Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-18-2019, 09:27 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Far to many dubious decisions - the time Graham Scott became a "CHEAT"
1. The first Gayle Booking for time wasting - GS was looking to make a name for himself.
2. The 2nd Gayle booking - when Gayle was actually pulling out of the challenge, although it was a 50/50 challenge.
Even Danny Murphy said quote "it was a wrong decision - the booking should be recinded".
3, The Greasy one's deliberate foot drag to gain a penalty, Even the Seal fans laughed said "he had conned the ref".
https://twitter.com/K_Forrester1869/stat...5568027648
4. The EFL panel reviewed the Greasy penalty and found it wasn't simulation. What a disgrace IMO.
5. This left Greasy to play on, when Gayle had received a ban for the same offence earlier in the season.
6. Abraham's blatant foul on Holgate in the Seals box was ignored, when clearly it was a foul / penalty.
That's enough i'm beginning to sound bitter.
I don’t blame him for the Gayle s/o... DG was charging round like an idiot all game and was lucky not to get a second yellow earlier than he did... unfortunately the “foul” his second yellow did come from was not deserving of a booking. Shan should have taken DG off a couple minutes before the inevitable card came out IMO.
GS’s main mistake was the shocking call on the Holgate penalty. The JG foul will be given time and time again, and to say it was comparable to DG’s outrageous dive against Forest is laughable. The reason the diving review didn’t punish JG is that there was a foul there... it wasn’t strong enough contact for the reaction, but let’s not pretend we’d not have called for it had it been the other way round.
GS got two big calls wrong on the red and the pen, but the former was entirely in our control to prevent, DG had not taken heed of the warning signs.
Just a shame there isn’t some kind of technology to prevent mistakes such as these happening in games.... oh wait it’s ruining the game we all love.
Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(08-19-2019, 08:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-18-2019, 09:27 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Far to many dubious decisions - the time Graham Scott became a "CHEAT"
1. The first Gayle Booking for time wasting - GS was looking to make a name for himself.
2. The 2nd Gayle booking - when Gayle was actually pulling out of the challenge, although it was a 50/50 challenge.
Even Danny Murphy said quote "it was a wrong decision - the booking should be recinded".
3, The Greasy one's deliberate foot drag to gain a penalty, Even the Seal fans laughed said "he had conned the ref".
https://twitter.com/K_Forrester1869/stat...5568027648
4. The EFL panel reviewed the Greasy penalty and found it wasn't simulation. What a disgrace IMO.
5. This left Greasy to play on, when Gayle had received a ban for the same offence earlier in the season.
6. Abraham's blatant foul on Holgate in the Seals box was ignored, when clearly it was a foul / penalty.
That's enough i'm beginning to sound bitter.
I don’t blame him for the Gayle s/o... DG was charging round like an idiot all game and was lucky not to get a second yellow earlier than he did... unfortunately the “foul” his second yellow did come from was not deserving of a booking. Shan should have taken DG off a couple minutes before the inevitable card came out IMO.
GS’s main mistake was the shocking call on the Holgate penalty. The JG foul will be given time and time again, and to say it was comparable to DG’s outrageous dive against Forest is laughable. The reason the diving review didn’t punish JG is that there was a foul there... it wasn’t strong enough contact for the reaction, but let’s not pretend we’d not have called for it had it been the other way round.
GS got two big calls wrong on the red and the pen, but the former was entirely in our control to prevent, DG had not taken heed of the warning signs.
Just a shame there isn’t some kind of technology to prevent mistakes such as these happening in games.... oh wait it’s ruining the game we all love.
At the match I thought the Gayle second yellow was a stupid mistake by Gayle, when I saw it back I was shocked. Blaming Shan for Gayle getting sent off and then saying the ref was wrong is having your cake and eating it. It was wrong.
The grealish penalty, like the chump from Derby the week before was players going down when they anticipoated contact. That is no different to what Gayle did against forst. If he has stood still he would almost certainly have been fouled. It just looked a lot worse because he was standing still not running.
Graham Scott saved the Villa from years of misery, they can only sell the ground once.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-19-2019, 08:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-18-2019, 09:27 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Far to many dubious decisions - the time Graham Scott became a "CHEAT"
1. The first Gayle Booking for time wasting - GS was looking to make a name for himself.
2. The 2nd Gayle booking - when Gayle was actually pulling out of the challenge, although it was a 50/50 challenge.
Even Danny Murphy said quote "it was a wrong decision - the booking should be recinded".
3, The Greasy one's deliberate foot drag to gain a penalty, Even the Seal fans laughed said "he had conned the ref".
https://twitter.com/K_Forrester1869/stat...5568027648
4. The EFL panel reviewed the Greasy penalty and found it wasn't simulation. What a disgrace IMO.
5. This left Greasy to play on, when Gayle had received a ban for the same offence earlier in the season.
6. Abraham's blatant foul on Holgate in the Seals box was ignored, when clearly it was a foul / penalty.
That's enough i'm beginning to sound bitter.
I don’t blame him for the Gayle s/o... DG was charging round like an idiot all game and was lucky not to get a second yellow earlier than he did... unfortunately the “foul” his second yellow did come from was not deserving of a booking. Shan should have taken DG off a couple minutes before the inevitable card came out IMO.
GS’s main mistake was the shocking call on the Holgate penalty. The JG foul will be given time and time again, and to say it was comparable to DG’s outrageous dive against Forest is laughable. The reason the diving review didn’t punish JG is that there was a foul there... it wasn’t strong enough contact for the reaction, but let’s not pretend we’d not have called for it had it been the other way round.
GS got two big calls wrong on the red and the pen, but the former was entirely in our control to prevent, DG had not taken heed of the warning signs.
Just a shame there isn’t some kind of technology to prevent mistakes such as these happening in games.... oh wait it’s ruining the game we all love.
Spot on about Gayle, he was walking a tightrope and was clearly one foul away from a second yellow, if only we had a striker we could have replaced him with.. *cough* *HRK* *cough*
The Holgate penalty speaks for itself.
Said at the time, and still maintain now that more wasn’t made about Gibbs’ role in the penalty. Had he not let his rag over a free kick a minute or two earlier he wouldn’t have gone diving in and given Scott a decision to make. A shocking lack of composure and discipline from an experienced player.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
We (rightly) complain about Scott’s performance but we should also be looking at our own lack of discipline.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-19-2019, 09:08 AM)Duffers Wrote: Said at the time, and still maintain now that more wasn’t made about Gibbs’ role in the penalty. Had he not let his rag over a free kick a minute or two earlier he wouldn’t have gone diving in and given Scott a decision to make. A shocking lack of composure and discipline from an experienced player.
Agree... imagine if it was Bartley making that foul....
Posts: 7,863
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(08-19-2019, 09:11 AM)Duffers Wrote: We (rightly) complain about Scott’s performance but we should also be looking at our own lack of discipline.
HRK for sure, Gayle has every right to go for that ball, he’d be lambasted for pulling out in such a critical game by some.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(08-19-2019, 09:11 AM)Duffers Wrote: We (rightly) complain about Scott’s performance but we should also be looking at our own lack of discipline.
This is where Gareth Barry was such a miss. I think he would have been able calm things down on the pitch, as it's clear the occasion had gotten to several of the players.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-19-2019, 09:46 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: (08-19-2019, 09:11 AM)Duffers Wrote: We (rightly) complain about Scott’s performance but we should also be looking at our own lack of discipline.
HRK for sure, Gayle has every right to go for that ball, he’d be lambasted for pulling out in such a critical game by some.
HRK and Gibbs definitely deserved censure. As I said, Gayle was obviously one foul away from a red and was still charging around like a maniac. Shan showed his inexperience by not hooking him.
Brunt in the second leg I’m at peace with, a genuine attempt to get the ball just too slow.
Posts: 7,863
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(08-19-2019, 09:51 AM)Duffers Wrote: (08-19-2019, 09:46 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: (08-19-2019, 09:11 AM)Duffers Wrote: We (rightly) complain about Scott’s performance but we should also be looking at our own lack of discipline.
HRK for sure, Gayle has every right to go for that ball, he’d be lambasted for pulling out in such a critical game by some.
HRK and Gibbs definitely deserved censure. As I said, Gayle was obviously one foul away from a red and was still charging around like a maniac. Shan showed his inexperience by not hooking him.
Brunt in the second leg I’m at peace with, a genuine attempt to get the ball just too slow.
We’ll have to agree to disagree there pal, hooking our most likely goal threat would be throwing in he towel for me.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I was there too - I'd have hooked Gayle and said so at the time. GS was losing his patience with Gayle and vice versa, things like the Gibbs booking and not booking their player, their time wasting not being picked up. GS had a hard on when sending him off.
Blame HRK for a pathetic Beckham-esque kick out when 3-1 down in injury time at Derby for Gayle not being subbed. HRK should have been instantly transfer listed and bombed out the club for that. Instead he's still our 3rd choice striker ffs.
The Greasy penalty - I can see why he gave it. Wrongly, but can understand why. This is the exact type of thing we should be trying to eradicate from the game - the attacker looking to make contact with the defender to win a penalty. He was dragging his leg more than Verbal in The Usual Suspects, desperate to find a leg to kick and Gibbs duly obliged.
|