Acclaimed albums that are shit
#81
(03-08-2022, 07:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 11:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

I've kept out of this thread because it's so subjective. Just an opportunity to display your prejudices. I agree that "musos" ( not just blokes) of all types take themselves and their music tastes too seriously. I played in a band whose drummer was a big Genesis fan, hated Indie music and dismissed most of my favourites as "just pub rock".

So,  Meatloaf and Queen. Excellent music, clever, complicated and theatrical. If you can't appreciate a bit of musical theatre you have a chip missing IMO. But then I'm biased because I love a bit of real opera, travelled the world to see it. Many people dismiss opera as bollocks, but will pay good money to watch Cats or Les Mis.

Back to the OP. Can't think of a "classic album" that I would describe as crap, but Rumours by Fleetwood Mac doesn't hold my attention at all these days and Second Coming by Stone Roses really wasn't worth the 5 year wait.

And finally, for the benefit of Spandau, I reckon pop music mostly turned to shit after 1977. Just my onions.
What’s your age? It has a huge bearing on your mindset.

Absolutely right, we're all rooted in that moment when we first were gripped by music. I'm nearly 66, old enough to have bought Beatles singles for six'n'eightpence at Taylors in Walsall (still got them, including the ones I stole off my brother and sisters). So I was 21 and nearly finished Uni when punk came along and tried to extinguish most of my favourite sounds. Later new wave was OK, but the 80s mostly passed me by because I was married and also moving around a fair bit - no time for gigs and little money to buy records.

I've often reflected that the evolution of popular music (in the very broadest sense) in the second half of the 20th century will never be repeated. Technology for music production, broadcasting and re-production advanced tremendously. We've now reached a point where you can hear what you like whenever you like, you can make and publish music from your own home. Never again will we all hear the same thing at the same time, TOTP, Whistle Test etc., or queue to buy a long-awaited new release. We can filter our music choices so we won't hear genres we aren't interested in. Whichever decade is your personal root, you just have to be glad you were part of a magical journey.
Reply
#82
(03-08-2022, 08:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 08:49 PM)Arti Wrote: I've never understood the reverence held for The Clash.

You didn't see them live, I take it?

No, too young, though I did see Joe Strummer and the Mescaleros twice and it was a good show.  My wife adored Strummer and she would play The Clash continually when we first met and I really tried to get in to it, but it wasn't happening.
Reply
#83
Arti Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Arti Wrote:I've never understood the reverence held for The Clash.

You didn't see them live, I take it?

No, too young, though I did see Joe Strummer and the Mescaleros twice and it was a good show.  My wife adored Strummer and she would play The Clash continually when we first met and I really tried to get in to it, but it wasn't happening.

As someone who first got into music by hearing the Beatles and 60's pop, then going out listening to Motown and Tighten Up discos, then seeing Bowie a couple of times (Aladdin Sane tour), Roxy and moving all the time to 'new' sounds, I put The Clash live up there as one of the greatest live shows ever. This was 77-78. I realise that stuff has dated badly and wouldn't play it now but at that time it was just so powerful. I saw Strummer and the Mescaleros and really enjoyed it but it was simply just another band.
Reply
#84
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The White Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

A bit strong, IMO, I never liked Queen particularly, but accept that you like them, and they were talented and a good live group. I could pity anyone who can`t see how good The Beatles, Beach Boys, Pink Floyd, Jefferson Airplane, Grateful Dead, Santana, The Doors etc were, but don`t, like what you want, because it is all opinions.
Reply
#85
(03-09-2022, 01:42 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The White Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

A bit strong, IMO, I never liked Queen particularly, but accept that you like them, and they were talented and a good live group. I could pity anyone who can`t see how good The Beatles, Beach Boys, Pink Floyd, Jefferson Airplane, Grateful Dead, Santana, The Doors etc were, but don`t, like what you want, because it is all opinions.

I'd rather jack...
Reply
#86
(03-09-2022, 12:15 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 07:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 11:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

I've kept out of this thread because it's so subjective. Just an opportunity to display your prejudices. I agree that "musos" ( not just blokes) of all types take themselves and their music tastes too seriously. I played in a band whose drummer was a big Genesis fan, hated Indie music and dismissed most of my favourites as "just pub rock".

So,  Meatloaf and Queen. Excellent music, clever, complicated and theatrical. If you can't appreciate a bit of musical theatre you have a chip missing IMO. But then I'm biased because I love a bit of real opera, travelled the world to see it. Many people dismiss opera as bollocks, but will pay good money to watch Cats or Les Mis.

Back to the OP. Can't think of a "classic album" that I would describe as crap, but Rumours by Fleetwood Mac doesn't hold my attention at all these days and Second Coming by Stone Roses really wasn't worth the 5 year wait.

And finally, for the benefit of Spandau, I reckon pop music mostly turned to shit after 1977. Just my onions.
What’s your age? It has a huge bearing on your mindset.

Absolutely right, we're all rooted in that moment when we first were gripped by music. I'm nearly 66, old enough to have bought Beatles singles for six'n'eightpence at Taylors in Walsall (still got them, including the ones I stole off my brother and sisters). So I was 21 and nearly finished Uni when punk came along and tried to extinguish most of my favourite sounds. Later new wave was OK, but the 80s mostly passed me by because I was married and also moving around a fair bit - no time for gigs and little money to buy records.

I've often reflected that the evolution of popular music (in the very broadest sense) in the second half of the 20th century will never be repeated. Technology for music production, broadcasting and re-production advanced tremendously. We've now reached a point where you can hear what you like whenever you like, you can make and publish music from your own home. Never again will we all hear the same thing at the same time, TOTP, Whistle Test etc., or queue to buy a long-awaited new release. We can filter our music choices so we won't hear genres we aren't interested in. Whichever decade is your personal root, you just have to be glad you were part of a magical journey.

Brilliantly and eloquently put.

It's an incredible journey the teenage years and the effects of music on future generations won't have the same effects as it did for those who grew up in the 60s to early 2000s.

My go to era is early 80s, as that's when life started in earnest for me, with teenage romances, a few quid in my pocket etc.

However, whilst I lived through the punk, new wave years, I do genuinely wish I'd experienced the late 60s, as Tom Joad clearly did. Although he didn't answer my question it's clear that was his era.

Incidentally, now my kids generally look at older music. My daughter is listening to a lot of Beatles and the solo stuff by McCartney and Lennon at the minute.
Reply
#87
(03-09-2022, 03:05 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-09-2022, 12:15 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 07:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 11:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote: 1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

I've kept out of this thread because it's so subjective. Just an opportunity to display your prejudices. I agree that "musos" ( not just blokes) of all types take themselves and their music tastes too seriously. I played in a band whose drummer was a big Genesis fan, hated Indie music and dismissed most of my favourites as "just pub rock".

So,  Meatloaf and Queen. Excellent music, clever, complicated and theatrical. If you can't appreciate a bit of musical theatre you have a chip missing IMO. But then I'm biased because I love a bit of real opera, travelled the world to see it. Many people dismiss opera as bollocks, but will pay good money to watch Cats or Les Mis.

Back to the OP. Can't think of a "classic album" that I would describe as crap, but Rumours by Fleetwood Mac doesn't hold my attention at all these days and Second Coming by Stone Roses really wasn't worth the 5 year wait.

And finally, for the benefit of Spandau, I reckon pop music mostly turned to shit after 1977. Just my onions.
What’s your age? It has a huge bearing on your mindset.

Absolutely right, we're all rooted in that moment when we first were gripped by music. I'm nearly 66, old enough to have bought Beatles singles for six'n'eightpence at Taylors in Walsall (still got them, including the ones I stole off my brother and sisters). So I was 21 and nearly finished Uni when punk came along and tried to extinguish most of my favourite sounds. Later new wave was OK, but the 80s mostly passed me by because I was married and also moving around a fair bit - no time for gigs and little money to buy records.

I've often reflected that the evolution of popular music (in the very broadest sense) in the second half of the 20th century will never be repeated. Technology for music production, broadcasting and re-production advanced tremendously. We've now reached a point where you can hear what you like whenever you like, you can make and publish music from your own home. Never again will we all hear the same thing at the same time, TOTP, Whistle Test etc., or queue to buy a long-awaited new release. We can filter our music choices so we won't hear genres we aren't interested in. Whichever decade is your personal root, you just have to be glad you were part of a magical journey.

Brilliantly and eloquently put.

It's an incredible journey the teenage years and the effects of music on future generations won't have the same effects as it did for those who grew up in the 60s to early 2000s.

My go to era is early 80s, as that's when life started in earnest for me, with teenage romances, a few quid in my pocket etc.

However, whilst I lived through the punk, new wave years, I do genuinely wish I'd experienced the late 60s, as Tom Joad clearly did. Although he didn't answer my question it's clear that was his era.

Incidentally, now my kids generally look at older music. My daughter is listening to a lot of Beatles and the solo stuff by McCartney and Lennon at the minute.
My love of 60`s rock, Hendrix, Jefferson Airplane,Steppenwolf,The Beatles etc, comes from having a much older brother, still find 60`s culture / bands / Vietnam War fascinating. My lad is nearly 20, on the side, when I am at work , sneakily listens to my old music, I know because the c.d`s are put back in the wrong place. He admits that The Beach Boys / Beatles were great.
Reply
#88
Mid  to late sixties was such a great time for music, it progressed and evolved so quickly. Pink Floyd's see Emily play was a musical life changing experience for me. Then Hendrix, Cream, Jefferrson Airplane (as mentioned earlier) such a fantastic time for music, the along came reggae, just brilliant. Pity the kids choices today.
Reply
#89
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
Squid Wrote:1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

I've kept out of this thread because it's so subjective. Just an opportunity to display your prejudices. I agree that "musos" ( not just blokes) of all types take themselves and their music tastes too seriously. I played in a band whose drummer was a big Genesis fan, hated Indie music and dismissed most of my favourites as "just pub rock".

So,  Meatloaf and Queen. Excellent music, clever, complicated and theatrical. If you can't appreciate a bit of musical theatre you have a chip missing IMO. But then I'm biased because I love a bit of real opera, travelled the world to see it. Many people dismiss opera as bollocks, but will pay good money to watch Cats or Les Mis.

Back to the OP. Can't think of a "classic album" that I would describe as crap, but Rumours by Fleetwood Mac doesn't hold my attention at all these days and Second Coming by Stone Roses really wasn't worth the 5 year wait.

And finally, for the benefit of Spandau, I reckon pop music mostly turned to shit after 1977. Just my onions.
What’s your age? It has a huge bearing on your mindset.

Absolutely right, we're all rooted in that moment when we first were gripped by music. I'm nearly 66, old enough to have bought Beatles singles for six'n'eightpence at Taylors in Walsall (still got them, including the ones I stole off my brother and sisters). So I was 21 and nearly finished Uni when punk came along and tried to extinguish most of my favourite sounds. Later new wave was OK, but the 80s mostly passed me by because I was married and also moving around a fair bit - no time for gigs and little money to buy records.

I've often reflected that the evolution of popular music (in the very broadest sense) in the second half of the 20th century will never be repeated. Technology for music production, broadcasting and re-production advanced tremendously. We've now reached a point where you can hear what you like whenever you like, you can make and publish music from your own home. Never again will we all hear the same thing at the same time, TOTP, Whistle Test etc., or queue to buy a long-awaited new release. We can filter our music choices so we won't hear genres we aren't interested in. Whichever decade is your personal root, you just have to be glad you were part of a magical journey.

Brilliantly and eloquently put.

It's an incredible journey the teenage years and the effects of music on future generations won't have the same effects as it did for those who grew up in the 60s to early 2000s.

My go to era is early 80s, as that's when life started in earnest for me, with teenage romances, a few quid in my pocket etc.

However, whilst I lived through the punk, new wave years, I do genuinely wish I'd experienced the late 60s, as Tom Joad clearly did. Although he didn't answer my question it's clear that was his era.

Incidentally, now my kids generally look at older music. My daughter is listening to a lot of Beatles and the solo stuff by McCartney and Lennon at the minute.
I may have mislead you there Spandau, apologies. My late 60s experience was as a kid. The 70s were my coming of age moments. Just a few years ahead of you, I guess.  Sneaking into the Throstle Clubs and Queen Mary discos underage listening to Prince Buster and Motown, seeing Bowie at Wolvo and Brum. Likewise Roxy Music. Then when punk came along it was really exciting and seemed to shake everything up. To this day I still go to gigs regularly but I find I've mellowed a lot. Less guitars and more lyrics is the new order. I don't really knock anything, whether I get it or not, although I'll stand on Gary Barlow's fuggin head if he ever tries to start singing in my local.  Big Grin
Reply
#90
(03-09-2022, 06:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:I've kept out of this thread because it's so subjective. Just an opportunity to display your prejudices. I agree that "musos" ( not just blokes) of all types take themselves and their music tastes too seriously. I played in a band whose drummer was a big Genesis fan, hated Indie music and dismissed most of my favourites as "just pub rock".

So,  Meatloaf and Queen. Excellent music, clever, complicated and theatrical. If you can't appreciate a bit of musical theatre you have a chip missing IMO. But then I'm biased because I love a bit of real opera, travelled the world to see it. Many people dismiss opera as bollocks, but will pay good money to watch Cats or Les Mis.

Back to the OP. Can't think of a "classic album" that I would describe as crap, but Rumours by Fleetwood Mac doesn't hold my attention at all these days and Second Coming by Stone Roses really wasn't worth the 5 year wait.

And finally, for the benefit of Spandau, I reckon pop music mostly turned to shit after 1977. Just my onions.
What’s your age? It has a huge bearing on your mindset.

Absolutely right, we're all rooted in that moment when we first were gripped by music. I'm nearly 66, old enough to have bought Beatles singles for six'n'eightpence at Taylors in Walsall (still got them, including the ones I stole off my brother and sisters). So I was 21 and nearly finished Uni when punk came along and tried to extinguish most of my favourite sounds. Later new wave was OK, but the 80s mostly passed me by because I was married and also moving around a fair bit - no time for gigs and little money to buy records.

I've often reflected that the evolution of popular music (in the very broadest sense) in the second half of the 20th century will never be repeated. Technology for music production, broadcasting and re-production advanced tremendously. We've now reached a point where you can hear what you like whenever you like, you can make and publish music from your own home. Never again will we all hear the same thing at the same time, TOTP, Whistle Test etc., or queue to buy a long-awaited new release. We can filter our music choices so we won't hear genres we aren't interested in. Whichever decade is your personal root, you just have to be glad you were part of a magical journey.

Brilliantly and eloquently put.

It's an incredible journey the teenage years and the effects of music on future generations won't have the same effects as it did for those who grew up in the 60s to early 2000s.

My go to era is early 80s, as that's when life started in earnest for me, with teenage romances, a few quid in my pocket etc.

However, whilst I lived through the punk, new wave years, I do genuinely wish I'd experienced the late 60s, as Tom Joad clearly did. Although he didn't answer my question it's clear that was his era.

Incidentally, now my kids generally look at older music. My daughter is listening to a lot of Beatles and the solo stuff by McCartney and Lennon at the minute.
I may have mislead you there Spandau, apologies. My late 60s experience was as a kid. The 70s were my coming of age moments. Just a few years ahead of you, I guess.  Sneaking into the Throstle Clubs and Queen Mary discos underage listening to Prince Buster and Motown, seeing Bowie at Wolvo and Brum. Likewise Roxy Music. Then when punk came along it was really exciting and seemed to shake everything up. To this day I still go to gigs regularly but I find I've mellowed a lot. Less guitars and more lyrics is the new order. I don't really knock anything, whether I get it or not, although I'll stand on Gary Barlow's fuggin head if he ever tries to start singing in my local.  Big Grin

Yea, people who like Take That and Mariah Carey and only used to buy one Cd a year from Tesco. Hideous people. 

They listen to Heart FM.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: