Appleton fav for Lincoln City
#21
(09-18-2019, 09:36 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: IMO (FWIW) haven't Lincoln reached the ceiling point on the owners and clubs expectations. Without substantial funding the incredible journey they have been on is almost at an end. I don't see that job as the opportunity to do much. Following the last managers brilliant work, it's a poison chalice now.


I think you're bang on there, and if Appy is even considering this move, it would lead me to seriously question his decision making abilities.
Reply
#22
Regarding Appleton, one Oxford fan said this:
Michael Appleton now odds-on fav for the Lincoln job. If any of their fans have doubts, he was the best Oxford Manager in recent times. And in that time we’ve had the man now being touted as the best English manager - Chris Wilder.


So he does sound like a useful chap to have around the place.
Reply
#23
Appleton obviously snubbed billy for an autograph or summint. His record and credentials are more than enough to show he’s a useful person to be involved in our club.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#24
(09-18-2019, 10:56 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:47 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:36 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:23 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:05 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: No you're absolutely right, we shouldn't be hiring coaches based on coaching ability, attitude and experience. 

I hope Appleton fucks off sharpish as he clearly adds no value to our club. Wonder if he can take that bellend Bilic with him too... how dare we appoint a manager with experience, coaching ability and a solid attitude.

Let's hope you don't work in recruitment anywhere.
Not suggesting those skills/traits aren't important what I asked you to do was relate to me the tangible outputs of those skills/traits that Appleton has that makes it a nightmare for him to leave. 
I suggest there are none really hence why the OP title is about him going to Lincoln and not Real Madrid

I would argue having someone in place managing our U23s who is being courted by a club in the division below as their head coach, and has over 250 games as a professional manger (across the PL, Champ and Leagues 1 and 2), including winning a promotion, a couple of cup runs and a track record of blooding and developing young players is a real asset... he's also had experience of playing and coaching with both our first team and academy, shown huge mental strength with his injuries and is highly thought of by coaches like Hodgson, Bilic, Puel etc...


Now I realise you don't really understand the value of context or character, but even you must be able to grasp the above is a pretty valuable person to be losing from an U23s role - and probably a little better suited to the role he's in than someone who'd be leaving for Real Madrid...

I'm just pressing the buttons because I have no idea why many posters on this board think Appleton is so good. He played for us a long time ago, was decent but no world beater, and not for very long until he was injured at an early age. Since then he's made a good career for himself at the lower levels and has had some successes along the way. Good for him. 

I'm 100% sure that if he'd never played for the Albion people would be scratching their heads over how he got a job here. They'd probably be asking the same Qs I am now like how many U21s/23s has he brought through the ranks to play at the highest level, what other academies has he worked in, what's his record in finding young talent like etc etc.. How come people aren't talking about Micky Mellon and isn't James O'Connor coaching at Orlando?
I find the whole Appleton love in bizarre.

I think the main qualification is the fact he's spent 5 years working in our youth academy, and was part of the changes when Ashworth was reforming it all... He's then spent 2 years with the first team, and has since worked at all levels of the football league as a manager.

Micky Mellon and O'Connor may well have some experience as a number one in the lower leagues and the MLS repsectively, but neither have Appleton's knowledge of the club and experience in youth football (let alone our youth set-up).

He worked with our youth 10-15 years ago but in no other academies. I could go on but I'm sure he's a nice bloke to have about the place so we'll leave it at that
Reply
#25
(09-18-2019, 11:08 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 10:56 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:47 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:36 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:23 AM)billybassett Wrote: Let's hope you don't work in recruitment anywhere.
Not suggesting those skills/traits aren't important what I asked you to do was relate to me the tangible outputs of those skills/traits that Appleton has that makes it a nightmare for him to leave. 
I suggest there are none really hence why the OP title is about him going to Lincoln and not Real Madrid

I would argue having someone in place managing our U23s who is being courted by a club in the division below as their head coach, and has over 250 games as a professional manger (across the PL, Champ and Leagues 1 and 2), including winning a promotion, a couple of cup runs and a track record of blooding and developing young players is a real asset... he's also had experience of playing and coaching with both our first team and academy, shown huge mental strength with his injuries and is highly thought of by coaches like Hodgson, Bilic, Puel etc...


Now I realise you don't really understand the value of context or character, but even you must be able to grasp the above is a pretty valuable person to be losing from an U23s role - and probably a little better suited to the role he's in than someone who'd be leaving for Real Madrid...

I'm just pressing the buttons because I have no idea why many posters on this board think Appleton is so good. He played for us a long time ago, was decent but no world beater, and not for very long until he was injured at an early age. Since then he's made a good career for himself at the lower levels and has had some successes along the way. Good for him. 

I'm 100% sure that if he'd never played for the Albion people would be scratching their heads over how he got a job here. They'd probably be asking the same Qs I am now like how many U21s/23s has he brought through the ranks to play at the highest level, what other academies has he worked in, what's his record in finding young talent like etc etc.. How come people aren't talking about Micky Mellon and isn't James O'Connor coaching at Orlando?
I find the whole Appleton love in bizarre.

I think the main qualification is the fact he's spent 5 years working in our youth academy, and was part of the changes when Ashworth was reforming it all... He's then spent 2 years with the first team, and has since worked at all levels of the football league as a manager.

Micky Mellon and O'Connor may well have some experience as a number one in the lower leagues and the MLS repsectively, but neither have Appleton's knowledge of the club and experience in youth football (let alone our youth set-up).

He worked with our youth 10-15 years ago but in no other academies. I could go on but I'm sure he's a nice bloke to have about the place so we'll leave it at that

No, you're completely correct. We should be approaching Tranmere to appoint Mellon as what we need is someone who has never worked in our youth set-up or in an academy, as his record is clearly on par or better suited.
Reply
#26
(09-18-2019, 11:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 11:08 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 10:56 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:47 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-18-2019, 09:36 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I would argue having someone in place managing our U23s who is being courted by a club in the division below as their head coach, and has over 250 games as a professional manger (across the PL, Champ and Leagues 1 and 2), including winning a promotion, a couple of cup runs and a track record of blooding and developing young players is a real asset... he's also had experience of playing and coaching with both our first team and academy, shown huge mental strength with his injuries and is highly thought of by coaches like Hodgson, Bilic, Puel etc...


Now I realise you don't really understand the value of context or character, but even you must be able to grasp the above is a pretty valuable person to be losing from an U23s role - and probably a little better suited to the role he's in than someone who'd be leaving for Real Madrid...

I'm just pressing the buttons because I have no idea why many posters on this board think Appleton is so good. He played for us a long time ago, was decent but no world beater, and not for very long until he was injured at an early age. Since then he's made a good career for himself at the lower levels and has had some successes along the way. Good for him. 

I'm 100% sure that if he'd never played for the Albion people would be scratching their heads over how he got a job here. They'd probably be asking the same Qs I am now like how many U21s/23s has he brought through the ranks to play at the highest level, what other academies has he worked in, what's his record in finding young talent like etc etc.. How come people aren't talking about Micky Mellon and isn't James O'Connor coaching at Orlando?
I find the whole Appleton love in bizarre.

I think the main qualification is the fact he's spent 5 years working in our youth academy, and was part of the changes when Ashworth was reforming it all... He's then spent 2 years with the first team, and has since worked at all levels of the football league as a manager.

Micky Mellon and O'Connor may well have some experience as a number one in the lower leagues and the MLS repsectively, but neither have Appleton's knowledge of the club and experience in youth football (let alone our youth set-up).

He worked with our youth 10-15 years ago but in no other academies. I could go on but I'm sure he's a nice bloke to have about the place so we'll leave it at that

No, you're completely correct. We should be approaching Tranmere to appoint Mellon as what we need is someone who has never worked in our youth set-up or in an academy, as his record is clearly on par or better suited.

Yours Gone Fishing, love Mortimer & Whitehouse lol
Reply
#27
We're all doomed.
Reply
#28
(09-18-2019, 01:27 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We're all doomed.

They'll be playing for England at the 2020s... so we'll be OK!
Reply
#29
Steve Madeley:
Noises in Lincolnshire suggest Michael Appleton edging closer to Lincoln manager's job. He made it clear to Albion when he returned that he wanted to manage again at some stage. They would have hoped that 'some stage' was a little further in the future, though.
Reply
#30
He’s gone took over at Lincoln today hopefully to never return. Good bye and good riddance .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: