REFEREE GRAHAM SCOTT
This fred running to 16 pages shows the injustice felt by virtually all Albion fans. Heath is right when he says we should let it go, yet it's bloody difficult. There were so many inconsistencies in the refereeing that day, it nothing short of disgraceful.
As an aside, I was with 3 villa season ticket holders on Saturday night and they were fuming about Bournemouth's gamesmanship and diving. I did point out the irony.
Reply
I think we all felt frustrated by the the way that first leg ended.

JRod hit the bar, Gayle scored from their gift and fluffed a gilt edged chance to play Murphy in.
That would have finished Vile off.
They'd created nothing of note until Hourihan's equaliser. Although it was a good strike he had time and space because 3 of our players ran towards Grealish and left him unmarked.

After that it was the Scott show. The dodgy pen, Gayle's 2 yellows (the first totally avoidable and the second unwarranted), and the ridiculous non decision for a penalty to us.

Then he failed to apply his own standards to Villa when they were running down the clock.

We lost that game partly due to our own errors and partly due to Scott's incompetence and home team bias.

I still don't get why for games of such importance, VAR wasn't used
Reply
(08-19-2019, 08:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: I think we all felt frustrated by the the way that first leg ended.

JRod hit the bar, Gayle scored from their gift and fluffed a gilt edged chance to play Murphy in.
That would have finished Vile off.
They'd created nothing of note until Hourihan's equaliser. Although it was a good strike he had time and space because 3 of our players ran towards Grealish and left him unmarked.

After that it was the Scott show. The dodgy pen, Gayle's 2 yellows (the first totally avoidable and the second unwarranted), and the ridiculous non decision for a penalty to us.

Then he failed to apply his own standards to Villa when they were running down the clock.

We lost that game partly due to our own errors and partly due to Scott's incompetence and home team bias.

I still don't get why for games of such importance, VAR wasn't used

I suspect it’s because VAR isn’t used during the regular season and would constitute a massive rule change during the season, which is not allowed.
Reply
(08-19-2019, 08:37 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-19-2019, 08:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: I think we all felt frustrated by the the way that first leg ended.

JRod hit the bar, Gayle scored from their gift and fluffed a gilt edged chance to play Murphy in.
That would have finished Vile off.
They'd created nothing of note until Hourihan's equaliser. Although it was a good strike he had time and space because 3 of our players ran towards Grealish and left him unmarked.

After that it was the Scott show. The dodgy pen, Gayle's 2 yellows (the first totally avoidable and the second unwarranted), and the ridiculous non decision for a penalty to us.

Then he failed to apply his own standards to Villa when they were running down the clock.

We lost that game partly due to our own errors and partly due to Scott's incompetence and home team bias.

I still don't get why for games of such importance, VAR wasn't used

I suspect it’s because VAR isn’t used during the regular season and would constitute a massive rule change during the season, which is not allowed.
They were happy enough to use it in our cup tie at Anfield when it wasn't used in most other Cup games that season.
Reply
(08-19-2019, 08:52 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(08-19-2019, 08:37 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-19-2019, 08:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: I think we all felt frustrated by the the way that first leg ended.

JRod hit the bar, Gayle scored from their gift and fluffed a gilt edged chance to play Murphy in.
That would have finished Vile off.
They'd created nothing of note until Hourihan's equaliser. Although it was a good strike he had time and space because 3 of our players ran towards Grealish and left him unmarked.

After that it was the Scott show. The dodgy pen, Gayle's 2 yellows (the first totally avoidable and the second unwarranted), and the ridiculous non decision for a penalty to us.

Then he failed to apply his own standards to Villa when they were running down the clock.

We lost that game partly due to our own errors and partly due to Scott's incompetence and home team bias.

I still don't get why for games of such importance, VAR wasn't used

I suspect it’s because VAR isn’t used during the regular season and would constitute a massive rule change during the season, which is not allowed.
They were happy enough to use it in our cup tie at Anfield when it wasn't used in most other Cup games that season.

Didn’t they agree to use it at PL grounds as they had the cameras/tech to make it work? This was back in the heady days of the ref running to look at w screen on the halfway line. Even that, as a trial would have been agreed before the season started.

If they want to have VAR in this season’s playoffs they need to have already decided.
Reply
(08-19-2019, 08:58 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-19-2019, 08:52 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(08-19-2019, 08:37 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-19-2019, 08:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: I think we all felt frustrated by the the way that first leg ended.

JRod hit the bar, Gayle scored from their gift and fluffed a gilt edged chance to play Murphy in.
That would have finished Vile off.
They'd created nothing of note until Hourihan's equaliser. Although it was a good strike he had time and space because 3 of our players ran towards Grealish and left him unmarked.

After that it was the Scott show. The dodgy pen, Gayle's 2 yellows (the first totally avoidable and the second unwarranted), and the ridiculous non decision for a penalty to us.

Then he failed to apply his own standards to Villa when they were running down the clock.

We lost that game partly due to our own errors and partly due to Scott's incompetence and home team bias.

I still don't get why for games of such importance, VAR wasn't used

I suspect it’s because VAR isn’t used during the regular season and would constitute a massive rule change during the season, which is not allowed.
They were happy enough to use it in our cup tie at Anfield when it wasn't used in most other Cup games that season.

Didn’t they agree to use it at PL grounds as they had the cameras/tech to make it work? This was back in the heady days of the ref running to look at w screen on the halfway line. Even that, as a trial would have been agreed before the season started.

If they want to have VAR in this season’s playoffs they need to have already decided.

I'm  sure you're  right. It doesn't  remove the sense of injustice that most Albion fans feel. It felt like the outcome  had already been determined. Vile were the media darlings and everybody's  preferred choice to go up and hey presto that's exactly how it happened. They weren't really  very good.
All their talk about karma after the JRod handball incident! That wasn't  season defining.
They had 45 other games that season and could still only manage 5th.
Reply
Add Ward and Pottage to the list
Reply
Reffed the Dings today.
Reply
(09-14-2019, 03:52 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Reffed the Dings today.

So at least 12 cunts on the pitch at any given time.
Reply
(09-14-2019, 08:55 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-14-2019, 03:52 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Reffed the Dings today.

So at least 12 cunts on the pitch at any given time.

True words.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)