Our Travelling Fans and Bilic's Red Card
#11
(08-24-2019, 01:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Full credit to the lot that went today, did not stop singing. I barely heard Derby make any noise. Fantastic.

What happens with Bilic's red card? 2 match ban from the dug out? Not allowed to communicate with the players during a match?? I've never understood the point if it means nothing? Also I think it should be rescinded as he was right about their incorrect penalty...

Spot on that first paragraph
Reply
#12
Great support.

Shite officiating.
Reply
#13
Haven`t seen todays game, only know what the lad told me, plus what I read on here. For what it`s worth, I think refs should be held to account more. Obviously some managers (Hughes, Warnock ) will always blame the ref if their team loses. But, these days refs are paid decent money, the days of refs working as a postman or whatever, and getting £20 plus petrol money on a Saturday are long gone.If they consider themselves to be `Elite refs`, then, in my view ,managers should be able to have some right to ask them to justify decisions.
Reply
#14
Ferriera deffo penalty from where I was standing took his leg.
Linesman called the penalty

Our fans were best on the train and New st Station.
Reply
#15
(08-24-2019, 01:58 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(08-24-2019, 01:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Full credit to the lot that went today, did not stop singing. I barely heard Derby make any noise. Fantastic.

What happens with Bilic's red card? 2 match ban from the dug out? Not allowed to communicate with the players during a match?? I've never understood the point if it means nothing? Also I think it should be rescinded as he was right about their incorrect penalty...

He was also right about the corner, which is what he got the second for.

Doesn’t matter if he was right or not, he’s still not allowed to have s go at the officials.
Reply
#16
I went today. Non stop noise from the Albion boys (and girls). Decent numbers, seemed almost full too. a few gaps to my left and i was high up in the corner bit. Second pen was a disgrace, justice was served with Johnstone's save.

(08-24-2019, 09:11 PM)coxy134 Wrote: Ferriera deffo penalty from where I was standing took his leg.
Linesman called the penalty

Our fans were best on the train and New st Station.

I shouted for it straight away, his standing leg was taken.
Reply
#17
(08-24-2019, 09:23 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-24-2019, 01:58 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(08-24-2019, 01:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Full credit to the lot that went today, did not stop singing. I barely heard Derby make any noise. Fantastic.

What happens with Bilic's red card? 2 match ban from the dug out? Not allowed to communicate with the players during a match?? I've never understood the point if it means nothing? Also I think it should be rescinded as he was right about their incorrect penalty...

He was also right about the corner, which is what he got the second for.

Doesn’t matter if he was right or not, he’s still not allowed to have s go at the officials.

Apparently they didn't even tell him what he was getting the card for... There's a good interview with him on E&D about it.
Reply
#18
Bilic's sending off was ridiculous. What was the second one for, complaining to the fourth official? Dean Smith should have been sent odd every other game last season if that rule was enforced consistently.

I love Slaven's passion though, I think it's important as it feeds down to the players and can be a part of creating a winning mentality. Klopp and Nuno are two of the most passionate managers I've ever seen and it hasn't done either of the clubs they currently manage any harm.
Reply
#19
Ive seen numerous references to the officials misinterpreting the rules because the lino said it hit his shoulder. This isn't right. If you watch the incident on Sky, he actually says "It hit his shoulder AND THE TOP OF HIS ARM". When the ref hears this, he gives the pen. He doesn't award it because he thinks the ball isn't allowed to hit a shoulder. I know these refs are bad, but even they know the basic rules!

In terms of our pen, it looked like one in real time and was definitely 'Brazilian' as there was no contact whatsoever. However, Cocu's reaction to it in his interview was interesting. He didn't bemoan the fact it shouldn't have been given, but made it clear he told the Derby players at half time to stay on their feet as the ref would psychologically give 50/50 decisions to us in their box as he'd awarded their second penalty and would have found out it was an incorrect decision at half time. Cocu therefore is more critical of Lowe for diving in recklessly in the area rather than the ref for giving the penalty in the first place. That one was understandably given - there's no excuse for Derby's second but the ref was hung out to dry by a lino who can't see what's right in front of him.
Reply
#20
(08-25-2019, 10:12 AM)steviedm Wrote: Ive seen numerous references to the officials misinterpreting the rules because the lino said it hit his shoulder. This isn't right. If you watch the incident on Sky, he actually says "It hit his shoulder AND THE TOP OF HIS ARM". When the ref hears this, he gives the pen. He doesn't award it because he thinks the ball isn't allowed to hit a shoulder. I know these refs are bad, but even they know the basic rules!

In terms of our pen, it looked like one in real time and was definitely 'Brazilian' as there was no contact whatsoever. However, Cocu's reaction to it in his interview was interesting. He didn't bemoan the fact it shouldn't have been given, but made it clear he told the Derby players at half time to stay on their feet as the ref would psychologically give 50/50 decisions to us in their box as he'd awarded their second penalty and would have found out it was an incorrect decision at half time. Cocu therefore is more critical of Lowe for diving in recklessly in the area rather than the ref for giving the penalty in the first place. That one was understandably given - there's no excuse for Derby's second but the ref was hung out to dry by a lino who can't see what's right in front of him.

Good post. 

Even with the first, although Gibbs stupidly goes to dive in, he stops himself. Any possible minimal contact is caused by Waghorn leaning in and throwing himself into a swan dive. There are a few angles on Derby’s longer YouTube highlights and I can’t see any trip. If he doesn’t break stride or initiate contact himself, there wouldn’t have been any. 

None of them should have been pens, but on two the defenders invited trouble.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: