Playing out from the back
#11
Remember some pundit writing about this last season, said its o.k if you have Beckenbauer and Baresi at the back.Otherwise, no.
Reply
#12
Playing out from the back has made it more exciting though! When it works it’s a joy,when it starts to go wrong I get palpitations and adrenaline kick! It should be made compulsory to play out from the back Smile
Reply
#13
Two problems with the fad of playing it out from the back.

1 any team with a competent manager but limited squad simply ignores ours and other teams desperate attempts to cajole them into over committing or losing shape.

2 you need good players to do it properly or you get caught out time after time which we do less this year but still do and it’s nit a tactic for a solid defence at Championship level imo.
Reply
#14
(01-12-2020, 03:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two problems with the fad of playing it out from the back.

1 any team with a competent manager but limited squad simply ignores ours and other teams desperate attempts to cajole them into over committing or losing shape.

2 you need good players to do it properly or you get caught out time after time which we do less this year but still do and it’s nit a tactic for a solid defence at Championship level imo.

Strange that teams are still coached to do it with little or no success
Reply
#15
(01-12-2020, 03:20 PM)oldun Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 03:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two problems with the fad of playing it out from the back.

1 any team with a competent manager but limited squad simply ignores ours and other teams desperate attempts to cajole them into over committing or losing shape.

2 you need good players to do it properly or you get caught out time after time which we do less this year but still do and it’s nit a tactic for a solid defence at Championship level imo.

Strange that teams are still coached to do it with little or no success

Coaches seem to be like sheep with very little imagination. A couple of innovative managers / coaches develop newish tactics and within a year half the league are playing them. It’s like chef’s suddenly discovering foam, gels, dry ice etc
Reply
#16
So are you saying pulis is the way forward ?
Reply
#17
(01-12-2020, 03:29 PM)The liquidator Wrote: So are you saying pulis is the way forward ?

Well playing suicide in your own box isn't.

Look at the Bournemouth v Watford game today on 46 mins. Foster collects the ball, looks to bowl it short to a Centre Half. Ax he is about to play, he sees danger and stops. Everyone resets and he plays long.

It's a bit like the green cross code. You dont step off the kerb if a juggernaut is bearing down on you.
Reply
#18
(01-12-2020, 03:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 03:29 PM)The liquidator Wrote: So are you saying pulis is the way forward ?

Well playing suicide in your own box isn't.

Look at the Bournemouth v Watford game today on 46 mins. Foster collects the ball, looks to bowl it short to a Centre Half. Ax he is about to play, he sees danger and stops. Everyone resets and he plays long.

It's a bit like the green cross code. You dont step off the kerb if a juggernaut is bearing down on you.

Good analogy that
Reply
#19
(01-12-2020, 03:29 PM)The liquidator Wrote: So are you saying pulis is the way forward ?

No I’m saying play to the strengths of the players at hand. What is wrong with playing it down the channels if you have willing runners or long to a target man if those players are at your disposal. Managing is surely about getting the best from your squad?
Reply
#20
it's not a straight binary between POFTB or Pulisball though is it? I don't think we do either at the minute and IMO Johnstone will pick whichever seems the best option for distribution at the time, whether that be rolling it to a CB, pinging it to a winger, punting it long etc etc.

As has been alluded to, fashions come and go in football and currently making your keeper roll it to your CB seems to be it. I'm glad that we don't do it (always...) any more though.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)