(06-10-2020, 05:30 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (06-10-2020, 04:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-10-2020, 03:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-10-2020, 08:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You've been crying for weeks about the lockdown being too harsh, ours was hardly Wuhan style military on the streets. We didn't even go as far as France or Spain, yet you wanted it eased. That report shows why we needed it as the minimum, it's also clear that we didn't lock down early or hard enough. If we'd have done that at the time, we'd be in a much better position to save the economy now. As it stands we went half measures and have to pay the price now.
The report comes from a group of scientists seeking to justify what we've done.
If you've been paying attention these last few weeks you'll have heard all manner of 'scientific' contributions to the debate. I have. There is no settled science on this matter whatsoever.
That said, the government has played a terrible game with the crap hand it was dealt.
I know I'm not alone in believing all our kids should be at school now, that the 2m distancing is based on no evidence whatsoever, that the chances for asymptomatic spread are negligible as are the chances of catching this outdoors too. That's from listening to scientists.
I look forward to the inevitable Public Inquiry into this catastrophe for our economy. Then we can start the finger pointing.
It will become abundantly clear that we've sacrificed freedoms, our children's education and the economy on a vague threat to NHS capacity that has never been tested in 12 weeks. And now we're going to have 10 million people on the NHS waiting list. Thank God I can afford health insurance for the family.
The increase in number of cases was massive at the start of the lockdown because of the uncontrolled spread, if we hadn't have had the lockdown it would have continued increasing rather than slowing down as it did. We've already had 65k excess deaths, without the lockdown you could have added 10s of thousands to that figure. We could also have locked down earlier if it wasn't for people like you screaming for the economy to be prioritised, that in itself would have done two things - reduced the number of deaths and meant we would be out of it by now and restarting the economy. If you can't see that then you really area lost cause to the $$ Spot on, I'll ask this question again to those who think we overreacted and the threat was not real, just how many deaths would you have been prepared to see before you agreeded lockdown was needed?
Lockdown was way too late so no overreaction when it did happen. If it had been at start of March and borders closed we'd have had less deaths and we'd be out of lockdown now. Whole thing totally mismanaged. But now there is an overreaction about getting people who aren't vulnerable or at risk (u45s) back out there.
Posts: 11,316
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-10-2020, 05:30 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Spot on, I'll ask this question again to those who think we overreacted and the threat was not real, just how many deaths would you have been prepared to see before you agreeded lockdown was needed?
And I'll make this point yet again.
It is not a question of Lockdown v Zero Lockdown, it's a question of selective isolation and management of those most at risk.
The number of those dying of Covid 19 without underlying medical condtions is miniscule. Tragic, but miniscule nevertheless.
Meanwhile we've laid waste to the economy, indebted the state by hundreds of billions, added 10 million to the NHS waiting list and ruined our childrens' education.
I genuinely believe there will be no second peak of deaths, I genuinely beilive the evidence that suggests asymptomatic and outdoor transmission of the virus is insignificant. There is no reason why our children should not be at school and the vast majority of people going about their daily lives.
Given the NHS has done the thick end of fuck all except Covid 19 for 3 months I strongly suspect there will be many many more premature deaths from undiagnosed / late diagnosed and untreated cancer than C19 deaths. My own mother was diagnosed late with a Stage 4 tumour and it was only the intervention of medicine that gave her 8 more largely active years. I fear there will be tens of thousands who are not so lucky.
Every decision you make in life is consciously or unconsciously driven by the principle of opportunity cost. I believe as a nation we have got this decision horribly wrong.
Posts: 8,955
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
06-11-2020, 09:34 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2020, 09:35 AM by baggy1.)
(06-11-2020, 09:23 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-10-2020, 05:30 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Spot on, I'll ask this question again to those who think we overreacted and the threat was not real, just how many deaths would you have been prepared to see before you agreeded lockdown was needed?
And I'll make this point yet again.
It is not a question of Lockdown v Zero Lockdown, it's a question of selective isolation and management of those most at risk.
The number of those dying of Covid 19 without underlying medical condtions is miniscule. Tragic, but miniscule nevertheless.
Meanwhile we've laid waste to the economy, indebted the state by hundreds of billions, added 10 million to the NHS waiting list and ruined our childrens' education.
I genuinely believe there will be no second peak of deaths, I genuinely beilive the evidence that suggests asymptomatic and outdoor transmission of the virus is insignificant. There is no reason why our children should not be at school and the vast majority of people going about their daily lives.
Given the NHS has done the thick end of fuck all except Covid 19 for 3 months I strongly suspect there will be many many more premature deaths from undiagnosed / late diagnosed and untreated cancer than C19 deaths. My own mother was diagnosed late with a Stage 4 tumour and it was only the intervention of medicine that gave her 8 more largely active years. I fear there will be tens of thousands who are not so lucky.
Every decision you make in life is consciously or unconsciously driven by the principle of opportunity cost. I believe as a nation we have got this decision horribly wrong.
You look on this as one decision which is exactly where the govt (not the nation btw) got this wrong. They could only deal with one thing at a time and because of that the many issues that are raised by that decision were ignored until someone shouted about them or they fell over.
The delay and the lack of strength in any lockdown was the 1st domino mistake that couldn't be recalled. The lack of transparency throughout make it impossible to judge the points you raise above. I agree in general with your thoughts on a second spike but without knowing how many hospital admissions there are then it is difficult to make a call on it - those figures have disappeared form the govt slides.
The NHS was the biggest fuck up throughout, they govt went to great lengths to build and have photos taken with the Nightingale hospitals and then never used them - all covid patients should have been isolated in them instead of infecting the general hospitals. If they had done that then normal hospitals could have got back to normal treatments. The big problem with all of that was that they built the nightingales and then never had any staff to put in them because, lo and behold, we have had years of cuts to the NHS and there weren't enough staff.
All of those decisions and lack of action was taken by this muppet government - I hope you are now seeing that this approach needs to change
Posts: 11,316
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
06-11-2020, 10:28 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2020, 10:33 AM by Protheroe.)
(06-11-2020, 09:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You look on this as one decision which is exactly where the govt (not the nation btw) got this wrong. They could only deal with one thing at a time and because of that the many issues that are raised by that decision were ignored until someone shouted about them or they fell over.
The delay and the lack of strength in any lockdown was the 1st domino mistake that couldn't be recalled. The lack of transparency throughout make it impossible to judge the points you raise above. I agree in general with your thoughts on a second spike but without knowing how many hospital admissions there are then it is difficult to make a call on it - those figures have disappeared form the govt slides.
The NHS was the biggest fuck up throughout, they govt went to great lengths to build and have photos taken with the Nightingale hospitals and then never used them - all covid patients should have been isolated in them instead of infecting the general hospitals. If they had done that then normal hospitals could have got back to normal treatments. The big problem with all of that was that they built the nightingales and then never had any staff to put in them because, lo and behold, we have had years of cuts to the NHS and there weren't enough staff.
All of those decisions and lack of action was taken by this muppet government - I hope you are now seeing that this approach needs to change
The issue of delay will come out in the Public Inquiry. Today I've read that Imperial had the ear of the Government with their flawed model when othe voices in SAGE were ignored. Perhaps if they hadn't been then we would've gone into Lockdown earlier.
My issue is not with the concept of Lockdown, it's simply the extent of it is ludicrous and highly damaging.
I completely agree with you about isolation of Covid 19 patients within the NHS, but I can't agree that it's a good use of limited resources to keep a standby army of nurses and doctors on hand for a 1 in 100 year pandemic.
Yes, all of these decisions have been taken by the government and I have been exceptionally critical of most of the reponses. Our bone of contention seems to revolve around your concept of an earlier fuller lockdown and my belief in a limited lockdown being lifted more quickly. We'll only find out who was right as this plays itself out, but if lasting damage is done to the economy, education and health of the nation ( https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-52985446) due to the severity of the lockdown the government will pay, and rightly so.
Posts: 8,955
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
06-11-2020, 11:44 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2020, 11:50 AM by baggy1.)
(06-11-2020, 10:28 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2020, 09:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You look on this as one decision which is exactly where the govt (not the nation btw) got this wrong. They could only deal with one thing at a time and because of that the many issues that are raised by that decision were ignored until someone shouted about them or they fell over.
The delay and the lack of strength in any lockdown was the 1st domino mistake that couldn't be recalled. The lack of transparency throughout make it impossible to judge the points you raise above. I agree in general with your thoughts on a second spike but without knowing how many hospital admissions there are then it is difficult to make a call on it - those figures have disappeared form the govt slides.
The NHS was the biggest fuck up throughout, they govt went to great lengths to build and have photos taken with the Nightingale hospitals and then never used them - all covid patients should have been isolated in them instead of infecting the general hospitals. If they had done that then normal hospitals could have got back to normal treatments. The big problem with all of that was that they built the nightingales and then never had any staff to put in them because, lo and behold, we have had years of cuts to the NHS and there weren't enough staff.
All of those decisions and lack of action was taken by this muppet government - I hope you are now seeing that this approach needs to change
The issue of delay will come out in the Public Inquiry. Today I've read that Imperial had the ear of the Government with their flawed model when othe voices in SAGE were ignored. Perhaps if they hadn't been then we would've gone into Lockdown earlier.
My issue is not with the concept of Lockdown, it's simply the extent of it is ludicrous and highly damaging.
I completely agree with you about isolation of Covid 19 patients within the NHS, but I can't agree that it's a good use of limited resources to keep a standby army of nurses and doctors on hand for a 1 in 100 year pandemic.
Yes, all of these decisions have been taken by the government and I have been exceptionally critical of most of the reponses. Our bone of contention seems to revolve around your concept of an earlier fuller lockdown and my belief in a limited lockdown being lifted more quickly. We'll only find out who was right as this plays itself out, but if lasting damage is done to the economy, education and health of the nation (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-52985446) due to the severity of the lockdown the government will pay, and rightly so.
This is really simple and i fail to understand why you can't see this. In this graph that is used every day you will see there is an increase in deaths due to the uncontrolled spread.
[img=458x207]blob:https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/621d5d7d-bd1d-46fd-88e1-8d322e46cf35[/img]
edit: not certain why this won't show but it's the daily data slide - you know what it looks like by now
And don't forget this is showing the lowest number that the govt can get away with, direct covid deaths, not the deaths with covid on the death cert or the excess deaths, so whichever way you look at it, it is a sweetened version of the truth.
If lockdown hadn't occurred then that initial spike would have continued to rise and I don't know how you can dispute that point. Now it might have tailed off eventually but we have 12M over 65s in this country that are vulnerable. The lockdown was 23rd March and although this govt chart starts are 14th March, the earliest covid 19 cases in care homes has been reported in the 1st week of March.
The govt dithered and missed opportunities - Cheltenham on the 10th - 13th March being the obvious ones. The steep line on the graph would have been much reduced with a earlier and harder lockdown meaning that by now we could have likely been in a position to get everything back to normal as soon as possible. We didn't and are now still in that uncertain phase.
Posts: 8,955
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(06-11-2020, 10:28 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I completely agree with you about isolation of Covid 19 patients within the NHS, but I can't agree that it's a good use of limited resources to keep a standby army of nurses and doctors on hand for a 1 in 100 year pandemic.
But they didn't have to keep an army of doctors and nurses on standby, just use the ones that they used anyway. They built temporary hospitals knowing they couldn't staff them - that was purely for the photo op. Instead they continued to use up precious hospital space when that could have been reopened for general care - absolutely bonkers!
Posts: 11,316
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
06-11-2020, 12:21 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2020, 12:21 PM by Protheroe.)
(06-11-2020, 11:44 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The steep line on the graph would have been much reduced with a earlier and harder lockdown meaning that by now we could have likely been in a position to get everything back to normal as soon as possible. We didn't and are now still in that uncertain phase.
This is the last post I will make on this matter as we're simply going round in circles.
a) "The Science" did not support an earlier Lockdown. This is a FACT. Revisionism of the FACTS now does not changed what they were at that point.
b) Lockdown could have been restricted to those most at risk. The spread of the virus may have been greater, but amongst those less likely to suffer acute problems.
c) Given that community spread & asymptomatic spread appear to be so limited there's no case for keeping schools closed.
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(06-11-2020, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2020, 11:44 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The steep line on the graph would have been much reduced with a earlier and harder lockdown meaning that by now we could have likely been in a position to get everything back to normal as soon as possible. We didn't and are now still in that uncertain phase.
This is the last post I will make on this matter as we're simply going round in circles.
a) "The Science" did not support an earlier Lockdown. This is a FACT. Revisionism of the FACTS now does not changed what they were at that point.
b) Lockdown could have been restricted to those most at risk. The spread of the virus may have been greater, but amongst those less likely to suffer acute problems.
c) Given that community spread & asymptomatic spread appear to be so limited there's no case for keeping schools closed.
I don't think it's a fact that science did not support an earlier lockdown, it's a fact that some scientists didn't support an earlier lockdown.
Lockdown could have been limited to those most at risk, but those countries who appear at this stage to have dealt with this most successfully didn't take that approach, countries such as NZ, Denmark, Czech Republic.
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
06-11-2020, 12:33 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2020, 12:33 PM by The liquidator.)
(06-11-2020, 11:44 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-11-2020, 10:28 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2020, 09:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You look on this as one decision which is exactly where the govt (not the nation btw) got this wrong. They could only deal with one thing at a time and because of that the many issues that are raised by that decision were ignored until someone shouted about them or they fell over.
The delay and the lack of strength in any lockdown was the 1st domino mistake that couldn't be recalled. The lack of transparency throughout make it impossible to judge the points you raise above. I agree in general with your thoughts on a second spike but without knowing how many hospital admissions there are then it is difficult to make a call on it - those figures have disappeared form the govt slides.
The NHS was the biggest fuck up throughout, they govt went to great lengths to build and have photos taken with the Nightingale hospitals and then never used them - all covid patients should have been isolated in them instead of infecting the general hospitals. If they had done that then normal hospitals could have got back to normal treatments. The big problem with all of that was that they built the nightingales and then never had any staff to put in them because, lo and behold, we have had years of cuts to the NHS and there weren't enough staff.
All of those decisions and lack of action was taken by this muppet government - I hope you are now seeing that this approach needs to change
The issue of delay will come out in the Public Inquiry. Today I've read that Imperial had the ear of the Government with their flawed model when othe voices in SAGE were ignored. Perhaps if they hadn't been then we would've gone into Lockdown earlier.
My issue is not with the concept of Lockdown, it's simply the extent of it is ludicrous and highly damaging.
I completely agree with you about isolation of Covid 19 patients within the NHS, but I can't agree that it's a good use of limited resources to keep a standby army of nurses and doctors on hand for a 1 in 100 year pandemic.
Yes, all of these decisions have been taken by the government and I have been exceptionally critical of most of the reponses. Our bone of contention seems to revolve around your concept of an earlier fuller lockdown and my belief in a limited lockdown being lifted more quickly. We'll only find out who was right as this plays itself out, but if lasting damage is done to the economy, education and health of the nation (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-52985446) due to the severity of the lockdown the government will pay, and rightly so.
This is really simple and i fail to understand why you can't see this. In this graph that is used every day you will see there is an increase in deaths due to the uncontrolled spread.
[img=458x207]blob:https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/621d5d7d-bd1d-46fd-88e1-8d322e46cf35[/img]
edit: not certain why this won't show but it's the daily data slide - you know what it looks like by now
And don't forget this is showing the lowest number that the govt can get away with, direct covid deaths, not the deaths with covid on the death cert or the excess deaths, so whichever way you look at it, it is a sweetened version of the truth.
If lockdown hadn't occurred then that initial spike would have continued to rise and I don't know how you can dispute that point. Now it might have tailed off eventually but we have 12M over 65s in this country that are vulnerable. The lockdown was 23rd March and although this govt chart starts are 14th March, the earliest covid 19 cases in care homes has been reported in the 1st week of March.
The govt dithered and missed opportunities - Cheltenham on the 10th - 13th March being the obvious ones. The steep line on the graph would have been much reduced with a earlier and harder lockdown meaning that by now we could have likely been in a position to get everything back to normal as soon as possible. We didn't and are now still in that uncertain phase.
Cheltenham could have cancelled themselves they didnt due to greed .....some of the blame goes to them aswell plus the fucking idiots who didnt lock down on the monday ......greed is the evil in everything.
Posts: 8,955
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(06-11-2020, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2020, 11:44 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The steep line on the graph would have been much reduced with a earlier and harder lockdown meaning that by now we could have likely been in a position to get everything back to normal as soon as possible. We didn't and are now still in that uncertain phase.
This is the last post I will make on this matter as we're simply going round in circles.
a) "The Science" did not support an earlier Lockdown. This is a FACT. Revisionism of the FACTS now does not changed what they were at that point.
b) Lockdown could have been restricted to those most at risk. The spread of the virus may have been greater, but amongst those less likely to suffer acute problems.
c) Given that community spread & asymptomatic spread appear to be so limited there's no case for keeping schools closed.
"The Science' is a phrase that the Govt will hide behind, there was an outcry at the time about Cheltenham, that is a fact. I remember this because my lad goes every year and he decided it was foolish based on what everyone knew at the time.
Lockdown being restricted to a specific group certainly wasn't something that could have been predicted, there was anecdotal evidence of it affecting the older age group in Italy but it was put down to their older average age and having a bigger old age population.
I'm pretty much there with you on the third point but the cases need to be lower. I've found the stats on hospital admissions with covid, there are still over 400 admissions a day in the UK, it is still out there and the main reason for that is there wasn't an early lockdown when being called for - see 1st point.
|