Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(10-06-2021, 12:37 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Would be a bigger fuss if the other CR7 announced he hadn't taken the vaccine either!
Indeed! However, he’s keeping it quiet…..
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I wasn't going to join in because it is so daft, but here we go: For a kidney transplant you need to have the same blood group and tissue type as the recipient so it would have to be a specific group that donate. 1st port of call would be organ donors who have died and their organs could be transplanted and then if we really did have an emergency situation where half of the population needed transplants then I am sure we would see a good number of the healthy population step forward. They would do this to help society.
We would still have a number of people that wouldn't and I would guess that with the kidney donation refusers there would be a sub-group that contained all of the people who won't have the vaccine.
Having the vaccine doesn't involve you giving away a body part in order to help the rest of the population, it simply requires you to have two very well tested jabs that over 3 and a half billion people have also had. By not having the vaccine it simply isn't doing everything we can to help avoid another lockdown that will lead to jobs and lives lost.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
10-06-2021, 12:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2021, 12:50 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(10-06-2021, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-06-2021, 12:35 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (10-06-2021, 12:32 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-06-2021, 12:04 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (10-06-2021, 12:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Last reply from me on this thread, you are equating a complicated, invasive kidney removal and the risks that brings to having a jab that takes barely a second to administer and the overwhelming majority will suffer at most a sore arm and some fatigue after it for a day or two. One will help keep a number of others safer from a potential life threatening virus, and collectively reduce infection rates to a minimum the other will save one persons life. The two scenarios are not comparable.
We all have a choice to do or not do things but those choices do have an impact on others and when they do they will be judged.
Right, then it’s ok to judge you and call you a selfish idiot moron for not being prepared to donate a kidney to save a life. You selfish thoughtless self centred “I’m alright jack” attitude you have. You’re prepared to impact someone else and let them die you selfish individual.
Well actually that’s not true. You’re well within your rights not to. And you shouldn’t be judged for that. Neither should Callum Robinson. People don’t know if he has a family member had a bad reaction. Or other circumstances. But that doesn’t matter, because he’s simply drawn a different line to you. So judge away, because no one gives a shit about you judging them.
(10-06-2021, 12:02 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Donating a kidney leaves you permanently kidneyless. The vaccine does nothing to you except stop you dying of covid (probably). They aren't the same.
MY point of view is that outside of medical necessity there is absolutely no good reason not to have it. The fertility thing is a total myth and it's been tested to the nth degree. Does Robinson *need* to have it if he's had covid twice already? Maybe, maybe not but it is difficult not to label people like this as anti-vaccine because other than the inconvenience of a 10 minute trip to the clinic, why would you possibly, possibly not have it?! Even if you might not strictly need to. It can only help you and others.
This why I am all for vaccine passports etc to go to events and the like. You don't get to enjoy the privileges of living in a society while shirking it's responsibilities. Getting vaccinated against a virus that has devastated most of the world for 2 years is one of those responsibilities IMO.
No good reason? Not true. There’s someone on this board who has had a bad reaction. He has a good reason not to have any more. Robinson has weighed up his risk of covid and doesn’t want it, sane as loads of sportspeople. Folk just need to accept it.
Thank god I don’t hang around with judgmental people like DH.
I'm glad I don't hang around with people who put their rights above their responsibilities.
Yet you’d put your right to keep two kidneys above someone who was dying. Because you have drawn a different line. You selfish I’m alright jack me me me type.
Still waiting for why it’s a ludicrous comparison. It’s just a different place to draw a line.
I hang around with people who treat people as human beings, not a vaccine status. So carry on, you love a good label.
As I said we shall never agree on this and btw you are judging me, for trying to fight for the rights of the most vulnerable who cannot be vaccinated to live as normal life as possible amongst people who are making that incredibly difficult with the choices they are making. If that makes me judgemental hey-ho I can live with it.
I answered your daft comparison point as have others.
Fighting for the rights of the most vulnerable. But not when someone needs a kidney….
I’m well aware it’s an extreme comparison, but it comes down to where you draw the line.
Each to their own, I’m just glad people I know respect each other’s choices and don’t throw people into two distinct groups.
(10-06-2021, 12:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I wasn't going to join in because it is so daft, but here we go: For a kidney transplant you need to have the same blood group and tissue type as the recipient so it would have to be a specific group that donate. 1st port of call would be organ donors who have died and their organs could be transplanted and then if we really did have an emergency situation where half of the population needed transplants then I am sure we would see a good number of the healthy population step forward. They would do this to help society.
We would still have a number of people that wouldn't and I would guess that with the kidney donation refusers there would be a sub-group that contained all of the people who won't have the vaccine.
Having the vaccine doesn't involve you giving away a body part in order to help the rest of the population, it simply requires you to have two very well tested jabs that over 3 and a half billion people have also had. By not having the vaccine it simply isn't doing everything we can to help avoid another lockdown that will lead to jobs and lives lost.
And it would see a good number of healthy people not step forward! And they’d never be slagged off for it. They’d never be judged. I know it’s an extreme example. I meant it to be. It was deliberate.
If we’re locking down again with such a high vaccine take up, we might as well give up anyway.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
10-06-2021, 01:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2021, 01:06 PM by Sliced.)
There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.
There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.
It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.
Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
I think the racial abuse was prior to that Slice. I could be wrong though, apologies if so.
But you’re right that Robinsons “vaccine status” should not be a story. It’s fuck all to do with anyone. Same as everyone else. It’s personal and private.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(10-06-2021, 12:47 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 12:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I wasn't going to join in because it is so daft, but here we go: For a kidney transplant you need to have the same blood group and tissue type as the recipient so it would have to be a specific group that donate. 1st port of call would be organ donors who have died and their organs could be transplanted and then if we really did have an emergency situation where half of the population needed transplants then I am sure we would see a good number of the healthy population step forward. They would do this to help society.
We would still have a number of people that wouldn't and I would guess that with the kidney donation refusers there would be a sub-group that contained all of the people who won't have the vaccine.
Having the vaccine doesn't involve you giving away a body part in order to help the rest of the population, it simply requires you to have two very well tested jabs that over 3 and a half billion people have also had. By not having the vaccine it simply isn't doing everything we can to help avoid another lockdown that will lead to jobs and lives lost.
And it would see a good number of healthy people not step forward! And they’d never be slagged off for it. They’d never be judged. I know it’s an extreme example. I meant it to be. It was deliberate.
If we’re locking down again with such a high vaccine take up, we might as well give up anyway.
I would imagine that all needed would step forward - clearly this would only involve 50% of the population as a maximum and there would be enough to mean that not everyone was needed. In this jab situation as many people as possible are needed and unfortunately there are many that simply can't be arsed, or rely on stupid theories for their defence.
And 90% of the adult population leaves about 18M people unvaccinated in the country (12M under 15s and 6M from the rest) which leaves a large number available for more transmission who could do more. We have a higher base of people in hospital than last year (which is steady at the moment) but we are ignoring the obvious if we think that hospital numbers won't go up. The question will be how much by.
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
10-06-2021, 01:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2021, 01:16 PM by boingingjim.)
(10-06-2021, 12:41 PM)wba13 Wrote: My biggest concern would not be Calum as he possibly could not get Covid seriously but he could pass it on to someone who could get Covid seriously or die. For me it’s totally selfish not to get vaccinated unless there are underlying issues to prevent you.
As could a vaccinated person. Round and round we go. His body is his life and slight deviation in performance could seriously damage his earning potential. Post vaccine I was rough for days and had an increased heart rate of around 10-15 BPM for a week or so after. I can totally understand why a professional sportsperson would not risk this after knowing they are heavily protected with antibodies from prior infection.
Imagine a scenario where he does get some kind of heart inflammation, is that for the greater good? The vulnerable in society are protected as best as they can be with some now having had 3 shots of a vaccine. We can't live life based on what ifs. Personal risk is for each individual to weigh up and decide.
It's like me demanding that dairy is banned from all commercial kitchens because I have a severe allergy to it. I just have to look and make a judgement call based on the menu in front of me (or choose not to eat out).
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.
There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.
It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.
Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.
However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(10-06-2021, 01:10 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I think the racial abuse was prior to that Slice. I could be wrong though, apologies if so.
But you’re right that Robinsons “vaccine status” should not be a story. It’s fuck all to do with anyone. Same as everyone else. It’s personal and private.
You're right. Reported today but happened a few months ago, I stand corrected
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(10-06-2021, 01:14 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-06-2021, 12:47 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 12:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I wasn't going to join in because it is so daft, but here we go: For a kidney transplant you need to have the same blood group and tissue type as the recipient so it would have to be a specific group that donate. 1st port of call would be organ donors who have died and their organs could be transplanted and then if we really did have an emergency situation where half of the population needed transplants then I am sure we would see a good number of the healthy population step forward. They would do this to help society.
We would still have a number of people that wouldn't and I would guess that with the kidney donation refusers there would be a sub-group that contained all of the people who won't have the vaccine.
Having the vaccine doesn't involve you giving away a body part in order to help the rest of the population, it simply requires you to have two very well tested jabs that over 3 and a half billion people have also had. By not having the vaccine it simply isn't doing everything we can to help avoid another lockdown that will lead to jobs and lives lost.
And it would see a good number of healthy people not step forward! And they’d never be slagged off for it. They’d never be judged. I know it’s an extreme example. I meant it to be. It was deliberate.
If we’re locking down again with such a high vaccine take up, we might as well give up anyway.
I would imagine that all needed would step forward - clearly this would only involve 50% of the population as a maximum and there would be enough to mean that not everyone was needed. In this jab situation as many people as possible are needed and unfortunately there are many that simply can't be arsed, or rely on stupid theories for their defence.
And 90% of the adult population leaves about 18M people unvaccinated in the country (12M under 15s and 6M from the rest) which leaves a large number available for more transmission who could do more. We have a higher base of people in hospital than last year (which is steady at the moment) but we are ignoring the obvious if we think that hospital numbers won't go up. The question will be how much by.
I reckon most wouldn’t step forward! But in any case they would not be judged. But I did mean it as an extreme comparison. That was deliberate.
One further point… I’ve mentioned the labelling as “anti vax”, ignoring all nuance and throwing people in with conspiracy theorists. It annoys people who have genuine reasons. There’s been lots of that. And believe me, I’m absolutely certain that this will make them even less likely to get the vaccine. Totally certain. So the labelling and slagging off will actually be counter productive.
I’m not aiming that at you by the way Baggy1.
|