Seals version of the Slav song
#61
(10-08-2019, 12:54 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: I did have a giggle at this.......

https://twitter.com/CalScriven/status/11...5100916738


Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#62
(10-07-2019, 10:38 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: They aren't noted as being a racist club, but I now understand the reasons for the upset 

 I hope it is just a stupid mistake rather than a racist undercurrent

They used to be one of the 'premier' clubs for racism in the 70's. The VillaYouth were borderline synonymous with the NF. A lot of it may have been as a reaction to us and the black players and Bham and the zulus.

As it happens, I genuinely believe the argument that a lot of racial comments aren't deliberately racist, just an ignorance of the historical and social context of the comments - which is understandable if you've never been in that position - and therefore why it would upset people. This is then exacerbated by people refusing to change their wording, citing 'political correctness gone mad'. I read it a lot on this site.

But you would have to be ignorant to a monumental scale to try and rhyme 'rasta' with 'master' and not understand why it would cause problems.

For these boys, it's a conundrum. The only way they can deny they're racist is by admitting they're earth-shatteringly stupid. It's a tough decision to make.
Reply
#63
That part about the villa youth being racist is complete bullshit ......I know 99% of the lads who were in that group as I was in the same area and still are mates to this day ........never in a million years have they ever been racist .
Reply
#64
(10-08-2019, 07:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-07-2019, 10:38 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: They aren't noted as being a racist club, but I now understand the reasons for the upset 

 I hope it is just a stupid mistake rather than a racist undercurrent

They used to be one of the 'premier' clubs for racism in the 70's. The VillaYouth were borderline synonymous with the NF. A lot of it may have been as a reaction to us and the black players and Bham and the zulus.

As it happens, I genuinely believe the argument that a lot of racial comments aren't deliberately racist, just an ignorance of the historical and social context of the comments - which is understandable if you've never been in that position - and therefore why it would upset people. This is then exacerbated by people refusing to change their wording, citing 'political correctness gone mad'. I read it a lot on this site.

But you would have to be ignorant to a monumental scale to try and rhyme 'rasta' with 'master' and not understand why it would cause problems.

For these boys, it's a conundrum. The only way they can deny they're racist is by admitting they're earth-shatteringly stupid. It's a tough decision to make.

And yet there most well known hooligan of that era was black.
Reply
#65
(10-08-2019, 07:33 AM)The liquidator Wrote: That part about the villa youth being racist is complete bullshit ......I know 99% of the lads who were in that group as I was in the same area and still are mates to this day ........never in a million years have they ever been racist .

Strange. Me and my friends got chased around Birmingham Bull ring. One of them got his skull fractured, I got two broken ribs and the other got pissed on and humiliated in the most sickening way possible. All the while, amongst other things they were chanting "villa youth" and one had NF VY on his knuckles. The hand my friend was made to kiss.

But hey, you know best.

Perhaps you would like to show me photos of your friends? I could put your mind at ease and tell you it wasn't them?
Reply
#66
(10-08-2019, 07:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-07-2019, 10:38 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: They aren't noted as being a racist club, but I now understand the reasons for the upset 

 I hope it is just a stupid mistake rather than a racist undercurrent

They used to be one of the 'premier' clubs for racism in the 70's. The VillaYouth were borderline synonymous with the NF. A lot of it may have been as a reaction to us and the black players and Bham and the zulus.

As it happens, I genuinely believe the argument that a lot of racial comments aren't deliberately racist, just an ignorance of the historical and social context of the comments - which is understandable if you've never been in that position - and therefore why it would upset people. This is then exacerbated by people refusing to change their wording, citing 'political correctness gone mad'. I read it a lot on this site.

But you would have to be ignorant to a monumental scale to try and rhyme 'rasta' with 'master' and not understand why it would cause problems.

For these boys, it's a conundrum. The only way they can deny they're racist is by admitting they're earth-shatteringly stupid. It's a tough decision to make.

I'm of the opinion that much stuff quoted as "racism" is an overreaction, Fuzz. I don't want to open that can of worms on here, but I totally accept that the "master" thing is very racist. It went over my head though, so I'm wondering how many other people sat in the crowd this happened to? 

Most people join in chants that contravene public order offences, is this just another case of people following like sheep? That isn't to condone it, but to try and understand it. I haven't seen Villa since the play-offs, and I haven't sung this song, but I could equally imagine being sucked into it whilst trying to support my team.
Reply
#67
(10-08-2019, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: And yet there most well known hooligan of that era was black.

He (Danny?) was indeed. He used to drink in the bar under the rotunda. It was something a lot of people couldn't understand. He was known more for his fighting rather than his brains.

(10-08-2019, 08:01 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm of the opinion that much stuff quoted as "racism" is an overreaction, Fuzz. I don't want to open that can of worms on here, but I totally accept that the "master" thing is very racist. It went over my head though, so I'm wondering how many other people sat in the crowd this happened to? 

Most people join in chants that contravene public order offences, is this just another case of people following like sheep? That isn't to condone it, but to try and understand it. I haven't seen Villa since the play-offs, and I haven't sung this song, but I could equally imagine being sucked into it whilst trying to support my team.

I agree completely with you. The difference with you, is once you read and understood the issue you no longer condoned it and would not sing it. A lot of people don't go that far and just refuse to try and understand and carry on singing it as if it's 'their right' to sing what they want and its just people being politically incorrect and manufacturing hurt. 
But, as with most things, there is a kernel of truth in all viewpoints. Unfortunately, a lot of people do look to be offended which just completes the circle.

The other thing I've noticed recently is a genuine belief that people will call something racist even though it's not. For instance, your comment about astle being black (paraphrasing). That's obviously not racist, but there seems to be a sneering comment that "oh somebody will call that racist" when in fact, they don't. To me that only causes trouble because reasonable minded people then feel that much of the concern about racism is overblown, when in fact nobody actually said anything. Then when something actually racist happens it gets dismissed with "here we go again". It's like the story of the shepherd and the wolf, only this time the wolf, not the shepherd keeps shouting 'wolf' so the villagers ignore it when he finally appears.
Reply
#68
(10-07-2019, 10:08 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm hoping it's intended to mean 'master and apprentice', rather than anything sinister. 

The problem with that interpretation is Nakamba is older than McGinn.
Reply
#69
re. Villa youth not being racist

I thought on reflection maybe my own personal experience had coloured my recollection.

So I did a bit of digging on the internet.

https://books.google.fr/books?id=5OBmDwA...22&f=false

https://books.google.fr/books?id=5OBmDwA...22&f=false

It seems I wasn't the only one who thought they were racist.

I'm not sure how true their general 'recollections' are given the topic of the books, but it would seem a pointless throwaway line to be made up in BOTH books. This coupled with my own experiences and recollections mean I'm comfortable to stand by what I said.

Perhaps, 30/40 years on, your friends are no longer the people they once were and no longer want to be associated with their behaviour when they were young?
Reply
#70
(10-08-2019, 08:02 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-08-2019, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: And yet there most well known hooligan of that era was black.

He (Danny?) was indeed. He used to drink in the bar under the rotunda. It was something a lot of people couldn't understand. He was known more for his fighting rather than his brains.

(10-08-2019, 08:01 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm of the opinion that much stuff quoted as "racism" is an overreaction, Fuzz. I don't want to open that can of worms on here, but I totally accept that the "master" thing is very racist. It went over my head though, so I'm wondering how many other people sat in the crowd this happened to? 

Most people join in chants that contravene public order offences, is this just another case of people following like sheep? That isn't to condone it, but to try and understand it. I haven't seen Villa since the play-offs, and I haven't sung this song, but I could equally imagine being sucked into it whilst trying to support my team.

I agree completely with you. The difference with you, is once you read and understood the issue you no longer condoned it and would not sing it. A lot of people don't go that far and just refuse to try and understand and carry on singing it as if it's 'their right' to sing what they want and its just people being politically incorrect and manufacturing hurt. 
But, as with most things, there is a kernel of truth in all viewpoints. Unfortunately, a lot of people do look to be offended which just completes the circle.

The other thing I've noticed recently is a genuine belief that people will call something racist even though it's not. For instance, your comment about astle being black (paraphrasing). That's obviously not racist, but there seems to be a sneering comment that "oh somebody will call that racist" when in fact, they don't. To me that only causes trouble because reasonable minded people then feel that much of the concern about racism is overblown, when in fact nobody actually said anything. Then when something actually racist happens it gets dismissed with "here we go again". It's like the story of the shepherd and the wolf, only this time the wolf, not the shepherd keeps shouting 'wolf' so the villagers ignore it when he finally appears.

That's all fair, Fuzz.

The trouble is that you have extremists on either side, so the middle ground tends to be ignored.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: