Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
Giles - yes
Saunders - cunt
Fatko- yes
Talbot - no
Gould - no
Ardiles- yes
Burkinshaw - A bit
Fuckley- yes
Harford - yes
Smith- no
Little - no
Megson - yes
Robson- no
Mowbray- yes
RdM - A bit
Hodgson- yes
Clarke - initially
Mel- yes
Irvine - no
Pulis- yes
Pardew- no
Moore- no
Shan - yes
Bilic - yes
IMO the three with the clearest/most indelible stamp pre Bilic were Megson, Pulis and Ardiles. Bilic is the first one in years that seems like he may actually be able to make us fluid and exciting on the attack without being a total basket case elsewhere.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(09-01-2019, 04:39 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Giles - yes
Saunders - cunt
Fatko- yes
Talbot - no
Gould - no
Ardiles- yes
Burkinshaw - A bit
Fuckley- yes
Harford - yes
Smith- no
Little - no
Megson - yes
Robson- no
Mowbray- yes
RdM - A bit
Hodgson- yes
Clarke - initially
Mel- yes
Irvine - no
Pulis- yes
Pardew- no
Moore- no
Shan - yes
Bilic - yes
IMO the three with the clearest/most indelible stamp pre Bilic were Megson, Pulis and Ardiles. Bilic is the first one in years that seems like he may actually be able to make us fluid and exciting on the attack without being a total basket case elsewhere.
Agree with that. Albion are very exciting to watch and you have to think, will improve. Bear in mind the goals conceded are largely down to individual error, then that can also be improved.
Posts: 2,079
Threads: 74
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
3
(09-01-2019, 04:39 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Giles - yes
Saunders - cunt
Fatko- yes
Talbot - no
Gould - no
Ardiles- yes
Burkinshaw - A bit
Fuckley- yes
Harford - yes
Smith- no
Little - no
Megson - yes
Robson- no
Mowbray- yes
RdM - A bit
Hodgson- yes
Clarke - initially
Mel- yes
Irvine - no
Pulis- yes
Pardew- no
Moore- no
Shan - yes
Bilic - yes
IMO the three with the clearest/most indelible stamp pre Bilic were Megson, Pulis and Ardiles. Bilic is the first one in years that seems like he may actually be able to make us fluid and exciting on the attack without being a total basket case elsewhere.
Good post mon. RDM would be a yes though - especially in the PL half season, funnily enough
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
09-01-2019, 09:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-01-2019, 09:19 PM by Big Daddy Cool.)
Halford, Megson, Mowbray, RDM, Hodgson, Clarke for me.
About three months before he got sacked, RDM was close to being the best Albion manager in my lifetime. Promoted with a record points total and a great start to the PL season including that great win at Emirates and beating Everton at Goodison 4-1. It's strange how as Albion fans we never mention him much compared to Mowbray for example.
Posts: 3,011
Threads: 287
Joined: Jun 2019
(09-01-2019, 09:15 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Halford, Megson, Mowbray, RDM, Hodgson, Clarke for me.
About three months before he got sacked, RDM was close to being the best Albion manager in my lifetime. Promoted with a record points total and a great start to the PL season including that great win at Emirates and beating Everton at Goodison 4-1. It's strange how as Albion fans we never mention him much compared to Mowbray for example.
I’m also sure we went on a 6 match unbeaten run. Think Blackpool A was a turning point? Agree RdM, Newton and Mafe were an impressive trio
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Agree with all that except RDM - he's a definite yes! We had balance, a game plan, solid enough defending, a great promotion. Only lost it after November in the prem.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(09-02-2019, 01:47 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Agree with all that except RDM - he's a definite yes! We had balance, a game plan, solid enough defending, a great promotion. Only lost it after November in the prem.
Yup
All went wrong when he started spending a lot more time in London and a lot less on the training ground.
Other than Villa all his managerial roles have had the same pattern... comes in, builds a successful side and game plan, but cannot fix it as soon as it goes wrong.
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-01-2019, 08:39 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (09-01-2019, 04:39 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Giles - yes
Saunders - cunt
Fatko- yes
Talbot - no
Gould - no
Ardiles- yes
Burkinshaw - A bit
Fuckley- yes
Harford - yes
Smith- no
Little - no
Megson - yes
Robson- no
Mowbray- yes
RdM - A bit
Hodgson- yes
Clarke - initially
Mel- yes
Irvine - no
Pulis- yes
Pardew- no
Moore- no
Shan - yes
Bilic - yes
IMO the three with the clearest/most indelible stamp pre Bilic were Megson, Pulis and Ardiles. Bilic is the first one in years that seems like he may actually be able to make us fluid and exciting on the attack without being a total basket case elsewhere.
Good post mon. RDM would be a yes though - especially in the PL half season, funnily enough
+1
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(09-01-2019, 04:39 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Giles - yes
Saunders - couldn't
Fatko- yes
Talbot - no
Gould - no
Ardiles- yes
Burkinshaw - A bit
Fuckley- yes
Harford - yes
Smith- no
Little - no
Megson - yes
Robson- no
Mowbray- yes
RdM - A bit
Hodgson- yes
Clarke - initially
Mel- yes
Irvine - no
Pulis- yes
Pardew- no
Moore- no
Shan - yes
Bilic - yes
IMO the three with the clearest/most indelible stamp pre Bilic were Megson, Pulis and Ardiles. Bilic is the first one in years that seems like he may actually be able to make us fluid and exciting on the attack without being a total basket case elsewhere.
Did you mean?
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
09-02-2019, 04:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-02-2019, 04:59 PM by Hopalong.)
From the managers I've seen, Atkinson had the most immediate impact albeit he inherited a wonderful side. In his first match at United in the cup we played some sensational stuff. And he took us on to our highest placing for 25 years and since. A large chunk of the glory has to go to Allen and Giles though for what was later achieved.
Hagan built a brilliant side in the 60s which went on to win the FA Cup, winning the League Cup in '66 and losing to QPR in '67. The 2nd leg 1st half performance against the WCW in the League Cup final still lives in the memory.
Giles - 1st time - performed miracles as did Megson and Di Matteo.
Honorable mention for Ashman and Mowbray. Ashman won the FA Cup - our last trophy and nearly got us there again in 69 and to the 1970 League Cup final.
Vic Buckingham is arguably our greatest ever manager building what was termed the team of the 50s. Left to manage Ajax where he discovered Cryuff and then later managed Barcelona. Said to be the creator of total football.
|