Taxing Times for Labour
#61
(09-12-2026, 08:04 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-12-2026, 07:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I understand what you are saying in your patronising way. I’m just saying that not every human behaviour and choice is down to taxation. If you don’t think that you are brainwashed look at the phraseology you use when describing something you agree with compared with something you don’t.

That isn't just what you were saying B1, you stated if they reduced the tax rate for these HNWs then everyone else would have to pay more. Which is patently not true if the reduction has the desired effect of attracting more of them (the premise). It's why debates on here always crumble into pettiness. There's very little good faith.

No it isn’t I was making a direct comparison with Proth’s original statement and showing how one-eyed it was. Can someone enlighten me with the period when we had this influx of HNW individuals that made the difference to our tax receipts?
Reply
#62
(09-12-2026, 11:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-12-2026, 08:04 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-12-2026, 07:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I understand what you are saying in your patronising way. I’m just saying that not every human behaviour and choice is down to taxation. If you don’t think that you are brainwashed look at the phraseology you use when describing something you agree with compared with something you don’t.

That isn't just what you were saying B1, you stated if they reduced the tax rate for these HNWs then everyone else would have to pay more. Which is patently not true if the reduction has the desired effect of attracting more of them (the premise). It's why debates on here always crumble into pettiness. There's very little good faith.

No it isn’t I was making a direct comparison with Proth’s original statement and showing how one-eyed it was. Can someone enlighten me with the period when we had this influx of HNW individuals that made the difference to our tax receipts?

Every human decision is in some way an opportunity cost decision. Every single one. Most are pretty rational too, and you don't get much more rational than the preservation of income and capital.

The Golden Age of HNWs coming to the UK began with financial deregulation under Dear Margaret and peaked in 2013 with 113,000 Non Doms. Labour knew which side its bread was buttered between 1997-2010 and even St Gordon left the remittance basis of taxation alone until 2008. 

Philip Hammond was responsible for beginning the real exodus in 2017 when he tried to shoot Labour's fox with the "Deemed Domicile" rule. He's also the cnut that introduced the worst aspects of IR35.

The Non-dom population instantly fell (heavily) as did the former UK portion of tax receipts from those HNWs. Given that the average direct income tax payment by the remaining 80,000 non doms was about £150,000 each in 2024 Hammonds change represented a loss of conservatively £4.5bn - £5bn per annum. Reeves abolished Non Dom status completely in her first Budget. Just that pre-Reeves £4.5 - £5bn loss would pay for the increase in the defence Budget, let alone the loss since. Someone should tell John Healey.

The fastest way for the UK to reverse this situation would be to scrap Stamp Duty on UK share purchases (likely to increase GDP by £4.47 for every £1.00 foregone), scrap CGT and scrap Inheritance Tax. Singapore, or even just New Zealand on Thames if you like.
Reply
#63
Scrapping CGT is fucking stupid, scrapping IHT entrenches wealth
Reply
#64
IHT remains an entirely avoidable tax. Those that get caught are usually those with the least wealth over the threshold. LVT on the other hand...

Why is scrapping CGT "fucking stupid"? The most "fucking stupid" thing ever was ending indexation. Most houses that sell these days are worth far less in real terms than they were 5 or 10 years ago, so there's zero Capital Gain. Many other assets have hardly moved in real terms either.

If you're happy for the government to spunk your cash when inflation has already eaten the "gain" then be my guest. Me? I'm a little more circumspect about that.
Reply
#65
You know full well I support reintroducing inflation allowances for Capital Gains. Scrapping it outright creates perverse incentives for income arrangements compared with labour and advantages rentiers which is economically idiotic and fundamentally illiberal, neither Switzerland nor Singapore have scrapped CGT in it's entirety for that reason even with their extremely generous capital markets. It is fucking stupid.

And scrapping IHT entrenches wealth, I would just shift the burden away from the estate to the recipient which in-turn means the only way to avoid it would be to use the assets while alive which is more beneficial to the economy and the Exchequer anyway.
Reply
#66
Anyone know why a newspaper owned by the Fourth Lord Rothermere, who inherited a fortune from the Third Lord Rothermere, who inherited his money from the Second Lord Rothermere, who inherited it from the First Lord Rothermere, is so strongly opposed to inheritance tax?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)