Old Trafford
#21
Good new ball pairing meets a top 6 packed with county plodders. 

All about seeing these 2 off
Reply
#22
Roy, dropped down to 4 still faces the first over.
Reply
#23
I watched a fair bit of the afternoon session and barely saw a decent fuller length delivery bowled by any of our bowlers.
Reply
#24
This is just too tense, I can't even watch! I fear a glorious failure but it's the hope that really hurts. 20 overs to hang on.
Reply
#25
Leach out. Can't see Broad blocking for 15 overs

Turns out Broad didn't have to
Reply
#26
(09-08-2019, 05:07 PM)Albionmad Wrote: Leach out. Can't see Broad blocking for 15 overs

Turns out Broad didn't have to

Poor from the top order though. They only needed to face 3 or 4 more overs each to get us over the line. Although the Aussies swapping an old ball for one that went everywhere for an hour never really helped
Reply
#27
It's a sorry state of affairs when England's lower order show fighting spirit whereas those higher up offered very little.

Main difference between the sides is Smith. The Aussie bowlers also had the edge. They were able to crank it up when it was necessary.

Think England need to replace Root as captain and let him get on with his batting. Don't think giving it to Stokes is necessarily the right call though. Echoes of Botham.

Bring back Brearley
Reply
#28
Seemed to be a lack of belief that they could bat for a day, whereas the Aussies knew they could get us out.

Not sure why Archer comes in ahead of Leech and Broad, but that’s probably by the by
Reply
#29
(09-08-2019, 05:21 PM)Albionmad Wrote: It's a sorry state of affairs when England's lower order show fighting spirit whereas those higher up offered very little.

Main difference between the sides is Smith. The Aussie bowlers also had the edge. They were able to crank it up when it was necessary.

Think England need to replace Root as captain and let him get on with his batting. Don't think giving it to Stokes is necessarily the right call though. Echoes of Botham.

Bring back Brearley

Smith has regained the ashes, almost single handed.   Looking at the 3 previous tests. Edgbaston, England lost a game they were controlling.  Lords, a draw while England were on top.  Headingley, England won while Australia were on top.  There is very little difference other than Smith.  As was said earlier, the openers only needed to stick around for a few overs and this test would have been a draw. As you say, Root needs to concentrate on his batting, his captaincy and field settings are poor. The problem is that there is barely anyone else who is a shoe-in in this side.
Reply
#30
A captain has to remain detached from any preoccupations. Root is or was England's best batsman. It's difficult to concentrate on both. Botham was England's best bowler and amongst the best batsmen. When awarded the captaincy, his own game fell apart. Brearley was an average batsman but one of the best captain's of all time. Illingworth was from the same mold. England need a captain who is capable of playing a captain's innings every now and again but whose mind is free to think tactics.

Don't ask me who though. I'll defer to the well remunerated selectors to figure that one out. Maybe we should start by sacking them
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)