Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
11-16-2019, 06:44 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-16-2019, 06:50 AM by Babel.)
(11-12-2019, 09:21 PM)Ossian Wrote: (11-12-2019, 06:43 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: think the electorate really needs proportional representation sooner rather than later
The fact that we have had two hung parliaments and a single wafer-thin majority in the most recent three elections suggests you are right. Add to that the 52/48 split in the referendum and there's compelling evidence to suggest that the electorate is polarised to the point of virtual stalemate.
Ironically, the only way we'd ever be likely to get meaningful electoral reform would be via a government with a substantial majority who had made it a manifesto pledge. One which - having gained that substantial majority - they would probably do their utmost not to honour. That pathetic 'Stick with FPTP or change to AV' charade from a few years back hardly qualified as a serious attempt at making the change to a more representative system.
Labour should have promised it (STV or something similar) in 2001 and delivered it in the subsequent parliament. They had the numbers to make it stick but were, in my view, simply too timid.
There, in a nutshell, is the conundrum: you get what you vote for. Thirty-eight to forty-three percent of the vote will leave the Tories with a huge majority, claiming they have a "democratic" mandate to do this or that. They don't, or won't; what they will have is an electoral mandate. There's a difference. That electoral mandate has favored every government for close on a century.
It pains to write this, but what's wrong with the Liberals is 1) the talent they lost from 2015, which is unaviodable when a party moves from being a big group to a rump, and 2) a leadership deficit. Cable was ok as a bridge, but Swinson doesn't have the status of a Steel, Ashdown, or (!) Clegg. Others have rightly pointed out the one-dimensional nature of LD policy.
Tactical voting could make a difference, accompanied by a high turnout, but there's not a lot of policy positives to inspire people to get out to vote and an awful lot of negative (least worse).
Posts: 1,972
Threads: 136
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(11-12-2019, 09:21 PM)Ossian Wrote: (11-12-2019, 06:43 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: think the electorate really needs proportional representation sooner rather than later
The fact that we have had two hung parliaments and a single wafer-thin majority in the most recent three elections suggests you are right. Add to that the 52/48 split in the referendum and there's compelling evidence to suggest that the electorate is polarised to the point of virtual stalemate.
Ironically, the only way we'd ever be likely to get meaningful electoral reform would be via a government with a substantial majority who had made it a manifesto pledge. One which - having gained that substantial majority - they would probably do their utmost not to honour. That pathetic 'Stick with FPTP or change to AV' charade from a few years back hardly qualified as a serious attempt at making the change to a more representative system.
Labour should have promised it (STV or something similar) in 2001 and delivered it in the subsequent parliament. They had the numbers to make it stick but were, in my view, simply too timid. If Labour put a pledge in their manifesto to pass legislation making it mandatory to SOTV, even i will vote for them
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-19-2019, 05:34 PM)Sotv Wrote: (11-12-2019, 09:21 PM)Ossian Wrote: (11-12-2019, 06:43 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: think the electorate really needs proportional representation sooner rather than later
The fact that we have had two hung parliaments and a single wafer-thin majority in the most recent three elections suggests you are right. Add to that the 52/48 split in the referendum and there's compelling evidence to suggest that the electorate is polarised to the point of virtual stalemate.
Ironically, the only way we'd ever be likely to get meaningful electoral reform would be via a government with a substantial majority who had made it a manifesto pledge. One which - having gained that substantial majority - they would probably do their utmost not to honour. That pathetic 'Stick with FPTP or change to AV' charade from a few years back hardly qualified as a serious attempt at making the change to a more representative system.
Labour should have promised it (STV or something similar) in 2001 and delivered it in the subsequent parliament. They had the numbers to make it stick but were, in my view, simply too timid. If Labour put a pledge in their manifesto to pass legislation making it mandatory to SOTV, even i will vote for them
 Good on you SOTV - you’re coming round aren’t you
Posts: 1,976
Threads: 163
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
11-20-2019, 12:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-20-2019, 12:18 PM by Bromley Baggie 2.)
(11-13-2019, 07:21 AM)HUGHIE REED31 Wrote: I have voted Labour all my life , but just can't bring myself to vote
Corbyn,Mcdonnell,Abbott & my new personal dislike Richard Burgon
Can't vote Tory
Looked at Lib-dems Not sure
Now if Labour got David Miliband back in the fold
as Leader , big game changer, they would walk election
and then Country might well move forward in the right direction.
So you voted for Michael Foot and unilateral disarmament? A plan to leave the EU? Higher taxation for the rich? The re-nationalisation of privatised industries?
Take away the disarmament and Labour's current manifesto isn't that different from what Foot was planning to do. And yes, I'm aware that Gerald Kaufman called the 1983 manifesto "the longest suicide note in history", but it was an old fashioned socialist manifesto and Thatcher was riding high thanks to the Falklands and thanks to the media, she was unassailable. Don't forget that prior to the Argentinian invasion of the islands, she was very close to being booted out by her own party, due to her economic policies causing riots in the streets.
The problem is that, as a country, we've lurched so far to the right thanks to the media digging away at people with personal attacks, that people now vote for personalities rather than policies.
Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(11-20-2019, 12:17 PM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: (11-13-2019, 07:21 AM)HUGHIE REED31 Wrote: I have voted Labour all my life , but just can't bring myself to vote
Corbyn,Mcdonnell,Abbott & my new personal dislike Richard Burgon
Can't vote Tory
Looked at Lib-dems Not sure
Now if Labour got David Miliband back in the fold
as Leader , big game changer, they would walk election
and then Country might well move forward in the right direction.
So you voted for Michael Foot and unilateral disarmament? A plan to leave the EU? Higher taxation for the rich? The re-nationalisation of privatised industries?
Take away the disarmament and Labour's current manifesto isn't that different from what Foot was planning to do. And yes, I'm aware that Gerald Kaufman called the 1983 manifesto "the longest suicide note in history", but it was an old fashioned socialist manifesto and Thatcher was riding high thanks to the Falklands and thanks to the media, she was unassailable. Don't forget that prior to the Argentinian invasion of the islands, she was very close to being booted out by her own party, due to her economic policies causing riots in the streets.
The problem is that, as a country, we've lurched so far to the right thanks to the media digging away at people with personal attacks, that people now vote for personalities rather than policies.
Dunno if we've lurched to the right; depends on the scale you choose. In cultural terms, more is possible.
Seems that people don't want to be told what to do by the supposedly individualist right or the collective left. And they hate the experts in the centre.
Posts: 180
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
0
(11-14-2019, 07:42 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Does make me chuckle when the opposition who have inflicted more government defeats (47) than any other opposition in British history are still described as 'inept'
Tory press doing its job
It's not really Corbyn brilliance that's doing that though, is it? It's the fact that a no other parties will work with the minority government.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
Shame the board voting intentions ain't the nation's. Still at least it's reassuring we still have a largely intelligent fanbase with social integrity
Posts: 412
Threads: 4
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
that people now vote for personalities rather than policies.
It's people that put the policies in place , and people who have to carry them out.
I would Trust the likes of Denis Healy, Peter Shore, John Smith etc
over the Corbyn crew to carry them out , sorry but that's were I am at.
Posts: 340
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
-2
I worked for an independent during the 2017 general election. We mustered up 325 votes.
We`re going to have another bash at it this time around.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Voting Tory to make sure the Liberal Undemocrat doesn't get in.
|