Old Trafford
#31
I don’t think it was the batting that lost it for us, more the bowling/fielding  in the first innings. In our first innings we took it past 4 sessions which ain’t bad against this Aussie attack. For some reason Archer wasn’t on it first innings. Add in the Leach no-ball. And the losses of Wood and Anderson for the series. I’m not sure there’s much Root can do about all that.
Reply
#32
(09-08-2019, 06:44 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: I don’t think it was the batting that lost it for us, more the bowling/fielding  in the first innings. In our first innings we took it past 4 sessions which ain’t bad against this Aussie attack. For some reason Archer wasn’t on it first innings. Add in the Leach no-ball. And the losses of Wood and Anderson for the series. I’m not sure there’s much Root can do about all that.

Our batting overall was woeful. Here and there we saw green shoots but by and large we came up well short.
Playing an Ashes series after a slogging World Cup was asking for trouble.

It's taken Burns and Roy several innings to adjust to the Test Match format.

And regarding Archer, was he bowling to orders?
Reply
#33
(09-08-2019, 06:47 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(09-08-2019, 06:44 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: I don’t think it was the batting that lost it for us, more the bowling/fielding  in the first innings. In our first innings we took it past 4 sessions which ain’t bad against this Aussie attack. For some reason Archer wasn’t on it first innings. Add in the Leach no-ball. And the losses of Wood and Anderson for the series. I’m not sure there’s much Root can do about all that.

Our batting overall was woeful. Here and there we saw green shoots but by and large we came up well short.
Playing an Ashes series after a slogging World Cup was asking for trouble.

It's taken Burns and Roy several innings to adjust to the Test Match format.

And regarding Archer, was he bowling to orders?
Roy is not a test player, ever.
Reply
#34
Much more than just Smith. Their attack is far better - especially the new ball pair

This isn’t a particularly strong Aus side - plenty of holes in their top 6. The real issue that England have only got about 5 Test class players - 6 if you count the injured JA
Reply
#35
(09-08-2019, 07:41 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Much more than just Smith. Their attack is far better - especially the new ball pair

This isn’t a particularly strong Aus side - plenty of holes in their top 6. The real issue that England have only got about 5 Test class players - 6 if you count the injured JA

I don't dispute they bowled better, but Cummins and Lyon aside, do they really? I'd say both sides come up well short. Smith's batting has swung it but the loss of Anderson and Wood cost our bowling, along with the fact their fielding was better close to the bat. 
 I'm always bitter after losing to them, but particularly so when we haven't played to our strengths.
Root. Great batsman, poor captain. 
Woakes. Underbowled. 
Roy. Clearly not an opener, although balanced by theirs being shite as well. 
Pitches, prepared to suit the opposition as opposed to our strengths. Or perhaps for the World Cup? 
And.. The World Cup, despite the team being very different, it seems the whole effort was aimed in that direction. Broad has played about 6 or 7 four day games and came back firing on all cylinders. How many of our other players have played any proper cricket? 
This was a good win for the aussies because they really weren't expecting us to slip up so regularly.
Reply
#36
They've got the best batsmen (potentially of all time), the best pace attack in the world and a vastly experienced spin bowler. Telling that their second best batsmen spent all summer at Glamorgan playing red ball cricket. It's almost as if practice worksm
Reply
#37
I'm already tired of reading how "brave England" fell just short of saving the series.

We've seen poor selection (in particular including Anderson in the first test, persisting too long with Moeen and leaving Woakes out of the fourth Test), very poor decision making in the field (Root doesn't have the magic of captaincy about him at all), individual batsmen failing under pressure or making poor choices, and an obvious problem with morale. Some days they went out there looking beaten, turned a winning position into a losing one within a session.

It has been a disastrous few years for England at Test level since Bayliss became coach. Root is a very poor captain. We may not have the ranks of talented players waiting to step up, but we shouldn't be seeing players underperform most times they take the field.
Reply
#38
(09-09-2019, 06:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm already tired of reading how "brave England" fell just short of saving the series.

We've seen poor selection (in particular including Anderson in the first test, persisting too long with Moeen and leaving Woakes out of the fourth Test), very poor decision making in the field (Root doesn't have the magic of captaincy about him at all), individual batsmen failing under pressure or making poor choices, and an obvious problem with morale. Some days they went out there looking beaten, turned a winning position into a losing one within a session.

It has been a disastrous few years for England at Test level since Bayliss became coach. Root is a very poor captain. We may not have the ranks of talented players waiting to step up, but we shouldn't be seeing players underperform most times they take the field.

We’re ranked 4th in the world, hardly disastrous. Aus are 5th.
Reply
#39
Where was Curran? Why wasn't Sibley called up? Why was Pope dicked about? Why was Roy continuously opening? Why does Bairstow still have the gloves? This has been years in the making, continuously avoiding playing good players who might have the temperament to play test cricket in favour of people out of firm or unsuited to the format. Australia called up Laubuschagne on form, they had several months of preparing for the conditions and they had a plan. That's why they won, Smith and Cummings aside they're not that good.
Reply
#40
(09-09-2019, 07:02 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 06:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm already tired of reading how "brave England" fell just short of saving the series.

We've seen poor selection (in particular including Anderson in the first test, persisting too long with Moeen and leaving Woakes out of the fourth Test), very poor decision making in the field (Root doesn't have the magic of captaincy about him at all), individual batsmen failing under pressure or making poor choices, and an obvious problem with morale. Some days they went out there looking beaten, turned a winning position into a losing one within a session.

It has been a disastrous few years for England at Test level since Bayliss became coach. Root is a very poor captain. We may not have the ranks of talented players waiting to step up, but we shouldn't be seeing players underperform most times they take the field.

We’re ranked 4th in the world, hardly disastrous. Aus are 5th.

Yes, but we had been top. And it isn't a big league. There are still only 8 proper test sides with any long term track record. And if Oz are 5th, why are we being trounced by them so apparently easily. Arrogance and complacency are what got us where we are now. Time for a better approach.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: