Willock leaving?
#41
It's not only the youngsters, the fan base goes through love ins and hates with any player. Since we got relegated the knife throwing has become more random.
Livermore was a target for the boo boys, lazy slow and fat.
Brunt was useless and should have retired years ago.
Mozza was always absent and was only fit when his contract was up for discussion.
Phillips had the heart of a pea IIRC he was scared to tackle and only played half of a season.
J Rod was useless and only scored penalties (apart from his handball of course)
Hegazi was a donkey and needed to go back to Egypt with his buddy Gbor.
Townsend looked to be a great buy. Now he's rubbish.
McCauley wasn't trying anymore.
Johnstone has more monkeys on his back then the local Safari Park has.
All of our forwards are carp, new signings Zohore / Austin are slow and a waste of money, HRK is useless and should never start.

All good players and as they are baggies we should love them all.
Reply
#42
(01-07-2020, 11:33 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: It's not only the youngsters, the fan base goes through love ins and hates with any player...

All good players and as they are baggies we should love them all.

I don't accept that being a fan means you should 'love them all'. I can think of a few players that don't deserve it. ( I'm not thinking of any current players, here)

Mindless abuse is one thing, but I've not got a problem with constructive criticism that's backed up with observation.

There's a few comments there that you listed that have some substance in their criticism.

As an example, Rondon and livermore definitely improved after they lost substantial weight. I'm absolutely not saying they were fat before, but their exercise regime definitely changed and they carried less muscle.

Is that sort of criticism allowed? For that matter, are we allowed to criticise the manager, the director or the ticketing staff?

If you were talking about schoolboy football you would have a point, but these players get such ridiculous sums of money because the beauty of the game they play engages so many people and the game is open to so much 'interpretation'. If you take away peoples ability to make such debate, you would also take away the bulk of the interest and with it the players salaries.
Reply
#43
(01-07-2020, 11:55 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 11:33 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: It's not only the youngsters, the fan base goes through love ins and hates with any player...

All good players and as they are baggies we should love them all.

I don't accept that being a fan means you should 'love them all'. I can think of a few players that don't deserve it. ( I'm not thinking of any current players, here)

Mindless abuse is one thing, but I've not got a problem with constructive criticism that's backed up with observation.

There's a few comments there that you listed that have some substance in their criticism.

As an example, Rondon and livermore definitely improved after they lost substantial weight. I'm absolutely not saying they were fat before, but their exercise regime definitely changed and they carried less muscle.

Is that sort of criticism allowed? For that matter, are we allowed to criticise the manager, the director or the ticketing staff?

If you were talking about schoolboy football you would have a point, but these players get such ridiculous sums of money because the beauty of the game they play engages so many people and the game is open to so much 'interpretation'. If you take away peoples ability to make such debate, you would also take away the bulk of the interest and with it the players salaries.

While I fully respect your opinion and understand your thoughts. I'm of the opinion all criticism should be directed at any of the other football clubs players in the championship. (Plenty to choose from) Never our own, not in public anyway. But that's just me - old gits thinking probably.
Reply
#44
Club and international managers, trainers, dieticians and physios don't think they're overweight or shite but some Internet gobshite decides they are ffs. If you had to tell it them to their faces it would be different I'm sure. Easy from the safety of your device. If they wear the stripes, get behind them. Leave barracking your own to the twats not far from us
Reply
#45
(01-07-2020, 01:02 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Club and international managers, trainers, dieticians and physios don't think they're overweight or shite but some Internet gobshite decides they are ffs. If you had to tell it them to their faces it would be different I'm sure. Easy from the safety of your device. If they wear the stripes, get behind them. Leave barracking your own to the twats not far from us

How do you know what the club's people think?  They may well have taken a view that diet/weight and/or training needed tailoring.  Moreover, it's not being abusive or a gobshite to form a view of a player's physique and attributes as a paying patron of the club. 

FWIW, Charlie Austin looked like he was carrying a stone at least.  And I would discuss it with him if the situation arose.  Though I fancy that is a remote contingency.
Reply
#46
(01-07-2020, 01:02 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Club and international managers, trainers, dieticians and physios don't think they're overweight or shite but some Internet gobshite decides they are ffs. If you had to tell it them to their faces it would be different I'm sure. Easy from the safety of your device. If they wear the stripes, get behind them. Leave barracking your own to the twats not far from us



This is what I mean, people get emotive and use words like 'barracking' and jump to conclusions without actually reading criticism. There is a big difference between 'barracking' and honestly discussing the club. 

I made it very clear they weren't fat because I knew somebody would jump in to prove what a 'loyal' fan they are.

Are you saying you can't see that Rondon at Newcastle and Livermore this year have a less muscular upper body than last season?

Somebody, somewhere, maybe the player themselves, has obviously changed their exercise regime and lessened the upper body training. It could be a coincidence, but it came at the same time as both players had an upturn in form.

I'm guessing the 'Club and international managers, trainers, dieticians and physios' did in fact, see a problem at west brom and newcastle and fixed it. I didn't see it at the time, but if I had, should I have kept quiet? Why?

In response to your comment, IF I was asked my opinion (which I wouldn't be) I would be quite happy to tell them to their face. As I would if I asked someone's to offer me constructive criticism. 

That's not barracking. There's nothing insulting or demotivating there. It's just discussing football. 

Here's another example, if we discussed team tactics against a particular team, would we be allowed to mention a players weaknesses relative to the opposition and how we should mitigate them? 

But ultimately, do you think the players really care or read this board? Players get paid a fortune because everybody has an opinion. They know that - that's the deal and they do very well out of it. They also know that most peoples opinion count for nothing.

If you're saying people shouldn't just be randomly insulted, I would absolutely agree. That's why I don't call other posters 'internet gobshites.'
Reply
#47
(01-07-2020, 10:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 09:20 AM)Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 08:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Expect Willock and Tulloch to be greeted as ‘one of our own’ for a few matches but as soon as their form dips they will be labelled money grabbing, arrogant, lazy etc. Then some fans can start the cycle again and again whilst bemoaning young players not getting a chance!

Alternatively, that sudden change in demeanour and loss of form/focus when their agents start talking numbers of zeros is pure coincidence. 

As always, the truth is somewhere in the middle. 

For example, Bilić admitted he had to sit Harper down about his attitude and application. Sunday showed exactly why Harper isn’t in the team. Decent in possession, but woefully slow to react to the second ball. That wasn’t about lack of first team action, it’s always been the case. 

He needs to get out and play to see if he can learn that, because that’s what will determines his success in the future. He doesn’t offer enough to be a luxury player. 

Ferguson has also suddenly gone casual in his play. That certainly wasn’t the case early season. That could be down to the contract negotiations and having his”head turned”, or could also be down to him feeling established and a bit complacent. Probably a bit of both.

The fans criticism of our young players is long standing and predates Harper. As with any young person entering their career they are going to make mistakes and do some things better than others. The fact some fans are quick to judge, jump on negative bandwagons reflects badly on them. How many stupid things did they do at 18-23? How many worked hard all the time and stayed focused, how many wouldn’t be interested in earning more, how many wouldn’t take advice not necessarily in their long term interest? The fickleness of fans and double standards is breathtaking at times.

Equally, they are not beyond criticism. This is the first team, going for promotion to the Premier League, not a development team. If criticism is fair and constructive, as I think mine was above, then it's valid. Sweeping generalisations about them being young are as ridiculous as writing them off as lazy, greedy or whatever.

It's not just young players. Our best players for many years in Mozza, Brunt, Foster were all massively under appreciated and frequently rubbished by certain clueless fans. J-Rod last year. Hodgson is remembered far more fondly now than at the time.

It's human nature to find fault.  When a player does three or four good things against us, we should be going all out to sign them. Once they're in our team, we look at their negatives and what they don't do. The longer they're here, the worse it gets. Look at Phillips, who is still a major player for us.

It applies in general life. For example, how many times do blokes chase a gorgeous woman for months and within two weeks they're moaning about her being a nause, despite all the evidence being there all along?!
Reply
#48
(01-07-2020, 01:31 PM)Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 10:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 09:20 AM)Statto Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 08:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Expect Willock and Tulloch to be greeted as ‘one of our own’ for a few matches but as soon as their form dips they will be labelled money grabbing, arrogant, lazy etc. Then some fans can start the cycle again and again whilst bemoaning young players not getting a chance!

Alternatively, that sudden change in demeanour and loss of form/focus when their agents start talking numbers of zeros is pure coincidence. 

As always, the truth is somewhere in the middle. 

For example, Bilić admitted he had to sit Harper down about his attitude and application. Sunday showed exactly why Harper isn’t in the team. Decent in possession, but woefully slow to react to the second ball. That wasn’t about lack of first team action, it’s always been the case. 

He needs to get out and play to see if he can learn that, because that’s what will determines his success in the future. He doesn’t offer enough to be a luxury player. 

Ferguson has also suddenly gone casual in his play. That certainly wasn’t the case early season. That could be down to the contract negotiations and having his”head turned”, or could also be down to him feeling established and a bit complacent. Probably a bit of both.

The fans criticism of our young players is long standing and predates Harper. As with any young person entering their career they are going to make mistakes and do some things better than others. The fact some fans are quick to judge, jump on negative bandwagons reflects badly on them. How many stupid things did they do at 18-23? How many worked hard all the time and stayed focused, how many wouldn’t be interested in earning more, how many wouldn’t take advice not necessarily in their long term interest? The fickleness of fans and double standards is breathtaking at times.

Equally, they are not beyond criticism. This is the first team, going for promotion to the Premier League, not a development team. If criticism is fair and constructive, as I think mine was above, then it's valid. Sweeping generalisations about them being young are as ridiculous as writing them off as lazy, greedy or whatever.

It's not just young players. Our best players for many years in Mozza, Brunt, Foster were all massively under appreciated and frequently rubbished by certain clueless fans. J-Rod last year. Hodgson is remembered far more fondly now than at the time.

It's human nature to find fault.  When a player does three or four good things against us, we should be going all out to sign them. Once they're in our team, we look at their negatives and what they don't do. The longer they're here, the worse it gets. Look at Phillips, who is still a major player for us.

It applies in general life. For example, how many times do blokes chase a gorgeous woman for months and within two weeks they're moaning about her being a nause, despite all the evidence being there all along?!

Bang on with all of that.

How many times does a youngster playing his first game get MOTM? It happens all the time because we initially focus on the positives. The more time goes on and you expect from the same player the more you notice negatives that were there all along. 

I've given up chasing women, pain in the arse all of them.  Cool
Reply
#49
I remember when abuse about players weight, misdemeanours and sexuality was used on the terraces to put off our opponents. If you think that calling out your own for all and sundry is good then crack on. It doesn't matter how much money someone earns they are still the same fellow members of the human race.
Reply
#50
(01-07-2020, 01:47 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: I remember when abuse about players weight, misdemeanours and sexuality was used on the terraces to put off our opponents. If you think that calling out your own for all and sundry is good then crack on. It doesn't matter how much money someone earns they are still the same fellow members of the human race.
 Crikey!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: