Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
We won’t appeal. No mention of an appeal on the OS and the BBC website states we won’t appeal. I read the BBC article, because I wanted to see if they’d gloated about it being discussed by their punTits.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(01-11-2023, 08:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
It's not the incident itself, for me, I agree it was a definite swing of the elbow. What really grinds my gears is the way it's come about. Basically sprout face kicks up a fuss to create a bit of drama and puts it in the public eye No-one can tell me however, that there were not similar incidents in other games last weekend which weren't highlighted so go unpunished.
It really is trial by pundit and as pundits are unashamedly biased, that is corrupt.
My feelings exactly. If BTA had done that a few months ago for Salford against Hartlepool with one camera on halfway would it have been highlighted? Very doubtful. If you are going to retrospectively ban players then it needs to be a level playing field in terms of opportunity to see such things. I would also be interested in who told the FA to look into it, or whether they just watch MOTD.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-11-2023, 08:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
It's not the incident itself, for me, I agree it was a definite swing of the elbow. What really grinds my gears is the way it's come about. Basically sprout face kicks up a fuss to create a bit of drama and puts it in the public eye No-one can tell me however, that there were not similar incidents in other games last weekend which weren't highlighted so go unpunished.
It really is trial by pundit and as pundits are unashamedly biased, that is corrupt.
Not so sure, I would imagine the Chesterfield coaches would have made the officials well aware at the time and following the game. It will have been on the officials radar well before Murphy opened his mouth.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(01-11-2023, 09:11 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-11-2023, 08:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
It's not the incident itself, for me, I agree it was a definite swing of the elbow. What really grinds my gears is the way it's come about. Basically sprout face kicks up a fuss to create a bit of drama and puts it in the public eye No-one can tell me however, that there were not similar incidents in other games last weekend which weren't highlighted so go unpunished.
It really is trial by pundit and as pundits are unashamedly biased, that is corrupt.
Not so sure, I would imagine the Chesterfield coaches would have made the officials well aware at the time and following the game. It will have been on the officials radar well before Murphy opened his mouth. Wouldn't that have happened in other games though mate? Maybe I am being over cynical, but it seems strange that the only action taken was the one that the BBC made a big thing of.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
01-11-2023, 09:24 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2023, 09:25 AM by Ted Maul.)
(01-11-2023, 09:21 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-11-2023, 09:11 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-11-2023, 08:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
It's not the incident itself, for me, I agree it was a definite swing of the elbow. What really grinds my gears is the way it's come about. Basically sprout face kicks up a fuss to create a bit of drama and puts it in the public eye No-one can tell me however, that there were not similar incidents in other games last weekend which weren't highlighted so go unpunished.
It really is trial by pundit and as pundits are unashamedly biased, that is corrupt.
Not so sure, I would imagine the Chesterfield coaches would have made the officials well aware at the time and following the game. It will have been on the officials radar well before Murphy opened his mouth. Wouldn't that have happened in other games though mate? Maybe I am being over cynical, but it seems strange that the only action taken was the one that the BBC made a big thing of.
Game finished about five hours before MOTD started, there was never going to be an official complaint and review in that time frame, the timings are coincidental. Interviews with Chesterfield staff after the match reference it, the incident will have been reported pretty much then but I'd imagine it wouldn't have been reviewed until Monday earliest. Ultimately it was a pretty deserved ban, you can't go round elbowing people so I don't have any complaints really. My only gripe is that they can't retrospectively ban their lad for a cheap shot on Ajayi, which is even worse when you consider Ajayi had just spent four months out with an ankle injury.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(01-11-2023, 09:21 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Wouldn't that have happened in other games though mate? Maybe I am being over cynical, but it seems strange that the only action taken was the one that the BBC made a big thing of.
It might just be that there weren't any similar incidents in the other games. The fact that we're not appealing against the ban implies that the club accepts that BTA did catch their player with his elbow and that attempting to make a case that he did it accidentally would be futile as it can't unequivocally be proven. You don't have to be looking at someone to deliberately elbow them.
I'm not saying that it was a deliberate act to elbow him in the face, just that we don't have sufficient proof to be able to show that it wasn't.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
01-11-2023, 11:17 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2023, 11:18 AM by Cheshire East Baggie.)
(01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
Is there any clear video evidence of what happened? BTA waved an arm, as the other fellow was pulling him back. Was it elbow straight in the mouth, or outstretched fingers brushing past his cheek? Did the Chesterfield player look seriously injured? Or did he go down shouting for a foul as he knew BTA was away from him?
I'm firmly of the opionion that media comment has affected the outcome of this. Unless BTA has said to the club "yeah, bang to rights, I elbowed the bastard" I would have expected us to appeal, but Danny Murphy's comments have probably made that pointless. Maybe broadcasters should be prevented from influencing the judicial process with their bullshit opinions.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(01-11-2023, 11:17 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
Is there any clear video evidence of what happened? BTA waved an arm, as the other fellow was pulling him back. Was it elbow straight in the mouth, or outstretched fingers brushing past his cheek? Did the Chesterfield player look seriously injured? Or did he go down shouting for a foul as he knew BTA was away from him?
I'm firmly of the opionion that media comment has affected the outcome of this. Unless BTA has said to the club "yeah, bang to rights, I elbowed the bastard" I would have expected us to appeal, but Danny Murphy's comments have probably made that pointless. Maybe broadcasters should be prevented from influencing the judicial process with their bullshit opinions.
Broadcasters are paid to make comments on what happened on the pitch which is what Murphy did. I very much doubt Danny Murphy was literally the only person to notice this incident and nothing would have been reported by Chesterfield. As Ted Maul said above, BTA elbowed their player and it would be a deserved red card. I'm not really getting why people on here are whining so much about it. If it had been the other way round with their player doing the same against us to score a late equaliser there would be uproar.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-11-2023, 11:17 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (01-11-2023, 06:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't feel that hard done by on this one. I think however it does show the rules up as not being fit for purpose.
BTA has clearly swung an elbow and he's caught the lad, you can't elbow people on football pitches it's violent conduct and he deserves a ban. Only hope is that he learns from it and a positive that he only misses two league games instead of three.
Where the rules are fucking stupid is that purely because the ref saw the challenge on Ajayi and booked their lad, they can't retrospectively say "we got that one wrong", whereas VAR at the time can. I can only assume there is no right to appeal things that have been dealt with by the ref to prevent four days worth of paperwork after each match day for the FA.
The other side to this is that if the ref spots it at the time, BTA is probably sent off, we don't score the equaliser and he's still banned for three games. Are we allowed to appeal this ban, do we not risk an extra game for a frivolous appeal? If so, I'm not sure I'd bother, the evidence is pretty conclusive against him.
Is there any clear video evidence of what happened? BTA waved an arm, as the other fellow was pulling him back. Was it elbow straight in the mouth, or outstretched fingers brushing past his cheek? Did the Chesterfield player look seriously injured? Or did he go down shouting for a foul as he knew BTA was away from him?
I'm firmly of the opionion that media comment has affected the outcome of this. Unless BTA has said to the club "yeah, bang to rights, I elbowed the bastard" I would have expected us to appeal, but Danny Murphy's comments have probably made that pointless. Maybe broadcasters should be prevented from influencing the judicial process with their bullshit opinions.
It's pretty conclusive, whether accidental or not, BTA has swung his arm back at the Chesterfield player and has made contact. He can still get banned even if he hadn't of made contact as the intent is there. You cannot start throwing your arms around like that on a football pitch in 2023, it's pretty basic stuff. His actions have allowed for the debate, it's not a witch hunt.
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
01-11-2023, 12:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2023, 12:16 PM by wbamitch.)
The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back
|