Exit poll
#31
(12-12-2019, 11:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 10:49 PM)Ossian Wrote: Ditching Corbyn wouldn't in itself be the answer.

As long as Labour remains in the grip of people who believe the ideological purity of the message takes precedence over actually winning it will serve no useful purpose. Winning is everything: if you can't win you're impotent. Jeremy Corbyn might embody all of the most admirable qualities of Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma Ghandi and Clement Attlee (I don't think so - but he might!); what use is he right now? To any of the disadvantaged and unrepresented? None whatsoever.

Five years now to reacquire the centre, and fuck only knows what level of damage to fix at the end of that. If the left are serious about mending what needs mending - and god knows there's plenty to go at, and five more years of it to come - it would be a start if the party's activists could stop shouting things like "Blairite scum" at some of their own candidates.

In all honesty I despair: as a centre/left (Social Democrat if you like) my instincts are that I should be part of a large demographic - possibly even the largest. I actually feel like one of the last of a dying breed; a bit like the Scottish Wildcat, except at least a few people actually give a shit about the plight of the wildcat.

Bloody hell, I'm pissed off.

Exactly Ossian, since Corbyn and Momentum came to power and lurched to the left they became unelectable. One question that this result doesn’t answer is what people think they’ve actually won?

Stopping Corbyn. If you think the last 3 years has been a shambles, you imagine it under him.
Reply
#32
(12-12-2019, 11:05 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:03 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Imagine voting against the NHS.

Imagine falling for the nonsense that the NHS 'IS GONNA BE SOLD AND ALL HOSPITAL FOOD IS GONNA BE CHLORINATED CHICKEN!! OH MY GOD!!"

Be interesting to see the NHS function with a 4 day week.

Wait and see.
Reply
#33
(12-12-2019, 11:08 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:06 PM)strawman Wrote:  BBC exit poll seat by seat forecast says Jo Swinson is extremely likely to lose her seat to the SNP.

"I stand before you as candidate for Prime Minister."

I bet Chuka's on manoeuvres already.

He's still got the Greens, Brexit Party and Tories to join for a full house
Reply
#34
(12-12-2019, 11:06 PM)strawman Wrote:  BBC exit poll seat by seat forecast says Jo Swinson is extremely likely to lose her seat to the SNP.

Her hubby will be able to provide for the family.
Reply
#35
(12-12-2019, 11:09 PM)Hi Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 10:49 PM)Ossian Wrote: Ditching Corbyn wouldn't in itself be the answer.

As long as Labour remains in the grip of people who believe the ideological purity of the message takes precedence over actually winning it will serve no useful purpose. Winning is everything: if you can't win you're impotent. Jeremy Corbyn might embody all of the most admirable qualities of Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma Ghandi and Clement Attlee (I don't think so - but he might!); what use is he right now? To any of the disadvantaged and unrepresented? None whatsoever.

Five years now to reacquire the centre, and fuck only knows what level of damage to fix at the end of that. If the left are serious about mending what needs mending - and god knows there's plenty to go at, and five more years of it to come - it would be a start if the party's activists could stop shouting things like "Blairite scum" at some of their own candidates.

In all honesty I despair: as a centre/left (Social Democrat if you like) my instincts are that I should be part of a large demographic - possibly even the largest. I actually feel like one of the last of a dying breed; a bit like the Scottish Wildcat, except at least a few people actually give a shit about the plight of the wildcat.

Bloody hell, I'm pissed off.

Exactly Ossian, since Corbyn and Momentum came to power and lurched to the left they became unelectable. One question that this result doesn’t answer is what people think they’ve actually won?

Stopping Corbyn. If you think the last 3 years has been a shambles, you imagine it under him.

Neil I just want to live in a tolerant, fair, kind country. I’ve seen precious little of that for ten years. This Conservative Government now has five years to show the blue collar workers they really care about them and that Brexit is the golden goose it’s made out to be for them. As I said nowhere to hide now, no excuses.

I hope that Labour will now return a centre left party under a realistically electable leader to offer a proper opposition. Looks like I got the Villa top for Christmas Wink
Reply
#36
(12-12-2019, 11:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:09 PM)Hi Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 10:49 PM)Ossian Wrote: Ditching Corbyn wouldn't in itself be the answer.

As long as Labour remains in the grip of people who believe the ideological purity of the message takes precedence over actually winning it will serve no useful purpose. Winning is everything: if you can't win you're impotent. Jeremy Corbyn might embody all of the most admirable qualities of Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma Ghandi and Clement Attlee (I don't think so - but he might!); what use is he right now? To any of the disadvantaged and unrepresented? None whatsoever.

Five years now to reacquire the centre, and fuck only knows what level of damage to fix at the end of that. If the left are serious about mending what needs mending - and god knows there's plenty to go at, and five more years of it to come - it would be a start if the party's activists could stop shouting things like "Blairite scum" at some of their own candidates.

In all honesty I despair: as a centre/left (Social Democrat if you like) my instincts are that I should be part of a large demographic - possibly even the largest. I actually feel like one of the last of a dying breed; a bit like the Scottish Wildcat, except at least a few people actually give a shit about the plight of the wildcat.

Bloody hell, I'm pissed off.

Exactly Ossian, since Corbyn and Momentum came to power and lurched to the left they became unelectable. One question that this result doesn’t answer is what people think they’ve actually won?

Stopping Corbyn. If you think the last 3 years has been a shambles, you imagine it under him.

Neil I just want to live in a tolerant, fair, kind country. I’ve seen precious little of that for ten years. This Conservative Government now has five years to show the blue collar workers they really care about them and that Brexit is the golden goose it’s made out to be for them. As I said nowhere to hide now, no excuses.

I hope that Labour will now return a centre left party under a realistically electable leader to offer a proper opposition. Looks like I got the Villa top for Christmas Wink

A split on the cards, do you think...?

95% chance Swinson has lost her seat, Britain Elects is reporting.
Reply
#37
(12-12-2019, 11:21 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:09 PM)Hi Neil Parsley Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 11:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 10:49 PM)Ossian Wrote: Ditching Corbyn wouldn't in itself be the answer.

As long as Labour remains in the grip of people who believe the ideological purity of the message takes precedence over actually winning it will serve no useful purpose. Winning is everything: if you can't win you're impotent. Jeremy Corbyn might embody all of the most admirable qualities of Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma Ghandi and Clement Attlee (I don't think so - but he might!); what use is he right now? To any of the disadvantaged and unrepresented? None whatsoever.

Five years now to reacquire the centre, and fuck only knows what level of damage to fix at the end of that. If the left are serious about mending what needs mending - and god knows there's plenty to go at, and five more years of it to come - it would be a start if the party's activists could stop shouting things like "Blairite scum" at some of their own candidates.

In all honesty I despair: as a centre/left (Social Democrat if you like) my instincts are that I should be part of a large demographic - possibly even the largest. I actually feel like one of the last of a dying breed; a bit like the Scottish Wildcat, except at least a few people actually give a shit about the plight of the wildcat.

Bloody hell, I'm pissed off.

Exactly Ossian, since Corbyn and Momentum came to power and lurched to the left they became unelectable. One question that this result doesn’t answer is what people think they’ve actually won?

Stopping Corbyn. If you think the last 3 years has been a shambles, you imagine it under him.

Neil I just want to live in a tolerant, fair, kind country. I’ve seen precious little of that for ten years. This Conservative Government now has five years to show the blue collar workers they really care about them and that Brexit is the golden goose it’s made out to be for them. As I said nowhere to hide now, no excuses.

I hope that Labour will now return a centre left party under a realistically electable leader to offer a proper opposition. Looks like I got the Villa top for Christmas Wink

A split on the cards, do you think...?

Possibly because I can’t see Momentum having the grace to admit they were wrong. Nothing imo good comes from extreme politics be it left or right. They are one in the same.
Reply
#38
(12-12-2019, 10:49 PM)Ossian Wrote: Ditching Corbyn wouldn't in itself be the answer.

As long as Labour remains in the grip of people who believe the ideological purity of the message takes precedence over actually winning it will serve no useful purpose. Winning is everything: if you can't win you're impotent. Jeremy Corbyn might embody all of the most admirable qualities of Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma Ghandi and Clement Attlee (I don't think so - but he might!); what use is he right now? To any of the disadvantaged and unrepresented? None whatsoever.

Five years now to reacquire the centre, and fuck only knows what level of damage to fix at the end of that. If the left are serious about mending what needs mending - and god knows there's plenty to go at, and five more years of it to come - it would be a start if the party's activists could stop shouting things like "Blairite scum" at some of their own candidates.

In all honesty I despair: as a centre/left (Social Democrat if you like) my instincts are that I should be part of a large demographic - possibly even the largest. I actually feel like one of the last of a dying breed; a bit like the Scottish Wildcat, except at least a few people actually give a shit about the plight of the wildcat.

Bloody hell, I'm pissed off.

I understand that view. I come from a solid working class background , from an area that is solid working class but has had a Conservative MP for about 25 years FFS. 17 mines were shut in the area - by Harold Wilson in 1965. My Grancher and his 9 brothers being amongst them. Much other industry was subsequently lost but it is that fact that sticks in the craw. Until Labour regain the trust of those people and their ancestors they have no chance. They should start by accepting democratically derived decisions - like Brexit. Movements like Momentum do not have that intelligence. Their idealism gets in the way. I agree about a centre left consensus but it will never happen.
Reply
#39
Labour lost Blythe Valley
Reply
#40
Based on the narratives coming from the Labour and Lib Dem supporters:

Lib Dems -> Swinson is shit

Labour -> Is Corbyn wrong? No this is the Libs/Greens fault

And they wonder why they're doing shite...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)