Nice to see the EU
#1
Defending democracy in Spain.....
Reply
#2
What were they expected to do? Despite the bullshit rumours they tend not to get involved in domestic issues.
Reply
#3
So you're saying you think the EU should've overruled the Spanish government in a domestic issue? I thought you took the opposite view.

As Baggy1 says, they don't really do that anyway...
Reply
#4
Your ilk would have criticised the EU no matter what it did, either they turn a blind eye or they interfere in domestic matters.

If you actually gave a shit, you'd be wondering why the governments of the individual EU members (like the UK) have been silent on the matter.
Reply
#5
I can see the tread marks on SOTV from here...
Reply
#6
Verhofstadt stood up in Parliament and credited the EU with ending despotism in Europe, yet here we are. Don't get me wrong, this is ultimately on the Spanish for being a shower of bastards but it just makes his claims totally ludicrous.

https://www.facebook.com/GuyVerhofstadt/...631029415/
Reply
#7
Despotism? They didn't clamp down on the UK government when they sent police on horses into the miners either - I don't remember much about the UK government being described as Despots at the time - we were part of the EU then.

Is the treatment heavy handed and unnecessary in Spain - it looks that way. Is it anything to do with the EU - I can't see what they could do. Are the Spanish government despots - No.
Reply
#8
(10-15-2019, 10:17 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Verhofstadt stood up in Parliament and credited the EU with ending despotism in Europe, yet here we are. Don't get me wrong, this is ultimately on the Spanish for being a shower of bastards but it just makes his claims totally ludicrous.

https://www.facebook.com/GuyVerhofstadt/...631029415/

You can't have it both ways, you can't have Brexiteers (way too cool a name for them) bemoaning the lack of autonomy of a national state that is in the EU and then at the same time slating the EU for not enforcing rather subjective rules of what is and isn't permissible democratically on said national state.  

This isn't so much a stick to beat the EU with rather a soggy twig.
Reply
#9
It would be hard to dispute that, post WW2, Europe has generally been a more settled place than was the case for the first half of the 20th century; the EU in its various forms has probably played its part and we've so far managed to avoid another Hitler or Mussolini. Or, for that matter, as it's Spain we're talking about, another Franco.

So maybe Verhofstadt's point has some validity, even if it is a bit of a stretch to talk about "guaranteeing democracy". Just how much restraint the EU could really exercise over somebody like Orban is open to debate. 

In the unlikely event the SNP decided to emulate independentismo catalán's methods, I doubt that a UK government would now respond in the same way as the Spanish. There was a time when I wouldn't have been so sure.
Reply
#10
(10-15-2019, 11:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Despotism? They didn't clamp down on the UK government when they sent police on horses into the miners either - I don't remember much about the UK government being described as Despots at the time - we were part of the EU then.

Is the treatment heavy handed and unnecessary in Spain - it looks that way. Is it anything to do with the EU - I can't see what they could do. Are the Spanish government despots - No.

They've battered and imprisoned people for holding an election. That is the dictionary definition of despotism.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: