Democracy
#21
Agree Rick, it was just a simple calculation based on the numbers. I did try and see what the actual rules would have been aligned to the 2011 referendum but couldn't find anything.
Reply
#22
(12-13-2019, 01:01 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 11:06 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 09:19 AM)Sotv Wrote: And of course you would have posted this if the result was reversed Big Grin

It cuts both ways, it's not a blue or red thing so wind your neck in a little.  Quite the opposite in fact, as an example the Lib Dems would have their share of votes much more reflected than they currently do.  The argument is against both Labour & Tory, which is probably why it will never happen.

And for the record I didn't vote for Corbyn, but I would have been happy with a hung parliament, which is what "one person, one vote" proper democracy would have given.  Plenty other countries manage to work alliances of power.
FWIW i don't like the FPP system as it makes many votes worthless in most elections. 

 Last nights results are from an election in very unusual circumstances where the old party loyalties have been broken, so it was an exception to that rule but generally it holds true that in traditional safe seats, most votes are "wasted". 

PR would be more democratic but would lead to far more coalitions. In the short term i think we would see the kind of debacle we have recently with parties just out to stymie each other,  but long term i would hope they would figure out how to work together.

One word of warning is that whilst we may see a truer representation of support support for the parties like the lib dems / greens, we would also see that for fringe parties and even extreme ones could gain seats.

Maybe, or maybe people would think twice before voting for extremes, either way that would be democracy.  If enough people voted for the BNP or Far Left to give them seats then so be it. 

If Boris keeps aligning to the ERG rather than becoming a one-nation tory then I'd say we have the extremes in already.  Let's be honest no one really knows what he stands for and whether he'll be a centralist or a Rees-Mogg loon.
Reply
#23
(12-13-2019, 09:19 AM)Sotv Wrote: And of course you would have posted this if the result was reversed Big Grin

Lots of people would have. It's a travesty UKIP had 1 seat in 2015. FPTP is deeply unrepresentative and when your entire democratic process is built on representative democracy that's a major problem.
Reply
#24
(12-13-2019, 08:17 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Do we truly have one?

I was explaining to my daughter last night how the FPP system works and she can’t comprehend why one vote doesn’t count as one vote.

I then explained that the Brexit Party has only stood in Labour held areas, knowing they won’t win a single constituency, just so people who won’t vote Tory can vote for Brexit against Labour.  She thought that sounded morally and ethically corrupt.  Wait until Farage gets his reward...

Then I explained that the Tories will have a huge majority despite only getting mid-low 40% of the vote.  This blew her mind.

It’s elections like this with such resounding majorities from a minority of the vote that highlight the need for electoral reform.     

There has to be a better way than the SNP having over 8% of parliament with less votes than the Lib Dems, who get 2%.

We wouldn't have heard a peep out of you if the LDs were the largest party and revoked Art 50, as they would have seen it as a mandate to do.
Reply
#25
(12-13-2019, 09:25 AM)billybassett Wrote: The biggest scandal democratically is the 33% of people - nearly 15 million of them who couldn't be arsed to trundle down to their polling station and actually vote. Every one of them - unless they're on their deathbed  Big Grin - are a disgrace

But isn't that a product of the system? If you live in a constituency with a very large majority, your vote isn't actually worth anything.

Having said that, I still voted...

(12-13-2019, 01:01 PM)Sotv Wrote: One word of warning is that whilst we may see a truer representation of support support for the parties like the lib dems / greens, we would also see that for fringe parties and even extreme ones could gain seats.

Unfortunately, if people vote for an extreme party, then they get a seat. Like it or not that's democracy. Perhaps when it is out in the open it could actually be debated.

Of course, you could always outlaw very extreme parties.
Reply
#26
(12-13-2019, 01:58 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 09:25 AM)billybassett Wrote: The biggest scandal democratically is the 33% of people - nearly 15 million of them who couldn't be arsed to trundle down to their polling station and actually vote. Every one of them - unless they're on their deathbed  Big Grin - are a disgrace

But isn't that a product of the system? If you live in a constituency with a very large majority, your vote isn't actually worth anything.

Having said that, I still voted...

(12-13-2019, 01:01 PM)Sotv Wrote: One word of warning is that whilst we may see a truer representation of support support for the parties like the lib dems / greens, we would also see that for fringe parties and even extreme ones could gain seats.

Unfortunately, if people vote for an extreme party, then they get a seat. Like it or not that's democracy. Perhaps when it is out in the open it could actually be debated.

Of course, you could always outlaw very extreme parties.
yes i agree entirely, and i think it would also work to expose some of the false promises they make.
Reply
#27
FPTP isn't ideal but then again neither is any form of PR that I'm aware of. Imagine a 3 party scenario where 2 parties get 49% and the third just 2% - the third party holds completely disproportional power.
Reply
#28
(12-13-2019, 01:54 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 08:17 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Do we truly have one?

I was explaining to my daughter last night how the FPP system works and she can’t comprehend why one vote doesn’t count as one vote.

I then explained that the Brexit Party has only stood in Labour held areas, knowing they won’t win a single constituency, just so people who won’t vote Tory can vote for Brexit against Labour.  She thought that sounded morally and ethically corrupt.  Wait until Farage gets his reward...

Then I explained that the Tories will have a huge majority despite only getting mid-low 40% of the vote.  This blew her mind.

It’s elections like this with such resounding majorities from a minority of the vote that highlight the need for electoral reform.     

There has to be a better way than the SNP having over 8% of parliament with less votes than the Lib Dems, who get 2%.

We wouldn't have heard a peep out of you if the LDs were the largest party and revoked Art 50, as they would have seen it as a mandate to do.

You're right you wouldn't, had they received 50% of the vote. 

It's this false idea that any party has been given a mandate to govern with a large majority in Parliament when only a minority of people voted for them.  It's as numerically bonkers as 50,000 more nurses, 40 new hospitals, £350m per week etc.

When you live in a stronghold for either party then your vote doesn't really count, which is unfair and a majority government voted by a minority of the people is an oxymoron to democracy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)