Thomas Cook
#31
(09-23-2019, 11:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:17 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:47 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: This is what happens when you have high street overheads and people can package up their own holiday on an app whilst having a dump, more like.

Exactly, but eh ho many will claim it's Brexit's fault.... gotta spread the fear! Most experts have said similar, people can sort their own holidays out these days just as easy as going to a shop and paying extra for it to be sorted for you.

Yeah it's nothing to do with companies budgeting at €1.20 to the pound when and it dropping to €1.09 because of the fucking shambles that is Brexit, it's all to do with people booking holidays using an app.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that when your major market is Europe and £1.5bn of your turnover is from that market that you will take a hit if the £ drops 10%.

Head in the fucking sand

Over 10 years it accumulated nearly £2bn of debt you muppet. Well before Brexit they were fooked. Jesus the gene pool is thinning

Muppet? Seriously? Fuck off - now back to the point.

They've suffered for years because of a lot of external factors, including Brexit, any one of them not occurring could have held this off. Brexit is the only one that is self inflicted out of terrorism, weather patterns, and blokes sitting on the bog booking their holidays. If you really want to stand back and blame other things for the 'project fear' realities then get yourself a long list.

Well at least you've backed off slightly from it was all Brexit's fault. I can hear the penny dropping. No doubt when your balls have fully dropped you'll be able to make a coherent argument or be able to read words over 5 letters so you can understand what the city is saying.
Reply
#32
(09-23-2019, 11:41 AM)billybassett Wrote: Well at least you've backed off slightly from it was all Brexit's fault. I can hear the penny dropping. No doubt when your balls have fully dropped you'll be able to make a coherent argument or be able to read words over 5 letters so you can understand what the city is saying.

You really are a cunt aren't you? Balls dropping? Fucking keyboard warriors on the rampage today.

Let me be clear - when you have a £1.8bn turnover and the pound drops because of Brexit by over 10% then you lose £180m of your cashflow. That's pretty similar to the cashflow prop up that they needed (they asked for £200m IIRC).

The travel industry is struggling, and has been for a while, we didn't need to self inflict more pain on them by voting to leave for various nebulous reasons. That was the final straw.

I try and debate in a reasonable way on here, and I'll always concede a point well made - you are a cunt sir, if you prove otherwise I'll will back track on that as well.
Reply
#33
(09-23-2019, 11:50 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:41 AM)billybassett Wrote: Well at least you've backed off slightly from it was all Brexit's fault. I can hear the penny dropping. No doubt when your balls have fully dropped you'll be able to make a coherent argument or be able to read words over 5 letters so you can understand what the city is saying.

You really are a cunt aren't you? Balls dropping? Fucking keyboard warriors on the rampage today.

Let me be clear - when you have a £1.8bn turnover and the pound drops because of Brexit by over 10% then you lose £180m of your cashflow. That's pretty similar to the cashflow prop up that they needed (they asked for £200m IIRC).

The travel industry is struggling, and has been for a while, we didn't need to self inflict more pain on them by voting to leave for various nebulous reasons. That was the final straw.

I try and debate in a reasonable way on here, and I'll always concede a point well made - you are a cunt sir, if you prove otherwise I'll will back track on that as well.

Big Grin
Reply
#34
(09-23-2019, 11:50 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:41 AM)billybassett Wrote: Well at least you've backed off slightly from it was all Brexit's fault. I can hear the penny dropping. No doubt when your balls have fully dropped you'll be able to make a coherent argument or be able to read words over 5 letters so you can understand what the city is saying.

You really are a cunt aren't you? Balls dropping? Fucking keyboard warriors on the rampage today.

Let me be clear - when you have a £1.8bn turnover and the pound drops because of Brexit by over 10% then you lose £180m of your cashflow. That's pretty similar to the cashflow prop up that they needed (they asked for £200m IIRC).

The travel industry is struggling, and has been for a while, we didn't need to self inflict more pain on them by voting to leave for various nebulous reasons. That was the final straw.

I try and debate in a reasonable way on here, and I'll always concede a point well made - you are a cunt sir, if you prove otherwise I'll will back track on that as well.

The £ has been at the level it is now since Sep 2016. 3 years. It would have been budgeted for over all these years. The weak £, whilst not helping, is not the reason they collapsed.
Since 2007 it's been merging operations with a number of organisations to try and shore up operations and get to a sustainable business model. In 2012 it almost went when shares dipped to around 10p - I think this was when some holiday makers died in their hotel. They've had numerous cash injections all of which have failed because their business model is flawed and outdated. They should have taken a leaf out of Dart grp's book. I've family who've worked in the business  -they knew.

So I'm all ready for coherent debate but you just spouted this Brexit nonsense about TC which is not true. There's enough rhetoric and lies about Brexit/Remain. People complaining about politicians lying or using hyperbole. The man/woman on the street want them held to account but you've fell right into the same trap. I may be what you called me - who knows- but at least I'm not peddling lies.
Reply
#35
Since 2016 you say - what could have happened in 2016

Nobody is saying their business model isn't outdated. I'm not even saying it is sustainable, what I am saying is that at the start of 2016 the £ was at about £1.35 - because of Brexit and the uncertainty around that the pound has fallen to £1.10. That gives them 10% less buying power (I'm being generous here, it's more like 20%), it costs them more in pounds to buy rooms than it did before Brexit.

You've worked in the industry you will know that contracts with hotel groups aren't on a year to year basis, they will probably be based on 5 year agreements that are now costing more than when agreed.

When your business is buying goods from overseas and those goods cost you more year on year because the pound is weakening then you will struggle. The amount they needed £200m is coincidently about 10% of their turnover which wouldn't have been needed if they hadn't had to pay 10 or 20% more for their goods.

And just to finish the point off - you say that the weak pound, whilst not helping, is not the reason they collapsed. For a company that buys 99% of their product from abroad that will be the main reason - any company whose cost of goods goes up between 10 and 20% and can't pass that on will fail when they are working on tight margins.

If it was purely down to market conditions we would see holiday pricing come down but we aren't, their problem was the scale that they have been hit because of the weak pound.
Reply
#36
(09-23-2019, 08:34 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The beginning of things to come, this is what 17+ million voted for. When a large chunk of your customers are reluctant to spend money / delay booking holidays because of Brexit. This is what happens.

Most of the return flights and costs will be paid via ATOL not the government.

Shall we ignore the fact it “wasn’t ready for the Twenty First Century.” (Simon Calder. BBC), too many town centre outlets, The massive increase of people being their own travel agent , over supply in the market, last years poor sales due to ‘staycations’ in the heatwave and people reluctant to visit two of its main destinations, Turkey and Egypt. (Didn’t realise they were in Europe, yet!) [/
Does this look like a successful healthy company which has only struggled since 2016?
[color=#454545][font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-49796827       (Soz, can’t get iPad to produce a sufficiently small image to post.[/font][/font]


Again just selecting and highlighting one partial reason stated to make a cheap point to fit an agenda. Is there nothing that doesn’t exist outside your, angsts ridden, Brexit bubble?
Reply
#37
I think you need to get closer to the screen JOK

Let's be clear again on this one JOK - is this business model sustainable? No. Would it have gone under eventually? Probably unless they changed their approach given time.

Now as I can cede both of those points and also say that this is not all down to Brexit, can the Brexiteers on here cede that Brexit has definitely had an impact that has pushed them over the edge.
Reply
#38
Not once did I say Brexit hasn't had an impact a weakening pound will have had an affect. But that wasn't THE reason it went bust. Christ. You commented that it was just down to Brexit and I picked you up on it.

Now you cede those points that it wasn't just Brexit. Well done for keeping up. You then add that Brexit pushed them over the edge. Nowhere have analysts said that the weakened £ pushed them over the edge. Again it is a combination of factors the biggest being over 10 years accumulating so much debt, through a defunct operating model; that their revenue has been unable to service. 

I'm a remainer sunshine so put you're pipe back in it's box..
Reply
#39
(09-23-2019, 11:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:47 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 08:34 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The beginning of things to come, this is what 17+ million voted for. When a large chunk of your customers are reluctant to spend money / delay booking holidays because of Brexit. This is what happens.

Most of the return flights and costs will be paid via ATOL not the government.

This is what happens when you have high street overheads and people can package up their own holiday on an app whilst having a dump, more like.

Exactly, but eh ho many will claim it's Brexit's fault.... gotta spread the fear! Most experts have said similar, people can sort their own holidays out these days just as easy as going to a shop and paying extra for it to be sorted for you.

Yeah it's nothing to do with companies budgeting at €1.20 to the pound when and it dropping to €1.09 because of the fucking shambles that is Brexit, it's all to do with people booking holidays using an app.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that when your major market is Europe and £1.5bn of your turnover is from that market that you will take a hit if the £ drops 10%.

Head in the fucking sand

Why have they been posting 9 figure losses for the last 6 years, then?
Reply
#40
(09-23-2019, 01:24 PM)billybassett Wrote: Not once did I say Brexit hasn't had an impact a weakening pound will have had an affect. But that wasn't THE reason it went bust. Christ. You commented that it was just down to Brexit and I picked you up on it.

Now you cede those points that it wasn't just Brexit. Well done for keeping up. You then add that Brexit pushed them over the edge. Nowhere have analysts said that the weakened £ pushed them over the edge. Again it is a combination of factors the biggest being over 10 years accumulating so much debt, through a defunct operating model; that their revenue has been unable to service. 

I'm a remainer sunshine so put you're pipe back in it's box..

And what you'll find is that with the points made I'll step back and agree that a weak business model was the main reason for all of their woes and it is my error about blaming the weak pound because of Brexit, albeit contributing to their demise earlier than otherwise.

It is obvious that the weak pound put their costs up by 10 - 15% pa which will be about £150m, and it also is a fact that without Brexit the pound wouldn't have weakened so much. My original point was badly worded and knee jerk due to people completely dismissing Brexit as contributory.

In the meantime I don't need to grow any balls, keep up, put my pipe back in my box or learn the appropriate use of 'your'. The one weakness in your aggressive argument is that I stated it ae THE (capital letters as well) reason was Brexit, I didn't say that, I was commenting on people saying it's purely down to using an app whilst having a shit and nothing to do with Brexit.

Next time wind yer neck in with the insults, the keyboard warrior look is so 2005.

(09-23-2019, 01:47 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:47 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 08:34 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The beginning of things to come, this is what 17+ million voted for. When a large chunk of your customers are reluctant to spend money / delay booking holidays because of Brexit. This is what happens.

Most of the return flights and costs will be paid via ATOL not the government.

This is what happens when you have high street overheads and people can package up their own holiday on an app whilst having a dump, more like.

Exactly, but eh ho many will claim it's Brexit's fault.... gotta spread the fear! Most experts have said similar, people can sort their own holidays out these days just as easy as going to a shop and paying extra for it to be sorted for you.

Yeah it's nothing to do with companies budgeting at €1.20 to the pound when and it dropping to €1.09 because of the fucking shambles that is Brexit, it's all to do with people booking holidays using an app.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that when your major market is Europe and £1.5bn of your turnover is from that market that you will take a hit if the £ drops 10%.

Head in the fucking sand

Why have they been posting 9 figure losses for the last 6 years, then?

For the hard of reading, cash flow is the reason they have gone under - higher costs because of a weak pound are the final straw. 

Losses over the last few years are a combination of Terrorism fears, Weak £ following Brexit, market changes (no trips to Egypt for instance) and a lot of other issues including bad management. The weak £ bit is completely self inflicted following Brexit and as I've shown, without that, they have had the £200m needed to stay afloat.

Would they have stayed afloat for much longer, who knows - what with terrorism fears receding, if the pound had been stronger, public confidence growing, they might have done. All travel firms work on very tight margins, any knocks will affect them, and IMO Brexit has pushed them over the edge.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: