Tonight
#11
(12-12-2019, 03:01 AM)scotbaggie Wrote: You guys are way too much on Austin, in my personal opinion. He made runs but there was no service because Krov cant control the middle and I'm not sure where Edward's and Phillip's were. He was isolated but still scored. I would be really tempted to try a formation  with Austin up top, HRK on for Phillip's and playing behind Austin. He could dish to Pererria, Austin, and Diangana. That's probably our most goal scoring line up. It also uses HRK and Austin's strengths

Does seem to be a bit of a scapegoat. No striker would've done much yesterday. Our wide players were non existent and Krovinovic isn't the sort of player who can do it all himself.
Reply
#12
(12-12-2019, 08:46 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 03:01 AM)scotbaggie Wrote: You guys are way too much on Austin, in my personal opinion. He made runs but there was no service because Krov cant control the middle and I'm not sure where Edward's and Phillip's were. He was isolated but still scored. I would be really tempted to try a formation  with Austin up top, HRK on for Phillip's and playing behind Austin. He could dish to Pererria, Austin, and Diangana. That's probably our most goal scoring line up. It also uses HRK and Austin's strengths

Does seem to be a bit of a scapegoat. No striker would've done much yesterday. Our wide players were non existent and Krovinovic isn't the sort of player who can do it all himself.

No striker would have done much, yet we were transformed once HRK came on for Austin.
Reply
#13
(12-12-2019, 08:46 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 03:01 AM)scotbaggie Wrote: You guys are way too much on Austin, in my personal opinion. He made runs but there was no service because Krov cant control the middle and I'm not sure where Edward's and Phillip's were. He was isolated but still scored. I would be really tempted to try a formation  with Austin up top, HRK on for Phillip's and playing behind Austin. He could dish to Pererria, Austin, and Diangana. That's probably our most goal scoring line up. It also uses HRK and Austin's strengths

Does seem to be a bit of a scapegoat. No striker would've done much yesterday. Our wide players were non existent and Krovinovic isn't the sort of player who can do it all himself.

I thought Austin was ok. I bet he was licking his lips after seeinging our creativity on Sunday and then looks around and sees Pereira and Diangana on the bench! Felt a bit sorry for him.

Took his goal very well and that's 4 in 4 for him. Can't see what the problem is myself.
Reply
#14
(12-12-2019, 09:01 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 08:46 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 03:01 AM)scotbaggie Wrote: You guys are way too much on Austin, in my personal opinion. He made runs but there was no service because Krov cant control the middle and I'm not sure where Edward's and Phillip's were. He was isolated but still scored. I would be really tempted to try a formation  with Austin up top, HRK on for Phillip's and playing behind Austin. He could dish to Pererria, Austin, and Diangana. That's probably our most goal scoring line up. It also uses HRK and Austin's strengths

Does seem to be a bit of a scapegoat. No striker would've done much yesterday. Our wide players were non existent and Krovinovic isn't the sort of player who can do it all himself.

No striker would have done much, yet we were transformed once HRK came on for Austin.

"Transformed", it was 1-1 when HRK came on. That has to be the most generous use of the word transformed I've ever seen. Did we have any shots on target after HRK came on? One maybe? and that was with Pereira behind him, not Krovinovic
Reply
#15
(12-11-2019, 11:45 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Ferguson. 5. Worst game yet. Caught out by cross field passes and gave the ball away. 

Sawyers. 6. Has his moments but way too casual and didn’t spread the ball quickly or accurately enough. Too many touches at times

Austin. 6. Lack of pace showed tonight and we were miles better when he went off. Took his goal well

Good marks, Manc.

Hate to say it but Nathan's performance bore all the hallmarks of someone who thinks he's made it. Harperesque. Sincerely hope I'm wrong.

Very rare to see 'Sawyers' and 'too many touches' in the same sentence. His performances this season have been marked out by the the fact he rarely has more than 2 touches at a time and the speed with which he moved the ball on. Very ponderous last night. When he performs, the team does, when he doesn't, well....

Feel sorry for Austin, I think the mind is willing but the body can't. Can't deny he still has a goalscoring instinct - can't believe he found a way through that wall to score. Noticed he kicked a water bottles and was steaming towards the changing rooms after he was taken off. Think someone must have said something to him and he ended up taking a place on the bench. Not sure if he was angry or frustrated.
Reply
#16
(12-12-2019, 09:05 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 09:01 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 08:46 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 03:01 AM)scotbaggie Wrote: You guys are way too much on Austin, in my personal opinion. He made runs but there was no service because Krov cant control the middle and I'm not sure where Edward's and Phillip's were. He was isolated but still scored. I would be really tempted to try a formation  with Austin up top, HRK on for Phillip's and playing behind Austin. He could dish to Pererria, Austin, and Diangana. That's probably our most goal scoring line up. It also uses HRK and Austin's strengths

Does seem to be a bit of a scapegoat. No striker would've done much yesterday. Our wide players were non existent and Krovinovic isn't the sort of player who can do it all himself.

No striker would have done much, yet we were transformed once HRK came on for Austin.

"Transformed", it was 1-1 when HRK came on. That has to be the most generous use of the word transformed I've ever seen. Did we have any shots on target after HRK came on? One maybe?

Transformed may be a bit excessive a word, however, HRK definitely made a difference for the good. He offered an outlet that Austin didn’t. He ran the channels, held it up well and brought others in to play.

I’m not an Austin hater. He has 4 in 4 and he’s worth a squad place. He just doesn’t offer much else, for me. HRK link play and enables other players to join further up the field. Austin should always be an option to come off the bench for me.
Reply
#17
(12-12-2019, 09:10 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 09:05 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 09:01 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 08:46 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 03:01 AM)scotbaggie Wrote: You guys are way too much on Austin, in my personal opinion. He made runs but there was no service because Krov cant control the middle and I'm not sure where Edward's and Phillip's were. He was isolated but still scored. I would be really tempted to try a formation  with Austin up top, HRK on for Phillip's and playing behind Austin. He could dish to Pererria, Austin, and Diangana. That's probably our most goal scoring line up. It also uses HRK and Austin's strengths

Does seem to be a bit of a scapegoat. No striker would've done much yesterday. Our wide players were non existent and Krovinovic isn't the sort of player who can do it all himself.

No striker would have done much, yet we were transformed once HRK came on for Austin.

"Transformed", it was 1-1 when HRK came on. That has to be the most generous use of the word transformed I've ever seen. Did we have any shots on target after HRK came on? One maybe?

Transformed may be a bit excessive a word, however, HRK definitely made a difference for the good. He offered an outlet that Austin didn’t. He ran the channels, held it up well and brought others in to play.

I’m not an Austin hater. He has 4 in 4 and he’s worth a squad place. He just doesn’t offer much else, for me. HRK link play and enables other players to join further up the field. Austin should always be an option to come off the bench for me.

Aye, a distinct improvement after the subs were made.
Reply
#18
(12-12-2019, 09:07 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 11:45 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Ferguson. 5. Worst game yet. Caught out by cross field passes and gave the ball away. 

Sawyers. 6. Has his moments but way too casual and didn’t spread the ball quickly or accurately enough. Too many touches at times

Austin. 6. Lack of pace showed tonight and we were miles better when he went off. Took his goal well

Good marks, Manc.

Hate to say it but Nathan's performance bore all the hallmarks of someone who thinks he's made it. Harperesque. Sincerely hope I'm wrong.

Very rare to see 'Sawyers' and 'too many touches' in the same sentence. His performances this season have been marked out by the the fact he rarely has more than 2 touches at a time and the speed with which he moved the ball on. Very ponderous last night. When he performs, the team does, when he doesn't, well....

Feel sorry for Austin, I think the mind is willing but the body can't. Can't deny he still has a goalscoring instinct - can't believe he found a way through that wall to score. Noticed he kicked a water bottles and was steaming towards the changing rooms after he was taken off. Think someone must have said something to him and he ended up taking a place on the bench. Not sure if he was angry or frustrated.

I really didn't get the Austin sub. He'd had no service all evening, no players even close to him, and whilst we seem to play better with HRK up top he'd just bloody scored the equaliser and we sub him immediately.

Not a great decision by Slav on that one IMO. What was the harm in giving him another 5/10 minutes with Pereira on the field
Reply
#19
SJ 7.5 - Few decent stops, particularly the second of the double save but he shouldn't have knocked it into such a dangerous area in the first place. Very unlucky with the goal.
Ferguson 5 - Poor game and not helped by being next to the shaky Bartley.
Townsend 7 - Limited player but offered some sort of threat down the left and at least had a go at their full backs.
Bartley 5 - Had one of his clumsy looking games and let their forwards the wrong side of him a couple of times.
Ajayi 6 - Covered well for Bartley on the odd occasion but also allowed their forwards goal side of him on too many occasions.
Livermore 6.5 - Plenty of energy second half but his passing was dire at times.
Sawyers 5.5 - Probably his poorest game of the season.
Krov 5 - Doesn't do enough to affect the game in the number 10 slot and pisses about with it too much when playing deeper.
Phillips 5 - Went missing for most of the first half and wasn't much better in the second.
Edwards 5.5 - Improved slightly after the subs by getting in behind them out wide but he needs to have a go at the full-back more when he picks the ball up. Too many times he just passed it back to Townsend when he could've looked to beat his man. End product was also poor.
Austin 6 - Took his goal well but increasingly looks a busted flush when starting games.

Subs:
HRK 7 - Held the ball up a lot better when he came on and his movement created more space for the three behind to work in
Pereira 6 - Didn't really do much wrong but no real spark.
Furlong 6.5 - Offered us a decent outlet when he came on and the pitch instantly became bigger with the threat of his pace on the right. Still looks suspect defensively.

Overall I'd say it was the worst performance of the season so it's definitely a point gained. Disappointing that one or two of the fringe players couldn't have put their name forward to push for a first 11 place over Christmas. Edwards' performance was of particular concern, given that Diangana will no doubt be going back to West Ham.
Reply
#20
(12-12-2019, 05:25 AM)B36baggie Wrote:
(12-12-2019, 12:23 AM)LoweBaggeridgebaggy Wrote: Need to buy couple of better offensive players in Jan ...Austin is dire & need a no.10 as Pereira back up

Lowe who caused us so much trouble tonight would be one I would go for,

Good marks by the way Manc,

Really? I thought he was terrible, fell to pieces as soon as he got near the box.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: