Willock leaving?
#51
(01-07-2020, 01:47 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: I remember when abuse about players weight, misdemeanours and sexuality was used on the terraces to put off our opponents. If you think that calling out your own for all and sundry is good then crack on. It doesn't matter how much money someone earns they are still the same fellow members of the human race.

Jesus. I was talking about their training regime. How else can I say it? Again, you're ramping up the rhetoric by not only inappropriately implying societal body-shaming but also bizarrely linking it to sexual oriental discrimination in the same sentence. None of that is actually relevant to anything I said!

Having said that, hypothetically, if a player was fat (which yet again, I don't believe either Rondon or Livermore were) and it interfered with his ability to play football to the best of his ability, then I would absolutely call that out*. Why not? It would be unprofessional of the player and/or the training team

For absolute clarification, minor misdemeanours or a players sexuality (or lack of) wouldn't interfere with his ability to play the game, so why would I care? (as it happens, I'd also not shout them at opposition players, either. Even if it did 'put off' our opponents)



*metaphorically - on a football forum, screaming it at him in the stadium probably wouldn't help the team much!



Thinking about it, maybe we're talking at cross-purposes here. 

Are you saying we shouldn't say anything at the ground when we are supporting the team or we shouldn't say anything at all on a forum or anywhere?
Reply
#52
(01-07-2020, 01:31 PM)Uh Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 10:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 09:20 AM)Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 08:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Expect Willock and Tulloch to be greeted as ‘one of our own’ for a few matches but as soon as their form dips they will be labelled money grabbing, arrogant, lazy etc. Then some fans can start the cycle again and again whilst bemoaning young players not getting a chance!

Alternatively, that sudden change in demeanour and loss of form/focus when their agents start talking numbers of zeros is pure coincidence. 

As always, the truth is somewhere in the middle. 

For example, Bilić admitted he had to sit Harper down about his attitude and application. Sunday showed exactly why Harper isn’t in the team. Decent in possession, but woefully slow to react to the second ball. That wasn’t about lack of first team action, it’s always been the case. 

He needs to get out and play to see if he can learn that, because that’s what will determines his success in the future. He doesn’t offer enough to be a luxury player. 

Ferguson has also suddenly gone casual in his play. That certainly wasn’t the case early season. That could be down to the contract negotiations and having his”head turned”, or could also be down to him feeling established and a bit complacent. Probably a bit of both.

The fans criticism of our young players is long standing and predates Harper. As with any young person entering their career they are going to make mistakes and do some things better than others. The fact some fans are quick to judge, jump on negative bandwagons reflects badly on them. How many stupid things did they do at 18-23? How many worked hard all the time and stayed focused, how many wouldn’t be interested in earning more, how many wouldn’t take advice not necessarily in their long term interest? The fickleness of fans and double standards is breathtaking at times.

Equally, they are not beyond criticism. This is the first team, going for promotion to the Premier League, not a development team. If criticism is fair and constructive, as I think mine was above, then it's valid. Sweeping generalisations about them being young are as ridiculous as writing them off as lazy, greedy or whatever.

It's not just young players. Our best players for many years in Mozza, Brunt, Foster were all massively under appreciated and frequently rubbished by certain clueless fans. J-Rod last year. Hodgson is remembered far more fondly now than at the time.

It's human nature to find fault.  When a player does three or four good things against us, we should be going all out to sign them. Once they're in our team, we look at their negatives and what they don't do. The longer they're here, the worse it gets. Look at Phillips, who is still a major player for us.

It applies in general life. For example, how many times do blokes chase a gorgeous woman for months and within two weeks they're moaning about her being a nause, despite all the evidence being there all along?!

Regardless of going for the title etc you can’t treat a seasoned pro at his prime with a kid of 18 finding his way in the game. They may have the talent but consistency and mental toughness usually comes with time and many fans have feck all patience and are miserable negative bastards. The constructive criticism argument is usually an excuse to have a good old moan at someone whether it’s justified or not.
Reply
#53
(01-07-2020, 02:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Regardless of going for the title etc you can’t treat a seasoned pro at his prime with a kid of 18 finding his way in the game. They may have the talent but consistency and mental toughness usually comes with time and many fans have feck all patience and are miserable negative bastards. The constructive criticism argument is usually an excuse to have a good old moan at someone whether it’s justified or not.

Possibly, but then it wouldn't actually be constructive criticism. It's something else.

I don't think we're 'miserable negative bastards'. We're actually just over-emotional. As someone else said, when they make their debut, they're often mom and the new wonder kid. Then the emotional blinkers wear off and the doubts set in. The reality is they were never that great and now they're not that bad. I suppose managers know this, which is why most tend to stick with the seasoned pros.

A side point, I genuinely don't know whether this is true. Do you think they might do well at first because the opposition don't know how to handle them, but as they get studied, their weaknesses become known by the opposition?
Reply
#54
(01-07-2020, 02:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 01:31 PM)Uh Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 10:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 09:20 AM)Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 08:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Expect Willock and Tulloch to be greeted as ‘one of our own’ for a few matches but as soon as their form dips they will be labelled money grabbing, arrogant, lazy etc. Then some fans can start the cycle again and again whilst bemoaning young players not getting a chance!

Alternatively, that sudden change in demeanour and loss of form/focus when their agents start talking numbers of zeros is pure coincidence. 

As always, the truth is somewhere in the middle. 

For example, Bilić admitted he had to sit Harper down about his attitude and application. Sunday showed exactly why Harper isn’t in the team. Decent in possession, but woefully slow to react to the second ball. That wasn’t about lack of first team action, it’s always been the case. 

He needs to get out and play to see if he can learn that, because that’s what will determines his success in the future. He doesn’t offer enough to be a luxury player. 

Ferguson has also suddenly gone casual in his play. That certainly wasn’t the case early season. That could be down to the contract negotiations and having his”head turned”, or could also be down to him feeling established and a bit complacent. Probably a bit of both.

The fans criticism of our young players is long standing and predates Harper. As with any young person entering their career they are going to make mistakes and do some things better than others. The fact some fans are quick to judge, jump on negative bandwagons reflects badly on them. How many stupid things did they do at 18-23? How many worked hard all the time and stayed focused, how many wouldn’t be interested in earning more, how many wouldn’t take advice not necessarily in their long term interest? The fickleness of fans and double standards is breathtaking at times.

Equally, they are not beyond criticism. This is the first team, going for promotion to the Premier League, not a development team. If criticism is fair and constructive, as I think mine was above, then it's valid. Sweeping generalisations about them being young are as ridiculous as writing them off as lazy, greedy or whatever.

It's not just young players. Our best players for many years in Mozza, Brunt, Foster were all massively under appreciated and frequently rubbished by certain clueless fans. J-Rod last year. Hodgson is remembered far more fondly now than at the time.

It's human nature to find fault.  When a player does three or four good things against us, we should be going all out to sign them. Once they're in our team, we look at their negatives and what they don't do. The longer they're here, the worse it gets. Look at Phillips, who is still a major player for us.

It applies in general life. For example, how many times do blokes chase a gorgeous woman for months and within two weeks they're moaning about her being a nause, despite all the evidence being there all along?!

Regardless of going for the title etc you can’t treat a seasoned pro at his prime with a kid of 18 finding his way in the game. They may have the talent but consistency and mental toughness usually comes with time and many fans have feck all patience and are miserable negative bastards. The constructive criticism argument is usually an excuse to have a good old moan at someone whether it’s justified or not.

I don't slag off players at the ground unless they do something stupid or ill-disciplined - e.g. I called HRK a fucking stupid twat at Derby last season for getting sent off. Mistakes happen in game and I despair at some of the reactions.

However, discussing things on here is what this place is about.  Highlight where my criticism isn't constructive before dismissing it with yet another sweeping generalisation. 

A quick read through our exchange highlights which one of us is having a "good old moan" and who isn't.
Reply
#55
Over emotional = pant pissing, moaning, knee jerking and over critical
Reply
#56
(01-07-2020, 02:49 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 02:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Regardless of going for the title etc you can’t treat a seasoned pro at his prime with a kid of 18 finding his way in the game. They may have the talent but consistency and mental toughness usually comes with time and many fans have feck all patience and are miserable negative bastards. The constructive criticism argument is usually an excuse to have a good old moan at someone whether it’s justified or not.

Possibly, but then it wouldn't actually be constructive criticism. It's something else.

I don't think we're 'miserable negative bastards'. We're actually just over-emotional. As someone else said, when they make their debut, they're often mom and the new wonder kid. Then the emotional blinkers wear off and the doubts set in. The reality is they were never that great and now they're not that bad. I suppose managers know this, which is why most tend to stick with the seasoned pros.

A side point, I genuinely don't know whether this is true. Do you think they might do well at first because the opposition don't know how to handle them, but as they get studied, their weaknesses become known by the opposition?

A little bit of both I think. Look at Rooney's debut goal for Everton, he's given acres of space to pick his spot and wallop it. Yes it's a good strike, but nobody at that level should be given that much space that distance from goal, they completely underestimated him.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#57
(01-07-2020, 02:59 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Over emotional = pant pissing, moaning, knee jerking and over critical

....and hyperbolic, dogmatic, slavering praise  Wink

But that's football...
Reply
#58
(01-07-2020, 01:09 PM)hudds Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 01:02 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Club and international managers, trainers, dieticians and physios don't think they're overweight or shite but some Internet gobshite decides they are ffs. If you had to tell it them to their faces it would be different I'm sure. Easy from the safety of your device. If they wear the stripes, get behind them. Leave barracking your own to the twats not far from us

How do you know what the club's people think?  They may well have taken a view that diet/weight and/or training needed tailoring.  Moreover, it's not being abusive or a gobshite to form a view of a player's physique and attributes as a paying patron of the club. 

FWIW, Charlie Austin looked like he was carrying a stone at least.  And I would discuss it with him if the situation arose.  Though I fancy that is a remote contingency.

I believe some Charlton fans were having this discussion with him on Sunday and he gestured his disagreement in return.
Reply
#59
I don't think I'd be in a hurry to discuss Charlies' weight with him.....
Reply
#60
(01-07-2020, 06:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I don't think I'd be in a hurry to discuss Charlies' weight with him.....

It's how you do it.  You could discuss how his training is going and how you lost some weight that needed shifting (hint).  Or just say "I bet it's all the pies..." Or - You might want to read their book; or perhaps not": https://www.theguardian.com/food/2020/ja...or-success
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: