The magic of the FA Cup
#11
(01-04-2020, 12:19 PM)col lard Wrote: What really pisses me off is the feeble attempts by Beeb and Sky to try and generate some interest in the history/traditions of the the competition that they did their very best to destroy. The FA have to shoulder their portion of the blame too. Semis-finals at Wembley should never have been allowed. All games should be played on the same day,at the same time,too.

Spot on !
The hypocrisy when they've all contributed to its decline.
I'm more sad than angry.
Albion's status within the game rests mostly on being a great Cup (the proper Cup) team.
It used to be that a Cup win at least equalled winning the league... hard to believe for anyone under 30!
Reply
#12
The league / Milk cup was always seen more as a game for fringe players.
From MY point of view, the cup competitions are only chance of winning any silverware. To that end we should field a fully strength team and at least give it a shot. Sure the big boys may well knock us out. But with the luck of the draw most of them will be knocked out each another.
I say go for it COYB.
It appears this season we should be focused on promotion, same last season and before that it was relegation. Rubbish absolute rubbish just excuses IMO.
Reply
#13
(01-04-2020, 09:36 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-04-2020, 08:57 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: It's gone hasn't it.
It certainly used to be the"biggest day in the football calendar". But I guess that was pre prem.
Devalued to the point where we are going to see clubs' reserve teams play each other.
You all know the gen.
The sad thing to me is that I don't much care.
I will if we get to the last few, and of course I want us to win.
But would I choose 3 points at Charlton over a cup win (if I had the choice!).
Sadly, I guess I would.
Shame...

I Love the FA Cup. Love it. But this season unfortunately we have to have eyes on promotion.

Charlton will rest loads too I'd imagine. It's been a long few weeks for the players and I can see a good few fringe players/youth getting a look in today in some capacity.

Still really hoping we win and have a run mind.

Charlton have a long injury list so a good opportunity to progress.
Reply
#14
The most annoying thing about 2008 was the fucking draw. Alecan pulled us out against moneybags Premier league Pompey when there were two other Champ sides in Barnsley and Millwall.
Reply
#15
(01-04-2020, 03:50 PM)Peachy Wrote: The most annoying thing about 2008 was the fucking draw. Alecan pulled us out against moneybags Premier league Pompey when there were two other Champ sides in Barnsley and Millwall.

Let's be honest though, we had it easy the whole way through.

Didn't we go all the way through to the semi's avoiding a PL team, until we finally met Pompey at Wembo?

Peterboro, Coventry, Bristol Rovers - it was a kind run.
Reply
#16
Carlisle and Hartlepool winning at HT - the magic is still there!
Reply
#17
I was there when we won it in 1968, The "King" gave their goalkeeper Gordon West no chance with the shot, my dream had come true, i was 11 years old, and believe me, it
 was a dream, of course, until i seen them going past the ground on the double decker showing us all the cup, what a fantastic day, i will treasure that forever, but as everyone
 else is saying......the magic has gone, and that's the reality, its lost its sparkle, saying that, i would love to see us reach the final one day again.
Reply
#18
(01-04-2020, 10:16 AM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(01-04-2020, 10:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: One of my greatest sadnesses as an Albion fan is that we never won those semis in 78 and 82. As a young lad then those defeats were excruciating.
However, by 2008 I really didn’t feel anywhere near as upset when we lost to Portsmouth as it meant so much less, even allowing for my adult attitude.
The truth is the FA Cup has been nothing but an irritance for years for clubs. It’s the riches of the Prem that has destroyed it.
A 3rd round tie at home used to mean 30,000 plus crowds and huge anticipation- now it’s 15,000 and minor interest in seeing the reserves.
Trying to pretend otherwise is delusional.
Only if you can get to the quarter finals does it become remotely interesting, but it’s almost inevitable that one of the big clubs will win it now. It’s a totally different competition to the one that it was a generation ago.
Really don’t care if we lose tomorrow at all.

Me too.
In 1978 after beating Forest in the quarters as a 10 year old all I wanted was to see us win the FA Cup. It was such a huge competition then. 1982 hurt more with the realisation it might not happen again.
My experience mirrors yours, Jack 

Also I've seen us lose 3 F A cup semis, and 1 League Cup. At 50 years old I question whether I will ever see us win anything meaningful in my lifetime.
Reply
#19
Fulham now 1 up against Vile. Personally I was hoping for a draw that would force both sides to play an extra game and a few more injuries for those fish eating tits
Reply
#20
(01-04-2020, 04:21 PM)Sotv Wrote: Fulham now 1 up against Vile. Personally I was hoping for a draw that would force both sides to play an extra game and a few more injuries for those fish eating tits

1-1 so you may be in luck
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)