*spoilers* Star Wars spoiler reviews / moans. *spoilers*
#11
It was pretty clear from the original title.

Why would you click on it if you were worried about spoilers?
Reply
#12
(12-20-2019, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote: It was pretty clear from the original title.

Why would you click on it if you were worried about spoilers?

I'm not even sorry if I've spoiled it for someone. The title mentioned spoilers. 

And, like you say, if it's a Star Wars thread and you're worried about spoilers, why click?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#13
(12-20-2019, 09:21 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote: It was pretty clear from the original title.

Why would you click on it if you were worried about spoilers?

I'm not even sorry if I've spoiled it for someone. The title mentioned spoilers. 

And, like you say, if it's a Star Wars thread and you're worried about spoilers, why click?

CIM will only believe spoilers if they’re written on the side of a bus anyway. 

The film was entertaining and just about tied all the loose ends together.

Dialogue was appalling even for Star Wars 
There wasn’t enough time to tell the story properly
Explanations for most things were wafer thin 
The Leia bits should have been rewritten rather than try and bodge things 
The new female assassin characters costume was an awful mix of Power Ranger and Flash Gordon
The Chewy is dead reaction by the crew was half hearted (shrug shoulders, boo hoo, oh let’s move on now five mins later)
Rey’s identity was signposted as soon as the lightning bolts left her hand 

Everything was rushed and turned up to 11. It looked great, paid respect to the original films but it’s way too lightweight compared to The Empire Strikes Back and almost every character was a cardboard cut whilst we zoomed from one planet and obvious plot twist to another. 

Like a 2-0 win against Preston at home it’s enjoyable but won’t live long in the memory.
Reply
#14
(12-20-2019, 09:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:21 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote: It was pretty clear from the original title.

Why would you click on it if you were worried about spoilers?

I'm not even sorry if I've spoiled it for someone. The title mentioned spoilers. 

And, like you say, if it's a Star Wars thread and you're worried about spoilers, why click?

CIM will only believe spoilers if they’re written on the side of a bus anyway. 

The film was entertaining and just about tied all the loose ends together.

Dialogue was appalling even for Star Wars 
There wasn’t enough time to tell the story properly
Explanations for most things were wafer thin 
The Leia bits should have been rewritten rather than try and bodge things 
The new female assassin characters costume was an awful mix of Power Ranger and Flash Gordon
The Chewy is dead reaction by the crew was half hearted (shrug shoulders, boo hoo, oh let’s move on now five mins later)
Rey’s identity was signposted as soon as the lightning bolts left her hand 

Everything was rushed and turned up to 11. It looked great, paid respect to the original films but it’s way too lightweight compared to The Empire Strikes Back and almost every character was a cardboard cut whilst we zoomed from one planet and obvious plot twist to another. 


Like a 2-0 win against Preston at home it’s enjoyable but won’t live long in the memory.

Cheers for the spoiler thread lads.

It sounds absolutely shit.

You've saved me the time and expense of going to see it for myself.

Bonus  Cool .
Reply
#15
(12-20-2019, 09:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:21 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote: It was pretty clear from the original title.

Why would you click on it if you were worried about spoilers?

I'm not even sorry if I've spoiled it for someone. The title mentioned spoilers. 

And, like you say, if it's a Star Wars thread and you're worried about spoilers, why click?

CIM will only believe spoilers if they’re written on the side of a bus anyway. 

The film was entertaining and just about tied all the loose ends together.

Dialogue was appalling even for Star Wars 
There wasn’t enough time to tell the story properly
Explanations for most things were wafer thin 
The Leia bits should have been rewritten rather than try and bodge things 
The new female assassin characters costume was an awful mix of Power Ranger and Flash Gordon
The Chewy is dead reaction by the crew was half hearted (shrug shoulders, boo hoo, oh let’s move on now five mins later)
Rey’s identity was signposted as soon as the lightning bolts left her hand 

Everything was rushed and turned up to 11. It looked great, paid respect to the original films but it’s way too lightweight compared to The Empire Strikes Back and almost every character was a cardboard cut whilst we zoomed from one planet and obvious plot twist to another. 

Like a 2-0 win against Preston at home it’s enjoyable but won’t live long in the memory.

Come on, you should know by now not to take death too seriously in Star Wars. Luke was laughing and joking hours after Obi Wan died. 

I'm not a fan of how Leia's death was dealt with. I do agree that, and other plot points, seemed rushed. 

Carrie and Leia deserved a better ending to Leia's story than that. 

As for your review, from a miserable git, like you, that's a fairly positive review.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#16
(12-20-2019, 07:27 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-19-2019, 10:03 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I enjoyed it... But boy oh boy it's so Disney...

(12-19-2019, 09:29 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I thought the Ren / Rey relationship was handled brilliantly throughout the trilogy. You could always tell that Ren would eventually turn to the good side, but I thought there was a chance Rey could turn to the darkside.

I knew they'd come together somehow, but thought it could have been done in a way that ended the force, as they brought balance to the force by coming together. 

I'm not sure I'm satisfied with Rey being Palatines granddaughter. Where was his child / children in the prequels? 

I would have liked more explanation as to how Palpatine stayed alive.

I'm not sure bringing Palpatine back was the right thing to do.

Hi son and daughter in law had fled and took Rey to Jakku, they covered that, not the conception ro any wife / mother stuff though... It's why Palpatine was hunting for them.

Palpatine basically channeled his inner Darth Palageius who had used the Force to cheat death ages before, it was a lost Sith thing.

No, I understood that. What I'm getting at, is the fact you'd have thought him having a love interest or a child would have been mentioned before now in the prequels or the original trilogy. 

Is it mentioned in any other cannon material, such as novels? 


That's just a minor gripe, as it seems the plot was shoehorned in rather than thought of since day 1.

I can't recall any other mention of him having family. As for shoehorned, I think all 3 sequels have been done that way. It may have been different had Carrie Fisher not died.

As I say for me it was the overtly Disneyfication of it that spoiled it a touch. Cramming in a new pointless robot (to sell more toys), extra cute creatures (to sell more toys) and then everything feeling a bit too convenient so that the heroes could win.

Personally I'd have left Rey and Kolo Toure to die, then it would have felt complete...no Sith, no Jedi = balance and no chance for more sequels when Disney feels the urges...As it is there is now one Jedi and no Sith, so the Sith have to rise again in the eternal battle for balance...

Dark Rey was much hotter than light Rey too!

As for the thread, anyone coming on here complaining needs shoeing, it was blatantly clear and obvious.

(12-20-2019, 11:59 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:21 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-20-2019, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote: It was pretty clear from the original title.

Why would you click on it if you were worried about spoilers?

I'm not even sorry if I've spoiled it for someone. The title mentioned spoilers. 

And, like you say, if it's a Star Wars thread and you're worried about spoilers, why click?

CIM will only believe spoilers if they’re written on the side of a bus anyway. 

The film was entertaining and just about tied all the loose ends together.

Dialogue was appalling even for Star Wars 
There wasn’t enough time to tell the story properly
Explanations for most things were wafer thin 
The Leia bits should have been rewritten rather than try and bodge things 
The new female assassin characters costume was an awful mix of Power Ranger and Flash Gordon
The Chewy is dead reaction by the crew was half hearted (shrug shoulders, boo hoo, oh let’s move on now five mins later)
Rey’s identity was signposted as soon as the lightning bolts left her hand 

Everything was rushed and turned up to 11. It looked great, paid respect to the original films but it’s way too lightweight compared to The Empire Strikes Back and almost every character was a cardboard cut whilst we zoomed from one planet and obvious plot twist to another. 

Like a 2-0 win against Preston at home it’s enjoyable but won’t live long in the memory.

Come on, you should know by now not to take death too seriously in Star Wars. Luke was laughing and joking hours after Obi Wan died. 

I'm not a fan of how Leia's death was dealt with. I do agree that, and other plot points, seemed rushed. 

Carrie and Leia deserved a better ending to Leia's story than that. 

As for your review, from a miserable git, like you, that's a fairly positive review.

I guess they were limited by the footage of her that they had and could work with? Especially after the previous resurrections through technology got panned. I thought they did what they could and it never felt jarring. Explaining that she'd trained with Luke cleared up the space walk from the previous movie too. She couldn't have lived.
Reply
#17
(12-20-2019, 08:56 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(12-19-2019, 09:29 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I thought the Ren / Rey relationship was handled brilliantly throughout the trilogy. You could always tell that Ren would eventually turn to the good side, but I thought there was a chance Rey could turn to the darkside.

I knew they'd come together somehow, but thought it could have been done in a way that ended the force, as they brought balance to the force by coming together. 

I'm not sure I'm satisfied with Rey being Palatines granddaughter. Where was his child / children in the prequels? 

I would have liked more explanation as to how Palpatine stayed alive.

I'm not sure bringing Palpatine back was the right thing to do.

Spoiler alert

Nothing gets past you, does it?
Reply
#18
Well it was certainly better than The Last Jedi!

I did quite enjoy it at the time and thought there was some good set piece bits in it. I liked the Rey / Ren parts.

On reflection though, I think what I found is that I really didn't care about the characters that much.

Considering the original trilogy were my favourite films as a child it felt a bit weird. I felt nonplussed when it looked as if Chewbacca had been blown up, and when Leia was on screen my first thought was that 'this is just CGI' - I know that sounds ironic given how much the films use CGI for alien characters.

I thought Hex being the spy was rushed, and I also there was no need to shoehorn so many original characters in. It just seemed like something to make older fans happy.

I also read online that the last word Ren/Ben said was 'dad' and there was still an hour of the film left to go!
Reply
#19
I'm with you Josh.

I liked it, much, much better than 8 which I really disliked.

Yeah it was a bit Disney but I enjoyed it and left happy.
Reply
#20
(12-21-2019, 04:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm with you Josh.

I liked it, much, much better than 8 which I really disliked.

Yeah it was a bit Disney but I enjoyed it and left happy.

Stop agreeing with me.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: