give a defensive side a goal lead from sloppiness is unforgivable in this league

Slav sounded frustrated with the club over no signings post game, also no comment it seems on why Ferguson was omitted completely, doesn’t look good, as for Gradys injury terrible timing and just adds to the intrigue with the porn barrons and what happens with him these next 2 weeks


Johnson 5 Not his fault for the goal but to get two hands on the shot he should have kept it out, nothing else to do

Furlong 7* Seemed to want it more than most, mixed bag with his crosses but tried hard and always presented himself as an option

Townsend 3 Oh dear, defended him to the hilt but so poor tonight, slow to react for goal, touch poor, crossing terrible, one 8nstance in the second half when we created an overlap on the left and he went backwards was criminal, love his endeavor just not good enough

Hegazi 4 Gets his chance to stake a claim and makes a basic mistake for the goal,tried to atone for error but the damage had already been done

Bartley 5 Some decent distribution at times in the second half but form has dipped from earlier in season

Livermore 5 One to forget, touch seemed off, sloppy pass led to Stoke breaking for goal, long range efforts well off target

Sawyers 6 Always showing for ball, too many passes sideways and comfortable, did try to instigate  a comeback in the 2nd half, seems to have rediscovered his early season form which is encouraging 

Grady N/A gutted for him....and us!

Pereira 6 Sublime skill and movement as always but shooting poor, hopefully elbow comes to nothing as losing him and Grady would be a disaster 

Phillips 5 Form is poor at the minute, had flashes tonight but just not hurting teams enough currently

HRK 6 Thought he was our best player with Furlong before being withdrawn, worked hard, tried to make things happen, some great hold up play and close control against a physical Stoke back line

Subs

Zahore 4 Gets a chance, big call from Bilic to bring h8m on and he just doesn’t work hard enough, has it all, pace power, decent in air, just seems to lack motivation and desire, two things you can’t coach!

Austin 4 Offered nothing but a poor touch

Brunt 6 Massive improvement down our left when he came on, some great distribution and crosses into their box

Let’s hope we get a couple in before Cardiff as the players need a lift as well as the supporters, 4 points from 18 as it stands

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#2
(01-20-2020, 11:56 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Typical Albion eh? The result and performance we all feared, and have seen soooooo many times over the years we decided to drop in, whilst live on TV and a chance to put daylight between us and third

Credit to Stoke, they’re mainly shite but they defended superbly and worked their bollocks off, 7touches in our 18 yard box and they win 1-0, to give a defensive side a goal lead from sloppiness is unforgivable in this league

Slav sounded frustrated with the club over no signings post game, also no comment it seems on why Ferguson was omitted completely, doesn’t look good, as for Gradys injury terrible timing and just adds to the intrigue with the porn barrons and what happens with him these next 2 weeks


Johnson 5 Not his fault for the goal but to get two hands on the shot he should have kept it out, nothing else to do

Furlong 7* Seemed to want it more than most, mixed bag with his crosses but tried hard and always presented himself as an option

Townsend 3 Oh dear, defended him to the hilt but so poor tonight, slow to react for goal, touch poor, crossing terrible, one 8nstance in the second half when we created an overlap on the left and he went backwards was criminal, love his endeavor just not good enough

Hegazi 4 Gets his chance to stake a claim and makes a basic mistake for the goal,tried to atone for error but the damage had already been done

Bartley 5 Some decent distribution at times in the second half but form has dipped from earlier in season

Livermore 5 One to forget, touch seemed off, sloppy pass led to Stoke breaking for goal, long range efforts well off target

Sawyers 6 Always showing for ball, too many passes sideways and comfortable, did try to instigate  a comeback in the 2nd half, seems to have rediscovered his early season form which is encouraging 

Grady N/A gutted for him....and us!

Pereira 6 Sublime skill and movement as always but shooting poor, hopefully elbow comes to nothing as losing him and Grady would be a disaster 

Phillips 5 Form is poor at the minute, had flashes tonight but just not hurting teams enough currently

HRK 6 Thought he was our best player with Furlong before being withdrawn, worked hard, tried to make things happen, some great hold up play and close control against a physical Stoke back line

Subs

Zahore 4 Gets a chance, big call from Bilic to bring h8m on and he just doesn’t work hard enough, has it all, pace power, decent in air, just seems to lack motivation and desire, two things you can’t coach!

Austin 4 Offered nothing but a poor touch

Brunt 6 Massive improvement down our left when he came on, some great distribution and crosses into their box

Let’s hope we get a couple in before Cardiff as the players need a lift as well as the supporters, 4 points from 18 as it stands

Cuzer

Nailed it. Couldn't argue with anything on there inc marks.
Reply
#3
Spot on Cuzer, can't argue with any of that.
Reply
#4
Agree re Brunt. With Gibbs out and Ferguson unavailable he is a more than good enough 3rd choice. Apart from the goal, I didn't think Hegazi was too bad, although it must be said, Stoke only had 2 attempts so they practically had the night off. Kanu was probably our best player and even if he was knackered, offered more than Ken. Philips was ok but the lack of threat on the left meant we were too cramped on his side. Edwards instead of Ken would have given us more width and Philips more of a chance.
Reply
#5
Yes, remarks spot on

Would say I’ve gone on WM twice asking why Brunt hasn’t been used especially with results & performances being so poor in last 4/5 weeks. Understand if Gibbs was fit, but for Townsend to get picked ahead of him is like taking Katie Price on a date when you could have taken Michelle Keegan

Based on that tonight my view is completely vindicated, we were so much better down the left with Townsend off, who Ive always said was is better than a League 1 player ... but tonight he made me change my view, league 2 at best. How he’s ended up at a club like West Brom I just do not know

Zohore unfortunately just can’t get up to head the ball, nor provide the pace or power we were desperate for. What a disappointment & the opposite of what we needed

Livermore back to his worst I’m afraid

That was fundamentally about a lack of quality, we need a couples of quality players in to lift things otherwise it’s the play offs I’m afraid
Reply
#6
I'm not looking forward to the lottery of the playoffs tbh, and if we don't go up automatic after spending so long in the top 2 and the club don't back Bilic in the transfer window then Lai deserves to loose every fuggin penny he invested in us.
Reply
#7
Agree with all of those. One of Livermore’s worst games of the season IMO. Tempted to give him 4.
Reply
#8
Agreed broadly with the marks but:

Johnstone - how does he not save that. One thing to do all night - undroppable it seems but needs a rest. Butland showed what a proper keeper can do in the last 15. - 4
Bartley - poor night at the office. what's with all these Trent A-A cross field balls that have a 1 in 2 success rate - 4
Sawyers - what is it about the first half with him. Gave Livermore no support first half in their half. His lackadaisical style just rubs off on the whole tempo- don't like it - 5
Zohore - service was non existent but never involved and never bothered - 2

Bilic - 3
Got it so wrong after Diangana went off. Our success has come with those interchanges at pace in the wider areas - Diangana -Peirera -Phillips and the full backs. Once the Big Zzzz came on Kanu kept coming inside and we lost all shape. Townsend just doesn't have the close control or trickery to help Phillips out and let's face it Phillips blows out of his ass after 30 mins.
Austin coming on for Kanu was also the wrong sub.

What is with this Bartley to Hegazi to Bartley to Furlong back to Bartley hoof nonsense. Livermore and Sawyers just not providing a good outlet forward from the back 4. We've lost all confidence to pass through teams and those teams are doing a job on us.

Stoke were chite. Gifted them a goal and they just sat on their 18yd box and soaked it up. We never looked like scoring in all honesty and unless Bilic can shake things up we're in trouble. Costly gifted equalisers at Barnsley and Charlton meant this was a must win really given our run, the games to come and to take the pressure off.

We need 10 wins or so in the next 18 games. Looks a long way off that kind of return.
Reply
#9
Stoke did a job on us, fair enough. Slav got his subs wrong, agreed. One thing though, there were still enough snapshots around the box for anyone with any composure, to pick a spot. For all his undoubted talent, Pereira isn't a great finisher, and could have had a hat trick last night. And before anyone misquotes me, he was still our most effective player. I'd say, a striker would give us a huge lift and it's no coincidence that Leeds also want one.
Reply
#10
Broadly agree Cuzer.

Where I might disagree is I would have given Sawyers and Perreria an extra half or whole mark. They wanted the ball, always were willing to give a team mate in possession an option, but when they were in possession it was very rarely reciprocated.

Not sure I agree we looked better when Brunt came on, no reflection on him he was introduced too late, but there really wasn't any noticeable improvement in our play.

Also harsh on Townsend, he is an average championship player and a team seeking promotion need better than average, but he didn't warrant a 3.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: