Who is the best goalkeeper you have seen in a West Bromwich Albion shirt?
#41
(08-29-2019, 02:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hoult
Foster
erm... Kiely

Kiely was really good. So solid!
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#42
(08-29-2019, 08:43 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Foster
Godden
Houston
Miller
Naylor

When Alan Miller was in goal his then girlfriend Claire Sweeney (Brookside) was often in the Halfords which always brightened up the game.

At one point Naylor seemed destined for a big move (think it was Man U but stand to be corrected). Injury and loss of form put paid to that.

Not sure about the big move, but he did get a England B cap when he was at the top of his game with us. Rest of the team were a bit shit at the the time mind!
Reply
#43
godden osbourne foster
Reply
#44
(08-29-2019, 09:10 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: No performance can ever top Fulop’s against Arsenal for sheer fucking incompetence. God rest him.

something very dodgy about that result - 

in no particular order

Osborne Naylor Foster and Godden
Reply
#45
I actually thought Zuberbuhler was okay. Made the art of keeping look like shelling peas at times.
Went out on a high with the 3-0 cup win vs the Dings. Not great obviously, but okay.

Foster pisses the lot of em`.
Reply
#46
It's difficult to separate actual talent from sentiment - long-serving goalies get more kudos, as do those who have performed occasional heroics. I can't put these in order, they were just dead reliable most of the time:

Foster
Hoult
Naylor
Godden
Osborne

Never a fan of Miller. I couldn't understand why his career just stopped and he didn't seem to care. Keepers who came in and made a difference at the time were Kiely and the Beast. But of course we were devoid of proper keepers at the time each of those came in.
Reply
#47
Loved Naylor, Beast and the Pig (that sounds liked a fugged up fairy tale) even Spinx.

But for ability can't decide out of Hoult or Foster for the number 1 slot, with Miller clear in 3rd.




Worst Paul Crichton!
Reply
#48
(08-29-2019, 06:48 PM)IDerek Hardballs Wrote: Chris Adamson?

A face only a mother could love.
Reply
#49
Foster
Foster
Foster
Foster
Foster
Amos Brearley
Reply
#50
(08-30-2019, 12:11 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's difficult to separate actual talent from sentiment - long-serving goalies get more kudos, as do those who have performed occasional heroics. I can't put these in order, they were just dead reliable most of the time:

Foster
Hoult
Naylor
Godden
Osborne

Never a fan of Miller. I couldn't understand why his career just stopped and he didn't seem to care. Keepers who came in and made a difference at the time were Kiely and the Beast. But of course we were devoid of proper keepers at the time each of those came in.
I think people rating Godden above Foster are wearing rose-tinted glasses. Godden wasn't a bad keeper but he was certainly one of the weaker links in that great team. IMO Foster was well ahead of him and all of the other Albion keepers I've seen over the years. 
In fact I think if we'd have had a golkeeper of Foster's quality back in the late seventies, early eighties, we might actually have won something rather than just going close.
But, obviously, we'll never know.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)