Rachel Thieves?
#61
(11-07-2025, 03:54 PM)Fido Wrote:
(11-07-2025, 03:41 PM)Rowie60 Wrote: The money guy on tv, Martin Lewis commented not long back that every political party who wants to be in government say exactly the same thing. "They intend to have no new taxes or tax increases".  Purely to get elected and that in the real world isn't sustainable if we want to keep decent services, education system and NHS, etc.
If we do see an increase in tax and there's no cuts in essential services and even an improvement in all that most want and need, I for one will happily pay extra tax.

A lot people are prepared to pay a little more if it means improvement on services, health, well-being etc. If it gets pissed away, which is currently the case, then those numbers dwindle to nothing. I'd love to see, for example, to see what kinds of inroads Streeting and co have made in terms of procurement savings in the NHS, for example.

I agree Fido. It's bit of a poisoned chalice for government at the moment. The benefit system, the NHS amongst other things are a mess and trying to sort those out, as the present government have found with the benefit system, you end up having to face unpopular decisions.
Reply
#62
Here’s the reality beyond the spreadsheets…

Employers don’t want to employ people who are disabled.
Employers can’t or won’t make working adjustments to enable them to employ many people who are disabled.
Employers are not properly helped by the government to make those adjustments.
The last Tory government shutdown state supported companies.
The disabled still need to eat, have heating, water, housing and care.
PIP isn’t an out of work benefit, it’s money to help the disabled live a decent life by recognising that it costs more money to live than compared to their non disabled counterparts.
Many disabled people need adapted cars and vans to get to jobs, school, heck even nice places others take for granted (I know that makes Tories, Reform xxxxs and Blue Labourshites angry at the temerity of them wanting such things.

The unpopular decisions are easy to make on paper but the above is the reality. Take away that support to the tune of £5-8bn but what do you suggest are the solutions to the above? Workhouse? A life of poverty and misery? Might cheer a few ableist up I suppose.

Personally I think we need to look at why young people are opting out of work, getting people off the sick list. I’m not adverse to means testing those who say it’s anxiety, ADHD etc but the idea you can just cut without understanding the reasons and consequences are not grown ups, they are just trying to solve complicated problems with simple solutions… almost populist in mindset from the centrist dads.
Reply
#63
Labour should’ve been honest and done it from the start. I’ve no issue with it.

Prothtits was right when he said a fair while back such things were inevitable
Raw Sausage
Reply
#64
What is means testing going to do? Are you saying that anyone who is disabled and has money should be treated differently to those without. PIP is to help the person with their needs. They tried to introduce a more targeted test and it was thrown out because it wasn't seen as fair when in fact it was the fairest method of all and far fairer than means testing.

Do you want me to repeat the same question here that you've ignored 4 or 5 times.
Reply
#65
I do find it interesting how many centrist dads are so comfortable othering, suggesting loads of them are defrauding the system, being a burden to the state etc and yet if I equated the same language to immigration particular those housed in hotels and HMOs there would be cries of racism… I see very little difference other than Centrist Dads are entirely comfortable with one and not the other.
Reply
#66
(11-07-2025, 05:18 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Labour should’ve been honest and done it from the start. I’ve no issue with it.

Prothtits was right when he said a fair while back such things were inevitable

Everything is broken. Local councils starved of government money, police cuts,  prisons overflowing, the NHS, funding for schools, roads full of potholes, numerous compensation claims- ignored for years,  a huge shortage of housing, hundreds of thousands entering the country illegally, you name it. Then Covid giveaways, Brexit costs,  energy subsidising. Anyone and everyone could see these things but now the day of reckoning arrives and people are surprised? I agree Labour maybe should have said they need to increase taxes before the election. But last time they said that they went from odds on and miles ahead in the polls to 2nd place. If you want a better society, it needs funding. Of course, as Ted Maul pointed out yesterday,  look at the money that can be found by the wealthy to subvert democracy.  Labour could try and tax those that get richer by each minute.
Reply
#67
Agree with every word TJ, and yes the fact that no one wants to tell the electorate the truth is at least as much a societal responsibility as a political party one

And yes, our structures are absolutely bollocksed
Raw Sausage
Reply
#68
Who's 'othering' here - a system was proposed that would assess people properly, not the half hearted tick box exercise we have now which has seen a growth in benefit spend way beyond any other period and not in line with equivalent economies, but that was seen as too tough when in fact it protects the very people you are trying to help, people in genuine need for support.

Othering - fuck me. I'll dig the question out shall I
Reply
#69
(11-07-2025, 05:19 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What is means testing going to do? Are you saying that anyone who is disabled and has money should be treated differently to those without. PIP is to help the person with their needs. They tried to introduce a more targeted test and it was thrown out because it wasn't seen as fair when in fact it was the fairest method of all and far fairer than means testing.

Do you want me to repeat the same question here that you've ignored 4 or 5 times.

No PIP should not be means tested in terms of money, just need. I never said it shouldn’t. 

I do wish you’d stop pretending that the previous failed cuts were well thought out reforms. No consultation with experts, charities or erm disabled people. How are you supposed to get a workable and fair system when you make up the policy on the back of a fag packet, because Reeves has hobbled the economy further by her own policies and boxed herself in with her ‘fiscal rules’. 

B1 stop playing the hard man it’s not really working, you’re about as intimidating as jelly on a radiator.
Reply
#70
You do understand what 'means tested' is don't you? It's is testing your finances to see if you've got the means to support yourself instead of the state supporting you with benefits etc.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: