Labour's next leader what they need
#81
(06-06-2026, 08:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-06-2026, 07:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-05-2026, 09:46 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Christ
Burnham's on Newsnight saying he will end 40 years of neo liberalism
Will he fuck
Hl

He doesn’t need to. We haven’t had 40 years of neoliberalism. We’ve had 40 years of creeping regulation and taxation of anything likely to help grow the economy.

Can't agree with that Proth.

I suppose it depends on what you term neo liberalism. But if part of it is a belief that the private sector will always be more effective than the public sector in providing services, then yes we have had a sustained period of neo liberalism.

Monbiot had a good comment piece in the Guardian about the provisions available fir children in care....something that should be a scandal, but probably won't be because the wider public just isn't interested in this issue.

The increasing trend for public services to be outsourced to the private sector is a big reason why I am increasingly questioning those who clamour for increased govt spending on public services. Why? when it only seems to benefit those in the private sector and not those who need the services provided.

A core principle of neo liberalism is deregulation. The UK is one of the most regulated democratic states in the world - let me give you three examples: 

A local authority has just told me I need to get a gas safety certificate for a property that does not have a gas supply or a gas meter fitted. I have to pay a gas engineer once a year to certify that I have not fitted a gas supply or meter to the property. 

Proth Major has applied for a job in a coffee shop. She's not allowed to use the grill until she's 18. I'm not sure what will magically occur on her 18th birthday that suddenly renders her grill-competent, but there's an impediment to youth employment right there. 

If you've invested in property, a business, an investment platform or anything at all "odd" over the last 20 years you'll have had to jump through the most ridiculous hoops to complete a deal or open an account. You can guarantee the bank you've been with for decades will block the first payment of any size you make to any new product. Yet money laundering and fraud is a greater problem than ever.

None of this helps the individual. None of this helps the tenant, the employer or the financial institution. I feel them, literally daily - as micro-aggressions from the state.

YET - like you say, the disaster area of child welfare in private sector homes is wholly unsanctioned. Why? Because it's easier for the state to make life harder for those of us who comply with the minutae of law than those that don't. I couldn't agree with you more about children in care, but the public sector has just as an appalling record as the private sector does - to our shame as a country.

Outsourcing of services to the private sector happens in most democratic countries. Some of it works really well, some of it doesn't. But as someone who works in contracts, SLAs and contractor performance every day I can tell you that problems in contract performance are usually due to poor scoping, input rather than output-based RFPS and a lack of penalties and sanctions (or oversight).

Burnham is dog-whistling about neo-liberalism, the advance of which which pretty much came to a grinding halt with the election of Blair.
Reply
#82
(06-06-2026, 09:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-06-2026, 08:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-06-2026, 07:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-05-2026, 09:46 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Christ
Burnham's on Newsnight saying he will end 40 years of neo liberalism
Will he fuck
Hl

He doesn’t need to. We haven’t had 40 years of neoliberalism. We’ve had 40 years of creeping regulation and taxation of anything likely to help grow the economy.

Can't agree with that Proth.

I suppose it depends on what you term neo liberalism. But if part of it is a belief that the private sector will always be more effective than the public sector in providing services, then yes we have had a sustained period of neo liberalism.

Monbiot had a good comment piece in the Guardian about the provisions available fir children in care....something that should be a scandal, but probably won't be because the wider public just isn't interested in this issue.

The increasing trend for public services to be outsourced to the private sector is a big reason why I am increasingly questioning those who clamour for increased govt spending on public services. Why? when it only seems to benefit those in the private sector and not those who need the services provided.

A core principle of neo liberalism is deregulation. The UK is one of the most regulated democratic states in the world - let me give you three examples: 

A local authority has just told me I need to get a gas safety certificate for a property that does not have a gas supply or a gas meter fitted. I have to pay a gas engineer once a year to certify that I have not fitted a gas supply or meter to the property. 

Proth Major has applied for a job in a coffee shop. She's not allowed to use the grill until she's 18. I'm not sure what will magically occur on her 18th birthday that suddenly renders her grill-competent, but there's an impediment to youth employment right there. 

If you've invested in property, a business, an investment platform or anything at all "odd" over the last 20 years you'll have had to jump through the most ridiculous hoops to complete a deal or open an account. You can guarantee the bank you've been with for decades will block the first payment of any size you make to any new product. Yet money laundering and fraud is a greater problem than ever.

None of this helps the individual. None of this helps the tenant, the employer or the financial institution. I feel them, literally daily - as micro-aggressions from the state.

YET - like you say, the disaster area of child welfare in private sector homes is wholly unsanctioned. Why? Because it's easier for the state to make life harder for those of us who comply with the minutae of law than those that don't. I couldn't agree with you more about children in care, but the public sector has just as an appalling record as the private sector does - to our shame as a country.

Outsourcing of services to the private sector happens in most democratic countries. Some of it works really well, some of it doesn't. But as someone who works in contracts, SLAs and contractor performance every day I can tell you that problems in contract performance are usually due to poor scoping, input rather than output-based RFPS and a lack of penalties and sanctions (or oversight).

Burnham is dog-whistling about neo-liberalism, the advance of which which pretty much came to a grinding halt with the election of Blair.

I agree with much of that, Proth, and from my own experience.  The various businesses I have run and ones in my immediate family are spending way too much time fulfilling varied compliance issues. A whole industry in itself but one in which people like us complete while there's an army of people that simply don't bother. I too could give examples of pointless burocracy that costs time and money and that is an industry in itself, a pointless, product-less one. Don't even start me on solicitors and money wasted ticking boxes. One example I'll leave you with: My eldest sold his small, profitable, well run business to start another (same sort of business) 20 miles away and nearer home. This involved a freehold premises, a different name and a very small business loan. No debts and an exemplary previous trading history with  solid equity behind him.  It has taken 6 months to get a business banking account (??? At one time, a phone call to someone at the bank we've dealt with previously would have sufficed), and now we intend to forego the loan as it became prohibitively expensive for no apparent reason. The solicitors are still arguing with each other,  over whatever they can find, 6 months on. In this event, the property seller and my family got round a table, drew up a short term rental agreement for now and the thing is up and running while the  sale finalises and the solicitors, council etc continue to finish off their boxticking.  I'm absolutely bewildered at the unnecessary complications and I've come to the conclusion if I were starting all over again, I probably wouldn't bother.
Don't even start me on those that don't bother with any of the rules and regs and seem to get by fine.
Reply
#83
(06-06-2026, 09:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-06-2026, 08:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-06-2026, 07:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-05-2026, 09:46 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Christ
Burnham's on Newsnight saying he will end 40 years of neo liberalism
Will he fuck
Hl

He doesn’t need to. We haven’t had 40 years of neoliberalism. We’ve had 40 years of creeping regulation and taxation of anything likely to help grow the economy.

Can't agree with that Proth.

I suppose it depends on what you term neo liberalism. But if part of it is a belief that the private sector will always be more effective than the public sector in providing services, then yes we have had a sustained period of neo liberalism.

Monbiot had a good comment piece in the Guardian about the provisions available fir children in care....something that should be a scandal, but probably won't be because the wider public just isn't interested in this issue.

The increasing trend for public services to be outsourced to the private sector is a big reason why I am increasingly questioning those who clamour for increased govt spending on public services. Why? when it only seems to benefit those in the private sector and not those who need the services provided.

A core principle of neo liberalism is deregulation. The UK is one of the most regulated democratic states in the world - let me give you three examples: 

A local authority has just told me I need to get a gas safety certificate for a property that does not have a gas supply or a gas meter fitted. I have to pay a gas engineer once a year to certify that I have not fitted a gas supply or meter to the property. 

Proth Major has applied for a job in a coffee shop. She's not allowed to use the grill until she's 18. I'm not sure what will magically occur on her 18th birthday that suddenly renders her grill-competent, but there's an impediment to youth employment right there. 

If you've invested in property, a business, an investment platform or anything at all "odd" over the last 20 years you'll have had to jump through the most ridiculous hoops to complete a deal or open an account. You can guarantee the bank you've been with for decades will block the first payment of any size you make to any new product. Yet money laundering and fraud is a greater problem than ever.

None of this helps the individual. None of this helps the tenant, the employer or the financial institution. I feel them, literally daily - as micro-aggressions from the state.

YET - like you say, the disaster area of child welfare in private sector homes is wholly unsanctioned. Why? Because it's easier for the state to make life harder for those of us who comply with the minutae of law than those that don't. I couldn't agree with you more about children in care, but the public sector has just as an appalling record as the private sector does - to our shame as a country.

Outsourcing of services to the private sector happens in most democratic countries. Some of it works really well, some of it doesn't. But as someone who works in contracts, SLAs and contractor performance every day I can tell you that problems in contract performance are usually due to poor scoping, input rather than output-based RFPS and a lack of penalties and sanctions (or oversight).

Burnham is dog-whistling about neo-liberalism, the advance of which which pretty much came to a grinding halt with the election of Blair.

The examples you give are not regulation, they are how the local authority and the employer have interpreted them. I suspect the LA is asking for something because they have a box on their form. No law requires you to have a gas safety certificate if you don’t have gas appliances.
Reply
#84
For the victim it matters not who wields the knife
Reply
#85
You are saying that we can’t have been neoliberal because we have too much regulation. We don’t, all of the examples you give are not regulations, they’re just daft people over compensating in case they make a mistake.
Reply
#86
(06-06-2026, 08:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You are saying that we can’t have been neoliberal because we have too much regulation. We don’t, all of the examples you give are not regulations, they’re just daft people over compensating in case they make a mistake.


True

As a Hayek cultist and true believer, Proth should know that neoliberalism acknowledges a role for government in regulating and organising so that the market economy can do its thing - and fuck everything up for the vast majority of the population.
Reply
#87
The government evidently - is perfectly capable of fucking everything up, it doesn’t need the market to do that.

However, as evidenced anywhere forever - if a government wishes to improve the lot of society in general it very definitely needs the market.
Reply
#88
Off piste but sobering from Jeremy in his book.

When I was Chancellor of the Exchequer I saw projections that the national debt – the borrowings on which we as a country make huge interest payments – would increase from around 100 per cent of GDP (gross domestic product) currently to an impossible 300 per cent by the 2070s.
Reply
#89
(06-07-2026, 09:37 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Off piste but sobering from Jeremy in his book.

When I was Chancellor of the Exchequer I saw projections that the national debt – the borrowings on which we as a country make huge interest payments – would increase from around 100 per cent of GDP (gross domestic product) currently to an impossible 300 per cent by the 2070s.

Although I'm loathed to admit this I went to his Smith Square book tour thing, hoping for some illumination.

As it is, all Hunt did and has done in his book is state the bleeding obvious. Yes, we're heading to hell in handcart - no, politicians don't want to do anything about it. The regression from reality since 2008 beggars belief.

If only we'd all accepted that we needed to be a little poorer (for a short time) in 2008, again (for a short time) during Covid and again (for a short time) with the Ukraine price shock then we wouldn't be here. When, describing the PLP,  Pat McFadden reprised his Westlife days he was absolutely right in claiming "When you looking like that" "Nothing's gonna change" they're taking us for "Fool Again" and when the fiscal crisis eventually hits it will be "Us against the world"
Reply
#90
(06-07-2026, 09:37 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Off piste but sobering from Jeremy in his book.

When I was Chancellor of the Exchequer I saw projections that the national debt – the borrowings on which we as a country make huge interest payments – would increase from around 100 per cent of GDP (gross domestic product) currently to an impossible 300 per cent by the 2070s.

I've agreed a lot with what he's said in his book tour regarding the fiscal issues in this country (fuck buying his book though), though that may be attributable to confirmation bias.

Which begs the question; why the fuck did you not do anything? Why did you ecaserbate those issues (especially cutting NICs)?

Same with Sunak in his Times opinion pieces. They were the PM and Chancellor, had nothing to lose as the Tories were fucked anyway and did absolutely nothing to fix the obvious. I don't care about your opinions because you knew that at the time and were to scared to either stare down the issues in our political system and fix them or fix the political system.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)