That Townsend cross
#71
(02-15-2024, 12:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think we have to be realistic about the quality of player we can afford currently. Which makes it even more silly when we criticise those perfectly capable players we already have. Given our defensive record wtf are we even talking about weak links in our defence?!?!?

Derek come on .....look at the chance on Tuesday for them ....cross over his head again and not close to the defender 


It's the same mistake over and over again
Reply
#72
(02-15-2024, 12:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 11:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 10:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 09:36 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.

Signed as a centre half and got pushed to left back, if I recall? He played poor at centre half but did a decent job at left back. I thought he was a good player for us. 

Memory may be hazy and that may be bollocks.

Think he was already playing LB for Blues when we signed him. He was primarily bought as a LB who could fill in at CB when needed.

Very much a typical Roy-era signing - solid, unspectacular, wasn't too invested in crossing the halfway line... He was doomed from the start due to his Villa connections and the growing desire at the time for sexier signings.

I don't recall Ridgewell being particularly slagged off or hated.  He was a solid, dependable player.  The idea we hate fullbacks is just crap.

There's always a weakest player in an eleven, every fan base does it and maybe that has been both Furlong and maybe more so Townsend at times which is why they get highlighted.

This forum has always moaned about full backs as far back as I can remember and that was the original Hawthorns Hearbeat before the E&S dumped their forums. They are always out of position, should have cut the cross out, crap at crossing, dive into tackles too much, don’t dive into tackles enough, shout too much, don’t shout enough, too softer feet, not soft enough feet.  They can never win… either we’ve had really bad fullbacks every season or the experts on here love to moan about them.
Reply
#73
They have been our weak link for at least 3 seasons
Reply
#74
(02-15-2024, 12:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 11:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 10:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 09:36 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.

Signed as a centre half and got pushed to left back, if I recall? He played poor at centre half but did a decent job at left back. I thought he was a good player for us. 

Memory may be hazy and that may be bollocks.

Think he was already playing LB for Blues when we signed him. He was primarily bought as a LB who could fill in at CB when needed.

Very much a typical Roy-era signing - solid, unspectacular, wasn't too invested in crossing the halfway line... He was doomed from the start due to his Villa connections and the growing desire at the time for sexier signings.

I don't recall Ridgewell being particularly slagged off or hated.  He was a solid, dependable player.  The idea we hate fullbacks is just crap.

There's always a weakest player in an eleven, every fan base does it and maybe that has been both Furlong and maybe more so Townsend at times which is why they get highlighted.

Nah, Ridgewell copped it loads, both on here and in the ground. I recall people sat waiting for the first possible excuse to have a go at him.
Reply
#75
Personally think it’s the hardest position to play in modern football, you’re expected to defend, create, run endlessly, cross, close down, shoot and never be out of position. It’s a thankless task of a position, particularly over the last decade or so. We have had a myriad of full backs and not one can do all of those tasks well but they are expected to, which is madness. If they could they wouldn’t be playing for us and particularly not now in the Championship.
Reply
#76
Townsend’s main issue is that he just doesn’t seem a very clever player. His decision-making leads to many “oh, FFS sakes” and the crossing is an example of that. He could also do with actually putting some effort in with his right foot so he doesn’t always have to turn fuggin clockwise. As has been oft said before it’s inexplicable how he turned in better performances for the most part in the league above where attacking and overlapping was a big part of his game and most of the time we look better when he’s doing that. Agree with Clem on cut-backs from crosses as well so we can boost the tally of the more attacking midfielders.
Reply
#77
I must sit in my bubble at the ground every week as I've not really heard this abuse aimed at Townsend or Furlong. People have moaned a bit on here about them, rightly so in some instances, and everything is heightened on these types of forums.

I think there's a lot of people being OTT about people moaning about people moaning.

Did we moan about Steven Reid or Billy Jones or Balis or Clemence or Zuiverloon? I thought they were all universally liked. I'd sure as hell like to hope we moaned about Andy McDermott and Neil Parsley - they were shit full backs in a shit squad. And we definitely moaned about Jason Davidson - he was terrible too.

I don't believe any of those were moaned about any more than anyone else. Gamboa was positively loved by at least one person on this forum.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#78
(02-15-2024, 01:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I must sit in my bubble at the ground every week as I've not really heard this abuse aimed at Townsend or Furlong.  People have moaned a bit on here about them, rightly so in some instances, and everything is heightened on these types of forums.

I think there's a lot of people being OTT about people moaning about people moaning.

Did we moan about Steven Reid or Billy Jones or Balis or Clemence or Zuiverloon?  I thought they were all universally liked.  I'd sure as hell like to hope we moaned about Andy McDermott and Neil Parsley - they were shit full backs in a shit squad.  And we definitely moaned about Jason Davidson - he was terrible too.

I don't believe any of those were moaned about any more than anyone else.  Gamboa was positively loved by at least one person on this forum.
I think this post moaning about people moaning about people moaning is very OTT.
Reply
#79
(02-15-2024, 01:17 PM)Fido Wrote: Townsend’s main issue is that he just doesn’t seem a very clever player. His decision-making leads to many “oh, FFS sakes” and the crossing is an example of that. He could also do with actually putting some effort in with his right foot so he doesn’t always have to turn fuggin clockwise. As has been oft said before it’s inexplicable how he turned in better performances for the most part in the league above where attacking and overlapping was a big part of his game and most of the time we look better when he’s doing that. Agree with Clem on cut-backs from crosses as well so we can boost the tally of the more attacking midfielders.

I am in agreement with the above and over the last 3 or 4 years at times I was thinking I was the only one seeing it. Before I added further I would like to say there has been improvement in the last 4 games to the point where I am not concentrating on what he is doing. My gripe with him is that he will not release the simple ball down the wing to our player, slows the game down, alway turns inside for the pass, runs forward but never back, poor decision making and costs more goals than any other defender. Furlong has had his problems but this season has worked out his game. Waiting for CT to do the same but time is running out.
Reply
#80
I've just caught last night's highlights, I noticed Townsend whipped a couple of great crosses in where the attacking players should have done better. I'll await those who are too eager to criticise to give credit where it's due.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)