Stoke
#21
(12-11-2019, 02:24 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:11 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: DK - McLean did well enough in his time here. People hold grudges about his political views, and let that cloud their judgement. Good to see you have a similar opinion of him as I did during his time here.

There's a difference between holding a grudge and just accepting he was an average Championship player playing in the Premier League. He tried hard, but anyone who remembers him as being anything other than crap is remembering a very different player to me.

One thing I've noticed about him is he never hides, even if he's having a stinker. He always wants the ball. 

I know from my own limited abilities as a footballer that sometimes you can go through a purple patch where for no apparent reason, things just go your way. It's probable that McClean is going through one of those spells because he's gone from being derided by the majority of our supporters to being the one we look to to provide the ammunition for our forwards.

Either way, as limited as we all know he usually is, I have massive respect for players and people who stand up to be counted. He's right up there for me.
Me too, DK. 
I respect any player who gives his all, even if that all is limited...
Contrast this...as I've sadly said before.. with that waste of talent that is Chadli. Or closer to both our homes, Saido...
I also respect his political views, but that's an old story...
Reply
#22
(12-11-2019, 03:55 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:24 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:11 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: DK - McLean did well enough in his time here. People hold grudges about his political views, and let that cloud their judgement. Good to see you have a similar opinion of him as I did during his time here.

There's a difference between holding a grudge and just accepting he was an average Championship player playing in the Premier League. He tried hard, but anyone who remembers him as being anything other than crap is remembering a very different player to me.

One thing I've noticed about him is he never hides, even if he's having a stinker. He always wants the ball. 

I know from my own limited abilities as a footballer that sometimes you can go through a purple patch where for no apparent reason, things just go your way. It's probable that McClean is going through one of those spells because he's gone from being derided by the majority of our supporters to being the one we look to to provide the ammunition for our forwards.

Either way, as limited as we all know he usually is, I have massive respect for players and people who stand up to be counted. He's right up there for me.
Me too, DK. 
I respect any player who gives his all, even if that all is limited...
Contrast this...as I've sadly said before.. with that waste of talent that is Chadli. Or closer to both our homes, Saido...
I also respect his political views, but that's an old story...

He tries hard, he never hides and he gives his all - I can't deny he always did this for us, but that's the absolute bare minimum any player should do, though I appreciate after watching what you have at Stoke recently DK this is a rarity.

I don't want to slate McClean as he did do his best for us, but the fact he worked hard barely compensated for the fact he's limited as hell and nowhere near the level required for the Premiership, or even the top half of the Championship. Would he get in our side now, no... would he get in Leeds, Fulham, Forest, Bristol City's sides... no he wouldn't. I mean, he was in and out of a struggling Stoke side last year!

McClean is an average at best Championship player, who if he was judged on application and workrate would be in the Champions League, but he's not and subsequently is playing in a side battling relegation from the second tier and unsurprisingly looks decent compared with the pea-hearted dross he's surrounded with.
Reply
#23
(12-11-2019, 04:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 03:55 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:24 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:11 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: DK - McLean did well enough in his time here. People hold grudges about his political views, and let that cloud their judgement. Good to see you have a similar opinion of him as I did during his time here.

There's a difference between holding a grudge and just accepting he was an average Championship player playing in the Premier League. He tried hard, but anyone who remembers him as being anything other than crap is remembering a very different player to me.

One thing I've noticed about him is he never hides, even if he's having a stinker. He always wants the ball. 

I know from my own limited abilities as a footballer that sometimes you can go through a purple patch where for no apparent reason, things just go your way. It's probable that McClean is going through one of those spells because he's gone from being derided by the majority of our supporters to being the one we look to to provide the ammunition for our forwards.

Either way, as limited as we all know he usually is, I have massive respect for players and people who stand up to be counted. He's right up there for me.
Me too, DK. 
I respect any player who gives his all, even if that all is limited...
Contrast this...as I've sadly said before.. with that waste of talent that is Chadli. Or closer to both our homes, Saido...
I also respect his political views, but that's an old story...

He tries hard, he never hides and he gives his all - I can't deny he always did this for us, but that's the absolute bare minimum any player should do, though I appreciate after watching what you have at Stoke recently DK this is a rarity.

I don't want to slate McClean as he did do his best for us, but the fact he worked hard barely compensated for the fact he's limited as hell and nowhere near the level required for the Premiership, or even the top half of the Championship. Would he get in our side now, no... would he get in Leeds, Fulham, Forest, Bristol City's sides... no he wouldn't. I mean, he was in and out of a struggling Stoke side last year!

McClean is an average at best Championship player, who if he was judged on application and workrate would be in the Champions League, but he's not and subsequently is playing in a side battling relegation from the second tier and unsurprisingly looks decent compared with the pea-hearted dross he's surrounded with.
But then you are blaming the player for something that isn't his fault, surely? Although it should be a basic requirement, trying your best, often is not. McClean never hides and would have a much easier life all round, if he did. I respect him as both a limited player and a decent person. As someone in Belfast once said to me, "Aah,  James,  nice lad but he sure doesn't help himself at times."
Reply
#24
(12-11-2019, 04:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 03:55 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:24 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 02:11 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: DK - McLean did well enough in his time here. People hold grudges about his political views, and let that cloud their judgement. Good to see you have a similar opinion of him as I did during his time here.

There's a difference between holding a grudge and just accepting he was an average Championship player playing in the Premier League. He tried hard, but anyone who remembers him as being anything other than crap is remembering a very different player to me.

One thing I've noticed about him is he never hides, even if he's having a stinker. He always wants the ball. 

I know from my own limited abilities as a footballer that sometimes you can go through a purple patch where for no apparent reason, things just go your way. It's probable that McClean is going through one of those spells because he's gone from being derided by the majority of our supporters to being the one we look to to provide the ammunition for our forwards.

Either way, as limited as we all know he usually is, I have massive respect for players and people who stand up to be counted. He's right up there for me.
Me too, DK. 
I respect any player who gives his all, even if that all is limited...
Contrast this...as I've sadly said before.. with that waste of talent that is Chadli. Or closer to both our homes, Saido...
I also respect his political views, but that's an old story...

He tries hard, he never hides and he gives his all - I can't deny he always did this for us, but that's the absolute bare minimum any player should do, though I appreciate after watching what you have at Stoke recently DK this is a rarity.

I don't want to slate McClean as he did do his best for us, but the fact he worked hard barely compensated for the fact he's limited as hell and nowhere near the level required for the Premiership, or even the top half of the Championship. Would he get in our side now, no... would he get in Leeds, Fulham, Forest, Bristol City's sides... no he wouldn't. I mean, he was in and out of a struggling Stoke side last year!

McClean is an average at best Championship player, who if he was judged on application and workrate would be in the Champions League, but he's not and subsequently is playing in a side battling relegation from the second tier and unsurprisingly looks decent compared with the pea-hearted dross he's surrounded with.

Just a small point of order, but barring a couple of injuries, he was pretty much an ever present, playing 42 league games.
Reply
#25
I presume you'll be supporting us tonight DK!
Reply
#26
(12-11-2019, 06:31 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: I presume you'll be supporting us tonight DK!

Goes without saying AP.  Smile

In all honesty, I'm nowhere near the point where I'm looking at other results. It's probably different if you're at the top. There's a natural enthusiasm that means you get a buzz from everything that's going on. Down among the deadmen, I'd rather take up knitting than have to confront the whole sorry situation.
Reply
#27
(12-11-2019, 06:44 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 06:31 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: I presume you'll be supporting us tonight DK!

Goes without saying AP.  Smile

In all honesty, I'm nowhere near the point where I'm looking at other results. It's probably different if you're at the top. There's a natural enthusiasm that means you get a buzz from everything that's going on. Down among the deadmen, I'd rather take up knitting than have to confront the whole sorry situation.

Hang in there DK. 

I think you have made the right appointment in O'Neill. I think he will keep you up but I don't doubt it'll be neither pretty or convincing. It'll go down to the last few games but he will do it imo.

What will the board do in Jan to support him and how much wriggle room do you have with FFP etc?

If the dough is there I think a couple of astute older heads on loan will come in. As I've said before it wouldn't surprise me one bit if Brunt is one given he's not in our 18 anymore.
Reply
#28
(12-11-2019, 07:01 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 06:44 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-11-2019, 06:31 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: I presume you'll be supporting us tonight DK!

Goes without saying AP.  Smile

In all honesty, I'm nowhere near the point where I'm looking at other results. It's probably different if you're at the top. There's a natural enthusiasm that means you get a buzz from everything that's going on. Down among the deadmen, I'd rather take up knitting than have to confront the whole sorry situation.

Hang in there DK. 

I think you have made the right appointment in O'Neill. I think he will keep you up but I don't doubt it'll be neither pretty or convincing. It'll go down to the last few games but he will do it imo.

What will the board do in Jan to support him and how much wriggle room do you have with FFP etc?

If the dough is there I think a couple of astute older heads on loan will come in. As I've said before it wouldn't surprise me one bit if Brunt is one given he's not in our 18 anymore.

We’re all guessing when it comes to FFP Peachy, but with the size of our squad, the wages some of these wasters are on, the ridiculous amounts we’ve paid for the players and the number of managers and staff we’ve had to pay for and then compensate for sacking them (if that’s included), I’d say we’re well beyond the point of wriggle room. 

I suspect we’re going to have to somehow do some serious offloading. The manager seems to be deliberately freezing out our two best players, Etebo and Ndiaye. I don’t think that’s a coincidence. Another old head from the Albion to replace them would go down a storm with supporters.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: