Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(10-29-2019, 07:37 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-28-2019, 10:42 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Standout player was Brunt. He was excellent.
He made it look effortless didn't he. An absolute Rolls Royce of a player in that setting.....
Just spotted on the Charlton highlights, when ferguson was sent off, Chris put his arm around him & escorted him down the tunnel, great professional & role model for the youngsters.
Posts: 9,604
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Really good showing last night against what was, admittedly, a very young Swansea team. We moved the ball excellently at times and the lads behind the striker were very impressive.
Ratings:
House - 6.5 - Not tested, couple of decent catches and distribution was okay.
Fitzwater - 6 - Not a fullback. Won't make it at CB. One to consider releasing.
Harmon - 7.5 - Really assured performance, good passer and crosser of the ball. maybe lacks half a yard of pace.
Hegazi - 8 - As expected, miles ahead of everyone else and played in 3rd gear.
O'Shea - 8 - Solid as a rock. Great passing. A great 4th choice
Brunt - 9 (MOTM) - Rolls Royce at that level. Range of passing is a joy and the example he sets in exemplary. The younger players are very lucky to have him around.
Harper - 5 - Strolled round, never sprinted, never put himself about, look completely disinterested. Compare this with how the senior pro next to him applied himself it was borderline embarrassing. No where near the first 18 at the minute.
Willock - 7.5 - Really well rounded footballer. Was stronger than I imagined he would be and seemed to hold the ball up really well. Could be a decent centre forward if he could fill out a bit. Would make it permanent if the price was right.
Tulloch - 8 - Has a fantastic ability to ride tackles and move the ball away from people. Reminds me slightly of Raheem Sterling. One to watch.
Edwards - 8 - Mixed bag. From the sublime to the lazy. Didn't seem to be as interested as he should, but when he did turn it on he was on another level. Need to develop a little consistency and could be a solid player for us for years to come.
Zahore - 7.5 - 2 goals, some decent flicks and moments of hold up. But doesn't half lack some "Umphhh". This is understandable as he was likely feeling his way back. Somebody needs to set fire to his car, get the fucker angry.
Subs:
Soule - 6 - 2nd time I have seen him play, not been convinced either time. Doesn't seem to have much pace and seems to just float about. Has a good reputation so fingers crossed he develops.
Clayton-Phillips - 7 - Very impressed. Busy, lively and seems to have a good appreciation of the game. One to watch.
Their players:
K. Evans, ran the show for them. Very impressive.
Jack Thomas, dirty little bastard, sign him up.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(10-28-2019, 10:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (10-28-2019, 10:21 PM)Peachy Wrote: (10-28-2019, 09:47 PM)Atomic Wrote: (10-28-2019, 09:31 PM)Peachy Wrote: (10-28-2019, 09:18 PM)Atomic Wrote: Won 2-0, big Ken grabbing a brace. Three disallowed first half for offside. Kyle Edwards was superb, their right back will be having nightmares tonight. Hegazi and O'Shea solid at the back, can't think of a worthwhile chance Swansea had. Rekeem Harper showed a bit more spark as well. It was a good evening but bloody cold.
Watched the 2nd 45 mins. Edwards skill was ridiculous at times. There was one run around 65 minutes which was incredible. Tight on the touchline he whipped past about four players and crossed brilliantly for Zohore who clipped wide.
We looked totally in command from what I saw. Very dominant and good crisp passing.
If Edwards could play to that level consistently then he'd be a real threat to Diangana's place in the team. He's great to have as an impact sub at the moment and better on the left hand side than the right IMO.
Agree. He's always looked better on the left.
Edwards doesn’t suit how we play at the moment IMO. He hugs the touchline too much and doesn’t drive into the box. The difference between him against Barnsley and Phillips against Charlton was huge. We just don’t create the same chances and he doesn’t create the same space for others.
There’s a very good player in Edwards, and one Id love to see us progress, but he needs to adapt his game to suit our style, or he’ll only be an impact sub for the foreseeable future.
Can't agree with that assessment. From the games I have seen that is one of his best attributes, the direct nature of his play which has meant he can force the issue in the opposition penalty box, so at Forest his goal, the 2 chances at QPR and I think it was Derby where his introduction helped enormously in being more penetrative than we had previously been.
In fact i would say that early on in the season Phillips had looked a little off key, and one of my reasons for saying that was his reluctance to get into the penalty area. The Huddesfield game was a bit of a sea change in that regard.
At the moment Phillips gets the nod over Edwards because his end product is superior, think Phillips would have buried at least one, if not both of the chances Edwards had in the QPR game.
I agree with you that at the moment Edwards is a very good option on the bench, and with Heath that he needs to work on his decision making and end product to realise fully the potential he has.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-29-2019, 08:50 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really good showing last night against what was, admittedly, a very young Swansea team. We moved the ball excellently at times and the lads behind the striker were very impressive.
Ratings:
House - 6.5 - Not tested, couple of decent catches and distribution was okay.
Fitzwater - 6 - Not a fullback. Won't make it at CB. One to consider releasing.
Harmon - 7.5 - Really assured performance, good passer and crosser of the ball. maybe lacks half a yard of pace.
Hegazi - 8 - As expected, miles ahead of everyone else and played in 3rd gear.
O'Shea - 8 - Solid as a rock. Great passing. A great 4th choice
Brunt - 9 (MOTM) - Rolls Royce at that level. Range of passing is a joy and the example he sets in exemplary. The younger players are very lucky to have him around.
Harper - 5 - Strolled round, never sprinted, never put himself about, look completely disinterested. Compare this with how the senior pro next to him applied himself it was borderline embarrassing. No where near the first 18 at the minute.
Willock - 7.5 - Really well rounded footballer. Was stronger than I imagined he would be and seemed to hold the ball up really well. Could be a decent centre forward if he could fill out a bit. Would make it permanent if the price was right.
Tulloch - 8 - Has a fantastic ability to ride tackles and move the ball away from people. Reminds me slightly of Raheem Sterling. One to watch.
Edwards - 8 - Mixed bag. From the sublime to the lazy. Didn't seem to be as interested as he should, but when he did turn it on he was on another level. Need to develop a little consistency and could be a solid player for us for years to come.
Zahore - 7.5 - 2 goals, some decent flicks and moments of hold up. But doesn't half lack some "Umphhh". This is understandable as he was likely feeling his way back. Somebody needs to set fire to his car, get the fucker angry.
Subs:
Soule - 6 - 2nd time I have seen him play, not been convinced either time. Doesn't seem to have much pace and seems to just float about. Has a good reputation so fingers crossed he develops.
Clayton-Phillips - 7 - Very impressed. Busy, lively and seems to have a good appreciation of the game. One to watch.
Their players:
K. Evans, ran the show for them. Very impressive.
Jack Thomas, dirty little bastard, sign him up.
Evans and Thomas you say? Good luck sending a scout to South Wales to find that pair
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
Didn't check last night. Was the new french lad Diaby on the bench?
Posts: 9,604
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-29-2019, 11:14 AM)Peachy Wrote: Didn't check last night. Was the new french lad Diaby on the bench?
No mate. Not on the bench.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,906
Threads: 31
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-28-2019, 10:02 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Edwards = still needs to learn to look up more and better decision making/end product. Does that and he could be anything.
Needs to be played as an actual winger as well. He can't play the more narrow role that Phillips does, as he just gets bullied in more central areas.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
I was there last too. I'd agree with most of Lurker#3's comments. Harper was anonymous for most of the match. As for Zohore, I don't know if he was playing within himself, but he could have done with showing a little more fire.
Other observations:
Brad House didn't have much to do, but did it well. However, he was very vocal and directing the team, which I thought was good.
Brunt did indeed look class. I would expect to see more of him coming off the bench. Where he really is such an excellent role model is that he always wants to win. Easy for him to just run around for a bit, but instead he's calling the linesman over to contest the offside (lino rudely ignored him).
Whoever said Edwards doesn't cut inside enough was spot on.
Willock looked very lively. Would be good to play him off the bench.
|