National Service
#81
The pledge was launched just two days after the defence minister Andrew Murrison said that the government had no plans for national service in “any form” because it would do more harm than good.

In an answer to a written parliamentary question, Murrison said placing “potentially unwilling” recruits with professional soldiers “could damage morale, recruitment and retention and would consume professional military and naval resources”.

He added that if, on the other hand, temporary recruits were kept separate “it would be difficult to find a proper and meaningful role for them, potentially harming motivation and discipline”.




Siri: fetch me the meaning of “on the hoof”
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#82
National service will be good for kids, says generation who've never had to do national service.

Boomers, man.
Reply
#83
Interesting Fred, this. I can see both points of view.

I don't think it can be argued that, generally, this generation of kids lack discipline and respect, and a National Service type discipline would instil those qualities into them. However, I don't believe our defence services should be subjected to taking anyone on that doesn't want to be there. That can not be good for anyone involved. 

I personally don't believe it's the answer, but I can see the argument.

The real issue is that society and schools are too soft on kids. They go through school without learning any discipline. That being said, you'll always get pondlife in society, that believe rules and law don't apply to them and they can act how they want. It's a sad fact of life and I'm not sure you'll ever eradicate that.

That doesn't mean as a society we should give up and accept it, something needs to be done because society is going to the dogs as it stands. As a general sweeping statement, society has become selfish, arrogant, and lacks any respect for anyone, and that has become increasingly the case since the Pandemic.

I'm not sure how you go about changing that attitude, but National Service isn't the answer, I don't think.
Reply
#84
Here's a thought. Why don't they invest the 2.5 billion in youth services that actually focus on the root cause?
Reply
#85
We'll be glad of trained soldiers when Putin comes knocking.

My dad did National Service, said it was one of the best things he ever did. Everyone I know who joined up also said it was the best thing they ever did. Chance to learn a real trade and a lot get degrees too.
Reply
#86
(05-27-2024, 08:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Here's a thought. Why don't they invest the 2.5 billion in youth services that actually focus on the root cause?

That's far to sensible.
I thought all the youth clubs and centres had been closed and turned into food banks or knocked down.
Reply
#87
I thought I'd posted on this thread yesterday, but my post isn't there this morning.

I can't remember exactly what I said, but it was along the lines of this being a desperate, ill-considered gimmick by a party that has nothing more to offer after 14 years of failure. The idea is only likely to appeal to older voters, but it's been so long since there was national service that a lot of them probably think that it's had its day, which goes for the Tories as well of course.
Reply
#88
(05-27-2024, 07:55 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Interesting Fred, this. I can see both points of view.

I don't think it can be argued that, generally, this generation of kids lack discipline and respect, and a National Service type discipline would instil those qualities into them. However, I don't believe our defence services should be subjected to taking anyone on that doesn't want to be there. That can not be good for anyone involved. 

I personally don't believe it's the answer, but I can see the argument.

The real issue is that society and schools are too soft on kids. They go through school without learning any discipline. That being said, you'll always get pondlife in society, that believe rules and law don't apply to them and they can act how they want. It's a sad fact of life and I'm not sure you'll ever eradicate that.

That doesn't mean as a society we should give up and accept it, something needs to be done because society is going to the dogs as it stands. As a general sweeping statement, society has become selfish, arrogant, and lacks any respect for anyone, and that has become increasingly the case since the Pandemic.

I'm not sure how you go about changing that attitude, but National Service isn't the answer, I don't think.

Today's kids smoke less, drink less, commit less crime, take fewer drugs and get pregnant less than their parents or grandparents. Any idea that the current generation needs discipline whilst previous ones didn't is absolutely bonkers.
Reply
#89
There was a fly-on-the-wall TV doc or series a few years back following a scheme in one of the U.S. states where young offenders had a choice of going to jail or going into the army for a set period. Everybody else in the unit was a young offender, I think, and the obvious intention was to put some perspective and values into their lives.

Some took to it and some struggled. Can't for the life of me remember what it was called now, though.
Reply
#90
I see they have found the magic money tree that has been missing from youth services for the past 14yrs. As Rich said invest in proper youth provision rather than this election gimmick.

Also this generation of 18yr olds are not lacking discipline or morality, most are in education, work and do other activities within their local communities. There are some like every generation have not had the best start in life but given we took away things like youth clubs, Sure Starts and other provision for families who needed extra help then what did people who agreed with austerity expect?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)