Little Rishi
#71
(10-24-2023, 12:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s all well and good those who think you can shoot, bomb and maim your way to peace whilst sitting on their sofa’s in the U.K., it’s a bit different when the unfortunate ‘collateral damage’ is a loved one or friend. If that happened to those advocating more and more violence as the answer, they would never forgive, never forget and would be pushed to the extremes politically. You will create more terrorist for the future, you may see a lull whilst they grow up full of hatred but it will return. That’s what has and will continue to happen unless there is a long term solution and if the answer is trying to make Israel a fortress surrounded by enemies it’s never going to find peace or make it’s citizens safe. That is selling a populist lie, offering simple solutions to complex and truly awful problems.

Can I ask what you believe Iran / Hamas was attempting to do when it kicked off the latest conflagration? 

Because from where I'm sitting it was a reaction to Israel gradually and painstakingly making peace and cooperation agreements with those of its neighbours that aren't failed states in their own right.
Iran isn't interested in stability in the Middle East unless it's on Iranian terms. Hamas & Hezbollah are Iran's useful idiots. 

The two-state solution is dead for as long as Hamas rules in Gaza, and for as long as Iran's mullahs draw breath.

So what is this the long term solution you're suggesting?

Is it Israel simply rolling over and accepting the greatest atrocity suffered by the Jewish people since the Holocaust?

Or is it peace on Iranian terms?

I have no doubt this board has its closeted Jew Baiters, but they're far outweighed by the hordes of hopelessly naive on this thread. 

It's no coincidence that most of the Islamic world is under the jackboot of corrupt autocracy. Arabs in any Middle Eastern nation are powerless pawns in tribal and religious power games. And you don't give succour to cunts like that.

I mentioned the fall of Berlin last week. The street by street defeat of the Nazis didn't create more Nazis. I wonder why you think the logic is different here? Are you speaking to anyone in Gaza? Or just those from Moseley or Islington?

I actually agree with this part. That is why instead of trying to level Gaza to the ground, Israel should have first reached out to Saudi, Jordan and Egypt, none of whom are fond of Hamas, Qatar or Iran and come up with some kind of strategy to counter Hamas/generate an alternative for Gaza using regional cooperation. That would have made Iran very unhappy.

But no. Israel is now yet again isolated in the region and isolated after showing the world that it is nowhere near as strong or powerful as everyone believed. The main news story globally are the deaths in Gaza, which increasingly look to the wider world not as a "targeted response", but as pointless revenge.
Reply
#72
(10-24-2023, 01:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 01:04 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The Hamas attack was a successful attempt to draw more people into the argument. 

Which argument? The Hamas only exists to destroy Israel and Israelis argument? Or another argument?

Their cause. As you know full well.
I sincerely hope you are proved to be correct. I see no such easy answer.
Reply
#73
For a "last word on the matter", seems to be dragging on as repetitive as ever.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#74
This is twitter, but it's really quite a good look at all the potential outcomes of what is currently happening:

https://twitter.com/iyad_elbaghdadi/stat...0Q9Fg&s=19

For those who don't have Twitter:


https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/17165...27072.html
Reply
#75
Really good thread that. And certainly a lot more use than the standard anti-semitism trope lobbed at anyone open minded enough to see it as a problem that is multi-faceted in nature.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#76
(10-24-2023, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 03:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you honestly think what the Israeli government is doing right now is going to help empower the Palestinian Authority in Gaza and allow them to take political control? Because I don't.

And what happened in Germany post WWII was massive developmental funding in the West and occupation in the East, I highly doubt Israel is going to pump money into Gaza and they don't even want to occupy it, so how is that supposed to work? I can also point to Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan, Northern Ireland or Germany in WWI where punitive action made things worse.

Everything about your position is hoping that Israel is on course to get rid of Hamas, forgive me for being skeptical especially with the current Israeli government in charge. The leadership and funding isn't even in Gaza, and it's not like the Hamas military leadership using Gazans as human shields and accidentally bombing them with faulty munitions has resulted in wavering support in Gaza, has it?

The only way I see an out here is for any ground invasion of Gaza to be in conjunction with restoring PA control there.

I honestly don't care about empowering the PA, they seem as illegitimate to the Gazans as Hamas does.

The Arab League could fund development in Gaza. It chooses not to.

Nor do I agree with you about support for Hamas. Across the Islamic world populations generally support the status quo, failure to do so doesn't generally end well. How solid is that kind of support when you cut the head off the snake? Egypt doesn't want the Muslim Brotherhood next door either, hence its tacit support (read: lack of outright condemnation) for what Israel is doing.

Removing or undermining Hamas in Gaza creates a power vacuum, that power vacuum has to be filled by someone. Israel doesn't want to fill it, Egypt doesn't want to fill it. Either fill it with PA or Hamas will come back as their funding and political framework is outside Gaza. That is why Lapid brought up needing to ensure PA are part of the solution with any ground invasion. In West Germany and West Berlin that was the allied states and in East Germany that was the communists, if you don't fill it you end up with an Iraq or Libya. And Iraq and Libya were not taken over by the "status quo".

And I'm well aware of Sisi's aversion to the Muslim Brotherhood and their affiliates like Hamas.

And this goes back to something I've said more than one, the head of the snake is not in Gaza so you can't cut it off there, that is why unless Israel is planning to also invade Qatar and Iran they need to replace Hamas with something and the only thing to replace them with is the PA. You can't just hope that a ground invasion with seemingly no end game is going to magically resolve itself.
Reply
#77
5,000 now dead in Gaza. Premature babies will be soon unable to breathe.

Meanwhile it’s all apparently necessary.

I hope the UN discord actually results in some meaningful action, because this is now a genocidal siege (however it was provoked).
Reply
#78
The lime trotted out that Hamas wants the destruction of Israel is looking increasingly hollow as they conduct genocide. It's an event that history will only look back on with ever greater disdain.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#79
(10-24-2023, 04:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 12:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s all well and good those who think you can shoot, bomb and maim your way to peace whilst sitting on their sofa’s in the U.K., it’s a bit different when the unfortunate ‘collateral damage’ is a loved one or friend. If that happened to those advocating more and more violence as the answer, they would never forgive, never forget and would be pushed to the extremes politically. You will create more terrorist for the future, you may see a lull whilst they grow up full of hatred but it will return. That’s what has and will continue to happen unless there is a long term solution and if the answer is trying to make Israel a fortress surrounded by enemies it’s never going to find peace or make it’s citizens safe. That is selling a populist lie, offering simple solutions to complex and truly awful problems.

Can I ask what you believe Iran / Hamas was attempting to do when it kicked off the latest conflagration? 

Because from where I'm sitting it was a reaction to Israel gradually and painstakingly making peace and cooperation agreements with those of its neighbours that aren't failed states in their own right.
Iran isn't interested in stability in the Middle East unless it's on Iranian terms. Hamas & Hezbollah are Iran's useful idiots. 

The two-state solution is dead for as long as Hamas rules in Gaza, and for as long as Iran's mullahs draw breath.

So what is this the long term solution you're suggesting?

Is it Israel simply rolling over and accepting the greatest atrocity suffered by the Jewish people since the Holocaust?

Or is it peace on Iranian terms?

I have no doubt this board has its closeted Jew Baiters, but they're far outweighed by the hordes of hopelessly naive on this thread. 

It's no coincidence that most of the Islamic world is under the jackboot of corrupt autocracy. Arabs in any Middle Eastern nation are powerless pawns in tribal and religious power games. And you don't give succour to cunts like that.

I mentioned the fall of Berlin last week. The street by street defeat of the Nazis didn't create more Nazis. I wonder why you think the logic is different here? Are you speaking to anyone in Gaza? Or just those from Moseley or Islington?

I actually agree with this part. That is why instead of trying to level Gaza to the ground, Israel should have first reached out to Saudi, Jordan and Egypt, none of whom are fond of Hamas, Qatar or Iran and come up with some kind of strategy to counter Hamas/generate an alternative for Gaza using regional cooperation. That would have made Iran very unhappy.

But no. Israel is now yet again isolated in the region and isolated after showing the world that it is nowhere near as strong or powerful as everyone believed. The main news story globally are the deaths in Gaza, which increasingly look to the wider world not as a "targeted response", but as pointless revenge.

The fact that Israel was normalising relations with neighbours is the very reason Iran instructed Hamas to act. You've put the cart before the horse.
Reply
#80
(10-24-2023, 04:55 PM)Squid Wrote: This is twitter, but it's really quite a good look at all the potential outcomes of what is currently happening:

https://twitter.com/iyad_elbaghdadi/stat...0Q9Fg&s=19

For those who don't have Twitter:


https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/17165...27072.html

(10-24-2023, 10:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 04:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 12:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s all well and good those who think you can shoot, bomb and maim your way to peace whilst sitting on their sofa’s in the U.K., it’s a bit different when the unfortunate ‘collateral damage’ is a loved one or friend. If that happened to those advocating more and more violence as the answer, they would never forgive, never forget and would be pushed to the extremes politically. You will create more terrorist for the future, you may see a lull whilst they grow up full of hatred but it will return. That’s what has and will continue to happen unless there is a long term solution and if the answer is trying to make Israel a fortress surrounded by enemies it’s never going to find peace or make it’s citizens safe. That is selling a populist lie, offering simple solutions to complex and truly awful problems.

Can I ask what you believe Iran / Hamas was attempting to do when it kicked off the latest conflagration? 

Because from where I'm sitting it was a reaction to Israel gradually and painstakingly making peace and cooperation agreements with those of its neighbours that aren't failed states in their own right.
Iran isn't interested in stability in the Middle East unless it's on Iranian terms. Hamas & Hezbollah are Iran's useful idiots. 

The two-state solution is dead for as long as Hamas rules in Gaza, and for as long as Iran's mullahs draw breath.

So what is this the long term solution you're suggesting?

Is it Israel simply rolling over and accepting the greatest atrocity suffered by the Jewish people since the Holocaust?

Or is it peace on Iranian terms?

I have no doubt this board has its closeted Jew Baiters, but they're far outweighed by the hordes of hopelessly naive on this thread. 

It's no coincidence that most of the Islamic world is under the jackboot of corrupt autocracy. Arabs in any Middle Eastern nation are powerless pawns in tribal and religious power games. And you don't give succour to cunts like that.

I mentioned the fall of Berlin last week. The street by street defeat of the Nazis didn't create more Nazis. I wonder why you think the logic is different here? Are you speaking to anyone in Gaza? Or just those from Moseley or Islington?

I actually agree with this part. That is why instead of trying to level Gaza to the ground, Israel should have first reached out to Saudi, Jordan and Egypt, none of whom are fond of Hamas, Qatar or Iran and come up with some kind of strategy to counter Hamas/generate an alternative for Gaza using regional cooperation. That would have made Iran very unhappy.

But no. Israel is now yet again isolated in the region and isolated after showing the world that it is nowhere near as strong or powerful as everyone believed. The main news story globally are the deaths in Gaza, which increasingly look to the wider world not as a "targeted response", but as pointless revenge.

The fact that Israel was normalising relations with neighbours is the very reason Iran instructed Hamas to act. You've put the cart before the horse.

I didn't disagree with that. My point was that Israel's response in Gaza has alienated their Arab allies. Israel is now the most isolated it's been in decades, because Netanyahu has prioritised his own political survival and legacy over the long term interests of the country.

Western support for Israel is fading, particularly when you take a generational perspective. The West also doesn't want to be worrying too much about Israel when there are the bigger concerns of Russia and China.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)