Old Trafford
#41
(09-09-2019, 05:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: They've got the best batsmen (potentially of all time), the best pace attack in the world and a vastly experienced spin bowler. Telling that their second best batsmen spent all summer at Glamorgan playing red ball cricket. It's almost as if practice worksm

Smith is exceptionally good, but Bradman's statistics are just ridiculous and will almost certainly never be beaten.
Reply
#42
(09-09-2019, 09:42 AM)74bus Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 05:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: They've got the best batsmen (potentially of all time), the best pace attack in the world and a vastly experienced spin bowler. Telling that their second best batsmen spent all summer at Glamorgan playing red ball cricket. It's almost as if practice worksm

Smith is exceptionally good, but Bradman's statistics are just ridiculous and will almost certainly never be beaten.

I suppose it’s different times, so always hard to say a best ever, in any sport.
Reply
#43
The exploits of Stokes will be the stuff of legend but that aside we have been crap in nearly every session.Even when we were back slapping ourselves for having won the match in a couple of starts the Aussies then showed us that we were premature! Overall it has been a surrender.
Reply
#44
(09-09-2019, 09:42 AM)74bus Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 05:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: They've got the best batsmen (potentially of all time), the best pace attack in the world and a vastly experienced spin bowler. Telling that their second best batsmen spent all summer at Glamorgan playing red ball cricket. It's almost as if practice worksm

Smith is exceptionally good, but Bradman's statistics are just ridiculous and will almost certainly never be beaten.

Thing is Smith was dropped/ no ball on 118 I think. There's a 100 runs they wouldn't have scored. So it would have meant the Aussies batting longer - probably another 15 overs. That was all we needed. 

Like any top level sport it's fine margins and taking your chances. In the first test they were 122-8. We never took our chance. It rained in the test we were going to win. And we let Smith off the hook this test. We took our chance at Headingley - amazingly but I'm convinced if Roy had have not played any part and we had someone who could actually open then we'd have won a test  - Cook would have been much better.
Reply
#45
(09-09-2019, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 09:42 AM)74bus Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 05:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: They've got the best batsmen (potentially of all time), the best pace attack in the world and a vastly experienced spin bowler. Telling that their second best batsmen spent all summer at Glamorgan playing red ball cricket. It's almost as if practice worksm

Smith is exceptionally good, but Bradman's statistics are just ridiculous and will almost certainly never be beaten.

Thing is Smith was dropped/ no ball on 118 I think. There's a 100 runs they wouldn't have scored. So it would have meant the Aussies batting longer - probably another 15 overs. That was all we needed. 

Like any top level sport it's fine margins and taking your chances. In the first test they were 122-8. We never took our chance. It rained in the test we were going to win. And we let Smith off the hook this test. We took our chance at Headingley - amazingly but I'm convinced if Roy had have not played any part and we had someone who could actually open then we'd have won a test  - Boycott would have been much better.
Bang on, but edited that last bit for you Smile

At the top level sport really is about fine margins, and those fine margins have generally gone the Aussies way. Althought they have a better and more balanced bowling attack than us, the major difference has been Smith's runs. Take those out the equation, and the little urn would be ours. Oh well, there's always the rugby...
Reply
#46
If Smith batted for England we'd have won the series by now.

Fine margins indeed - not seen stats on this but would be interested to see how many LBWs have been given (or not) for each side based on umpire's decision. The finest of margins that you cannot really control.

Dropped catches are poor play as is no-balling, but the Leach one was millimetres.
Reply
#47
Unchanged squad for the next test. Ed Smith can piss off.
Reply
#48
(09-09-2019, 11:15 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Unchanged squad for the next test. Ed Smith can piss off.

In fairness there is no point throwing some youngsters and debutants in for a dead rubber against the best bowling attack in the world hell hell bent on winning in England for the first time in a generation. There's nothing to be gained and could put some players back years, just look what too much too soon did for Haseeb Hameed. Hasn't even got a Lancashire contract for next season.
Reply
#49
(09-09-2019, 11:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 11:15 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Unchanged squad for the next test. Ed Smith can piss off.

In fairness there is no point throwing some youngsters and debutants in for a dead rubber against the best bowling attack in the world hell hell bent on winning in England for the first time in a generation. There's nothing to be gained and could put some players back years, just look what too much too soon did for Haseeb Hameed. Hasn't even got a Lancashire contract for next season.

I agree that wholesale changes would have been wrong, but I'd have dropped Roy, and picked some like Northeast from Hampshire, who could slot in as number three, with Root moving back to his preffered number four slot.
Reply
#50
(09-09-2019, 11:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 11:15 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Unchanged squad for the next test. Ed Smith can piss off.

In fairness there is no point throwing some youngsters and debutants in for a dead rubber against the best bowling attack in the world hell hell bent on winning in England for the first time in a generation. There's nothing to be gained and could put some players back years, just look what too much too soon did for Haseeb Hameed. Hasn't even got a Lancashire contract for next season.


On the flip side, look at what happened to Steve Smith when he was thrown in against us in a dead rubber. Sibley has been knocking on the door for ages and Pope has been in the squad this summer, Roy is useless and we're desperate for an opener.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)