Just read this.
#11
(01-04-2020, 06:20 PM)Statto Wrote: Another player who the longer they are are here, people focus on their negatives. When Phillips plays well, so do we, and his importance to our shape is massive.

Him being knackered has coincided with us struggling to put teams away. The loss of Diangana recently has been amplified by this. Just like last year wasn’t just about losing Barnes.

Agreed. I've always maintained that the loss of Phillips last season was equally as damaging as losing Barnes, and that if Phillips hadn't been injured we would still have gone up.

It would be fantastic to sign Bowen but it would be a shame to lose Phillips into the bargain. Taking the longer view however and taking into account their respective ages, it would be a great deal. Can't see it happening though.
Reply
#12
(01-04-2020, 06:25 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-04-2020, 06:20 PM)Statto Wrote: Another player who the longer they are are here, people focus on their negatives. When Phillips plays well, so do we, and his importance to our shape is massive.

Him being knackered has coincided with us struggling to put teams away. The loss of Diangana recently has been amplified by this. Just like last year wasn’t just about losing Barnes.

I agree with this, except the fact that he gets knackered/injured at least once a season means we need to be looking at replacements.

He always seems to have a spell of 4-5 games out then takes another 4-5 games to get back up to speed we simply cannot afford this it crippled us last season, we must get replacements in on both flanks imho, plus if letting Phillips go means we get Bowen it would be a massive massive statement of intent from us this season.
Reply
#13
(01-04-2020, 06:20 PM)Statto Wrote: Another player who the longer they are are here, people focus on their negatives. When Phillips plays well, so do we, and his importance to our shape is massive.

Him being knackered has coincided with us struggling to put teams away. The loss of Diangana recently has been amplified by this. Just like last year wasn’t just about losing Barnes.

+1
Reply
#14
(01-04-2020, 06:27 PM)Statto Wrote:
(01-04-2020, 06:25 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-04-2020, 06:20 PM)Statto Wrote: Another player who the longer they are are here, people focus on their negatives. When Phillips plays well, so do we, and his importance to our shape is massive.

Him being knackered has coincided with us struggling to put teams away. The loss of Diangana recently has been amplified by this. Just like last year wasn’t just about losing Barnes.

I agree with this, except the fact that he gets knackered/injured at least once a season means we need to be looking at replacements.

If we are serious about promotion and Premier League survival, we need to be keeping him but looking at bringing in the likes of Bowen ahead of him in the pecking order.

I would normally agree, except I think that moving down in the pecking order would shatter Phillips already low confidence and he's not the sort of player you can bring in off the bench.
Reply
#15
Cant see this happening , would MP want to go to Hull and give up what is a excellent chance of prem football next season also couldnt see Hull paying him what we are and no disrepect to Hull but playing in a half empty stadium is hardly a exciting prospect .
Reply
#16
(01-04-2020, 06:33 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-04-2020, 06:20 PM)Statto Wrote: Another player who the longer they are are here, people focus on their negatives. When Phillips plays well, so do we, and his importance to our shape is massive.

Him being knackered has coincided with us struggling to put teams away. The loss of Diangana recently has been amplified by this. Just like last year wasn’t just about losing Barnes.

+1

I agree with most of this, if not all.

But the problem with Phillips is that there isn't a season when he doesn't lose fitness/form for a significant period of the season, which isn't good for a team that has been quite reliant on him from an attacking point of view.

This may be the first season when we are not over reliant on him and he has made a significant contribution in terms of goals scored despite not being in great form.

Overall I would prefer to keep him, but if the only way we could get a younger player with exciting potential is to let him go, then I might be persuaded that this would be for the best. Need to be sure about the quality of the incoming player mind.
Reply
#17
Wasn’t that long ago that Matty & Hal were having to do the corporate circuit, not even on the bench.
Sad to say but if you’re going to progress as a business you have to prune and grow; now is the time to be thinking about the 20/21 season surely?
Reply
#18
Philips leaving would be a mistake and a travesty
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)