Just stop oil protests
#81
(07-20-2023, 11:53 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:42 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:36 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

I agree we need far more information, I also agree that this subject makes hypocrites of us all. I can’t and won’t be giving up my car and for my families needs I can’t afford an electric vehicle. The problem is we won’t like the answers. There aren’t going to be for the immediate futures cheaper or better alternatives than what we have. Humans are selfish, stubborn and short term creatures and it will take something absolutely catastrophic to make us change our habits by then I suspect it’ll be way too late. The Leonardo DiCaprio film Don’t Look Up is a perfect example of where we are as a species.

TBF it doesn’t make hypocrites of everyone. Only those who preach but don’t practice are the hypocrites. If you say you don’t give a shit and act like you don’t give a shit you’re hardly a hypocrite.

But the key is we need detail. I refuse to say I support a cause of stopping oil, for example, when I genuinely don’t know if this would increase our costs, and I’ll never support anything that hammers the working classes.

Likewise with electric cars etc. I don’t support this transition if it prices ordinary people out of driving while the rich can carry on.

I was sent this a few weeks ago. It will certainly make everyone realise electric cars are certainly not the eco-friendly solution. Well worth the watch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yiga3atlTRs

New BEVs are better than new ICEs for carbon emissions, but driving an old car for as long as possible and buying used are also better than buying new ICEs. There's still a point where the manufactured emissions of a BEV go below the operational emissions of an ICE though.

As for the "eco-friendly" solutions, that's walking, cycling and electrified public transport.
Reply
#82
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: CA baggie… What do you mean by the government implementing restrictions? I think this is the detail people want to know. Actual impacts on their lives. What sort of restrictions?

I don't know, I'm happy to state I don't know enough about what's truly required.  But clearly some changes or restrictions to the way we currently live will have to be implemented as we can't continue as we are.

It may be something as simple as accepting that we can't have strawberries all year round as they grow in the summer!  Why are we importing them?  Why are we importing flowers from around the world?   We may have travel restrictions placed on us, such as air-miles per annum in order to cut air traffic.  

We will have to adapt.

I don’t think there’s a chance in hell that the public will ever accept air mile restrictions. Or the businesses it would bankrupt and the impact on jobs etc. the public already watch the rich and politicians etc fly round in private jets and that pisses people off enough (and quite rightly).
Reply
#83
What I don’t get is the Earth has finite resources and yet we seem to be consuming ever more crap we don’t really need, worshipping consumerism whilst chasing exponential ‘growth’. It will stop and then what?

Btw the irony is we are on our 8th page talking about the subject as a direct/indirect result of the protesters actions.
Reply
#84
(07-20-2023, 12:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What I don’t get is the Earth has finite resources and yet we seem to be consuming ever more crap we don’t really need, worshipping consumerism whilst chasing exponential ‘growth’. It will stop and then what?

Btw the irony is we are on our 8th page talking about the subject as a direct/indirect result of the protesters actions.

But without the lorry driver, who had nothing whatsoever to do with it, this thread wouldn't even exist. The butterfly effect is truly in operation.
Reply
#85
(07-20-2023, 11:34 AM)Morley Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

The biggest impact on climate is people.  How many would support a ban on having more than 1 child?

But, how do you ban people from having more than 1 child? We only have 1, that was because we could not afford child care for another, grandparents were into their seventies etc, so we left it at that. But, any woman can fall pregnant, `it was by accident` etc. How do you enforce a ban ?
But, you then get the opposite in Western countries politicians talk about a falling birth rate, loonies like Rees -Mogg saying everyone should have more kids, but doesn`t say how you can afford to keep them, but, Sub Saharan Africa, South America etc, still have families with 6 or 7 kids,.
Hence loads come here in boats, but English (and Swedish, Danes, Poles etc ) don`t want them, as , `They are taking our jobs` etc. But, those European people don`t want jobs like cleaning toilets, sweeping streets etc.
Honestly don`t know the answer.
Reply
#86
Assume those complaining don’t walk in the middle of the brummie road after a match blocking cars ? Lots appear to do this…
Reply
#87
(07-20-2023, 12:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: CA baggie… What do you mean by the government implementing restrictions? I think this is the detail people want to know. Actual impacts on their lives. What sort of restrictions?

I don't know, I'm happy to state I don't know enough about what's truly required.  But clearly some changes or restrictions to the way we currently live will have to be implemented as we can't continue as we are.

It may be something as simple as accepting that we can't have strawberries all year round as they grow in the summer!  Why are we importing them?  Why are we importing flowers from around the world?   We may have travel restrictions placed on us, such as air-miles per annum in order to cut air traffic.  

We will have to adapt.

I don’t think there’s a chance in hell that the public will ever accept air mile restrictions. Or the businesses it would bankrupt and the impact on jobs etc. the public already watch the rich and politicians etc fly round in private jets and that pisses people off enough (and quite rightly).

What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#88
(07-20-2023, 12:27 PM)Loanee Wrote: Assume those complaining don’t walk in the middle of the brummie road after a match blocking cars ?  Lots appear to do this…

That is an excellent comparison.

Almost like-for-like circumstances.
Reply
#89
(07-20-2023, 12:27 PM)Loanee Wrote: Assume those complaining don’t walk in the middle of the brummie road after a match blocking cars ?  Lots appear to do this…

I bet they're the very same people that get all aggy with car drivers beeping at them to walk on the pavement or behind the cones.

The culture know is "all about me".
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#90
(07-20-2023, 09:18 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 09:05 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 09:01 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There's no excuse for that level of violence, but these protesters need to expect some sort of physical confrontation - it's no good wailing and moaning when some nutter goes too far. Apparently there were 160 individuals involved in these "slow march" protests. Nevertheless I would expect the police to clear the streets as quickly as possible. Yes, it costs a huge amount in police time and resources, which is why the sentences handed out should be a deterrent.

Direct action protests of all sorts are fuelled by the protesters' complete conviction that their cause transcends anyone else's rights, opinions, wellbeing or freedom to just get on with whatever they are doing. I had a sister who loved a protest, any cause gleefully taken up. It's a mindset with some people. But in my view it's only a "peaceful" protest if no-one is adversely affected by it. Delays getting to hospital, missing flights, missing important work meetings, these aren't "peaceful" outcomes. It's on the slippery slope towards terrorism, and the really enthusiastic protesters don't see that blurred line.

Good post Chesh....

x 2.

Spot on Chesh.

I actually have more sympathy with the guy giving the kicking realising that he now has the inconvenience of his car being repaired due relatively directly to these twats.

He might well be a guy of good character, who under stress has behaved what in the cold light of day looks unreasonably.

Those acting all pious, I ask would you have snapped in a similar situation?

He was with his pregnant partner who was driving and as she moved to avoid protestors a van went into the side of them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)