We are always told
#11
(09-25-2019, 07:19 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(09-25-2019, 08:17 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(09-25-2019, 07:57 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(09-25-2019, 07:42 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Sorry for being extremely patronising but this stinks of "old man shouts at cloud". Groups being violent towards one another is older than the human race, and it's been pervasive throughout human society. People don't like outsiders to their group, sometimes they get violent.
So sorry for being pedantic but you are obviously not sorry for being patronising otherwise you wouldn’t have written you response that way.

I am well aware that humans have always displayed tribalism but the point is we are always trying to temper that natural emotion by encouraging and nurturing the concept of ‘society’. What you seem to be implying is that it’s acceptable to be racist, homophobic, sexist et al, just because humans are like that.

No, what I'm saying is that this isn't a new phenomena in the slightest and it's quite frankly a stupid example to use to frame it as though it's representative of society falling apart. The "old man shouts at cloud" is a metaphor from the Simpsons whereby Abe Simpson complains about the failings of modern society which I feel parallels your point regarding the youth club. And trust me, I could have been much much more patronising than using a Simpsons reference as a metaphor.

If you want to integrate people you need to do so from the start and do it regardless of personal lamentations. Bringing people together after divisions have been made is what leads to these issues and it's been an issue throughout human history. The issue that should be addressed is using youth clubs to stop people joining gangs, not bringing rival gangs together. It's as stupid as bringing one group of mods and one group of rockers together in the 60s.

You know, Borin', you've been really patronising here towards JO's K. You're not telling us anything, you're just knocking him down. I suppose he's grateful that you weren't more patronising.

Not sure why you've highlighted the last point Chesh, unless I'm being wooshed, given that entire last paragraph is addressing the issue of bringing in rival gangs into a group and isn't related to JOK.

The purpose of that being written is with regards to highlighting the fact that violence caused by localised encounters between two rival groups is not a new thing, and as such it is stupid to say that society is falling apart because of it. If it were, society would have fallen apart while we were still using stone tools millennia ago. Me using the mods and rockers was me telling him something, this is hardly a new phenomenon and you don't bring two rival groups together lest tensions boil over no matter the era. The purpose of encouraging youth clubs is to act as a preventative measure, to stop people joining gangs in the first place. That is how you integrate people with differences; by normalising them to each other you make the differences, as pointless as they are, seem negligible. If you decide to do it after people view those differences as something worth fighting over, then bringing them together risks things going south. Why are the Albion such an inclusive club? Because generations of children, who had no concept of race, grew up idolising the likes of Regis and Cunningham, whereas in clubs where that wasn't the case racism in the terraces remained prevalent within the same generation, even if the makeup of the support was still extremely similar. If that generation were 10 years older and already aggressive towards black people then I guarantee you Albion fans would have thrown bananas at them instead.

As for my aggression in the responses, I'm getting absolutely sick of people acting as though things that have been happening for millennia in human society as though they're suddenly an example of society falling apart. If these issues were actually leading to society falling apart then there wouldn't be a society now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)